S006: retained result to original source and back

Corrected finite closeout · four paths Exercised · broader qualification unfinished

Current progress · Work and evidence · Exact start/progress history

S006 completed its finite named-result/original-source/inspect/reopen increment on a distinct accurately scoped Work/Plan. The earlier completion on the broader semantic Work was an administrative error and is explicitly superseded; the same unchanged broader Work now has a not_completed review. Seven component completions stand. Four bounded existing-actor paths remain Exercised, not automatically Qualified. Assisted CLI, temporary MCP/operator and process limits are retained.

This closeout and progress share fixed native cutoff 4986, recorded 8 October 2026 at 11:38:37 UTC / 05:38 MDT. S005 finite guidance remains Qualified/completed, S004 remains not completed and all sixteen full Version 1 outcomes remain incomplete. No replacement sprint is selected. Exact published start4900 and progress4976 remain history.

Selected result and maturity

The selected outcome is unchanged: use a meaningful named retained result to read its exact original source through actual semantic assessment, receive useful ordinary output, deliberately inspect unchanged references and reopen the same result/action. Actual owner permissions remain authoritative; a separately labeled current observation never substitutes for the captured original.

Exercised means a bounded ordinary journey with relevant recovery was demonstrated. Readiness, source tests, publication/staging, installation, runtime and independent qualification are distinct. This finite closeout does not automatically promote the four paths to Qualified.

Public source and actual availability

The read-only semantic-assessment.assessment.check query assesses supplied operation, whole schema closure and captured request; it does not fetch Content or execute effects. The helper associates /fields/source with content and dispatches content.note.read only from the complete ready exact-original preview. Exact carried references remain behind deliberate inspection, with authored text unchanged.

Actual Content output includes the full 876-character original, title and six-field reference. Complete owner result/input equal the independent exact read. A first order-sensitive JSON-string comparison was corrected to canonical field comparison without changing results. Both environments reopened without reseeding and preserved the whole observation, including actual owner result rather than a reconstructed preview.

Actual interface use and assisted fresh trial

The matched operator opened the full source viewport and returned to the same named result/retained observation, exit 0. Two opening keys overlapped asynchronous menu loading; an additional explicit open displayed the source. The complete text fit at 80×24, so Home/End produced no movement. This does not qualify long-note scrolling.

A temporary staged MCP server returned the same complete source. Public default output contains state/title/text/observation/actions; explicit JSON and transport inspection preserve exact owner input/result and report. This is real-data transport evidence, not an independent unfamiliar MCP trial or an update to the running harness connector.

A fresh Sol/high worker completed CLI source/inspection/reopen/return, with initial and returning output byte-identical. One parent clarification mapped the actor ID to its friendly name; the participant independently checked scope, without a profile switch. Aspen compared the saved receipts without rerunning the helper. Aspen’s later bounded packet judgment confirms selected counts/refusal; wider qualification remains separate.

The participant reported 18 shell submissions / 13 Sidecat commands / 5 helper calls: nine startup/discovery, three initial task use, three returning submissions and three evidence setup/writes; zero failed shell submissions or retries. Returning use is not a two-call result. The first precise timestamp is missing and first saved stdout was reconstructed from immediately read bootstrap files; later outputs are actual tool returns. Nested host/Content calls were not measured by this participant. Fresh worker context used an existing actor, not fresh enrollment or human identity.

Separate measured business calls

A delegating tracer invoked the original native callable and retained its actual response; it manufactured no assessment or owner result. These measurements are separate from the fresh participant’s 18-submission trial.

The source/count trace captured 29 CLI submissions: 26 exit 0 and three preparation/control failures. It separately reports five helper calls, seven helper-observation calls, 22 measured logger calls plus three control logger calls, 11 log reads and one normal preparatory Content read. Logger/observation overhead is not user/business call count. Individual logger reply bodies/keys are absent, so this is not a daemon-audit claim. Setup/control failures remain failures, not product passes.

Negative and real refusal evidence

Four actual helper actions each made one assessment and zero Content calls, returning public aggregate incomplete/action unavailable:

• Missing source member: found false, blocked, incomplete preview.
• Invalid digest against the unchanged captured live schema: incompatible exact-pattern cause.
• Unsupported unevaluatedProperties: unknown with reason preserved, using a changed synthetic declaration supplement.
• Overlapping oneOf: ambiguous input contract with both branches compatible, using a changed synthetic declaration supplement.

Supplied synthetic values/declarations are labeled; the installed host and schema were unchanged. No mock assessment report supplies these results.

A separate raw installed-host competing-value control returned two compatible suggested connections, selected neither, with empty arguments/incomplete preview and blocked unresolved Content. It did not produce a reachable two-ready-candidate helper case or an ambiguous-helper qualification. That helper case remains unreachable and unqualified.

The genuine native refusal used a separate legitimate private fixture without granting the attempting actor access. Exactly one assessment and one Content attempt returned permission_denied / note_access_denied. Public refused/unavailable state and full original owner error/exact input were retained unchanged through cold inspection; carried and cold inspection made zero new assessment/Content calls. There was no retry or fallback. Early capture/setup failures remain disclosed. Private fixture values/references are excluded here.

This is an actual one-read owner refusal, not pre-dispatch permission detection. The pre-dispatch permission API is absent. Pre-dispatch missing/competing/unsupported non-success has zero Content reads; the refusal follows exactly one attempted authorized owning Content read. Native owner authority remains intact.

Corrected disposition and immutable error history

Aspen’s 4978 independent review confirms the selected source/negative/refusal/count packets without rerunning actions or reading the private refusal fixture. Rowan’s 4986 correction completes a distinct, accurately titled finite Work/Plan at 11:38:34 UTC and replaces the mismatched S006 board main. The seven accurately scoped component completions stand.

The broader semantic-resolution Work retains its exact original definition and has a separate review occurrence judged not_completed at 11:38:28 UTC. Its earlier 11:33 completion was an administrative error; that immutable record and affected original closeout wording are explicitly superseded, not erased or treated as proof. General unfamiliar vocabulary/context resolution and prerequisite composition remain unfinished. This is scope reconciliation of the existing sprint, not a new implementation, replacement sprint or release gate.

The finite increment used explicit member binding and structural contract assessment; that is not general semantic command resolution. Rowan retains the broader obligation and future selection; Linden retains future maintained-package adoption and reachable consumer refinements; Aspen retains independent MCP/operator/human and wider qualification; Cedar retains future matched activation/connector delivery when selected.

Delivery-record process defect

Cedar’s delivery occurrence has a completed judgment but planned activity and no own progress Note. After judgment, the ordinary progress operation no longer applies. Cedar retained the actual publication/build/install/site receipts separately in native 4984 and made no synthetic progress update or new occurrence. This is a disclosed recording defect; completed delivery is not repeated to repair it.

The separate native scope error shows why the pinned Work purpose must match the selected result before judging its occurrence. Future participant capture begins before call1 and the ordinary entry includes the legitimate actor-directory mapping. Original assisted narratives, failed controls and logger overhead remain preserved; these process improvements add no custody/startup gate.

Additional inspection and verified prior reporting

A later bounded own-context cached operator inspection displayed all six retained owner-input/result source fields and returned to ordinary content without a new source action. Nested counts were unmeasured. It is cached retained-result inspection, not separate full-Note technical viewport, long-note or independent operator qualification.

The prior public progress at source937d66c5 / cutoff4976 was checked once remotely, 20/20 tests passed, published natively and independently served-byte/pipeline verified. Complete status/source/plan and history downloads matched; the pipeline succeeded. HTML availability/byte checks do not establish browser rendering or product qualification. That earlier snapshot’s pending judgment remains accurate for its fixed cutoff and is preserved unchanged.

Carried qualification and earlier history

The four S006 paths remain Exercised. Maintained-package installation, running-harness connector delivery, a reachable two-ready-candidate ordinary helper choice and pre-dispatch permission API remain unfinished. Independent GUI/MCP participant acceptance, human/fresh enrollment, long-note behavior and full release qualification are not implied.

S005’s finite guidance-use boundary remains Qualified and completed under existing-actor limits. Its complete history retains 34/68 calls, first 22 reader calls transcribed, README 403/local fallback, UI setup assists and beginning/PageDown/end coverage, administrative pre-charter sequence and actual attention activation. Eight cards are explanations, not capabilities.

S004 remains not completed, with original unfinished owner scope preserved. All sixteen full Version 1 outcomes remain incomplete. Jev and a next sprint remain unselected. Broader unfinished obligations retain their owners and are not silently dropped by the finite closeout.

Fixed source boundary and exact history

Current bounded source metadata · Current snapshot · Unchanged progress4976 snapshot · Progress4976 plan · Progress4976 source metadata

Unchanged S006 start snapshot · Original S006 plan · Original S006 source metadata · Earlier completed/unfinished history

This projection reads the full correction4986 and exact returned finite/broad/error owner receipts, with current corrected board and completed integration/delivery occurrences. Later owner and updated-reference reads are separately timestamped supplemental observations, not an atomic event fence. Original erroneous records remain private-source history and are summarized here without their real references. Published4976/start4900 and earlier S005/S004/S003/agreement bytes remain unchanged.