{ "schema": "sidecat.rearchitecture.dashboard.v1", "refresh_minutes": 15, "checked_at": "2026-10-08T11:45:32.492856Z", "source_updated_at": "2026-10-08T11:38:37.058510407Z", "summary": "S006’s finite named-result/source-action increment is completed on its own accurately scoped Work/Plan. A worker read the full original source, inspected exact retained details and returned after reopening; four bounded existing-actor paths remain Exercised. The earlier completion on the broader semantic Work was an administrative error and is superseded; the same unchanged broader Work now has a not_completed review. Seven component completions stand. Assisted CLI, temporary MCP/operator limits and Cedar’s missing occurrence progress record remain disclosed. S005 finite guidance stays Qualified/completed, S004 is not completed and all sixteen full Version 1 outcomes remain incomplete.", "scope_note": "Corrected finite S006 closeout, not general semantic-resolution or Version 1 qualification. The accurately scoped finite Work/Plan is completed; broad vocabulary/context resolution and prerequisite composition are not_completed on the same unchanged Work. Immutable erroneous history is retained and explicitly superseded. No replacement sprint is selected. Start4900/progress4976 and all earlier history/agreement bytes remain preserved.", "working_scope": "Installed/runtime evidence, Aspen’s bounded packet review and Rowan’s corrected finite disposition support the selected closeout. Four existing-actor paths remain Exercised; completion does not automatically promote them to Qualified. Source/staging/install, actual use and broader release qualification remain distinct.", "working": [ "Presentation c2f0ab27 and UI 6b567afa are published and matched-staged; engine 6460491f is published. Host 23676ba1 passed its focused source run, was built, installed and activated on the existing Team node. Helper a9110345 is published and used through legitimate native kept adoption; maintained-package installation is not claimed.", "An actual named source action assessed the full owning alternative contract, selected the exact-content branch and returned all 876 source characters. The exact six-field input and actual owner result equal the independent exact owner read. Both named environments reopened without reseeding and retained the complete carried observation.", "Actual matched operator use displayed the complete source viewport and Back returned to the same named result/observation. All 876 characters fit at 80×24; this provides no long-note scrolling qualification. Initial menu loading overlapped two opening keys before an additional explicit open.", "A temporary staged MCP server returned the same complete source in public default output; deliberate JSON/transport inspection retained the exact input/result and report. This is actual-data transport use, not independent unfamiliar MCP acceptance or deployment of the running harness connector.", "A fresh Sol/high worker completed an assisted CLI read/inspect/reopen/return sample. One clarification mapped the actor ID to its friendly name; the worker independently checked scope. Eighteen shell submissions comprised thirteen Sidecat commands and five helper calls; returning use took three submissions. First precise timestamp is missing and first stdout was reconstructed. Its nested business-call counts were not measured.", "A separate delegating trace measured explicit and returning actions at one assessment/one Content call each; name-only, carried and cold inspection made zero/zero. Four pre-dispatch helper negatives made one assessment/zero Content each. Changed synthetic declarations are supplements, not installed schema changes.", "A genuine native owner refusal followed exactly one assessment and one Content attempt. It retained permission_denied/note_access_denied and the exact error/input after cold reopen, with no retry/fallback. Pre-dispatch permission knowledge remains unimplemented. Raw host two-suggestion controls selected neither value and were blocked; the two-ready-candidate helper case is unreachable and unqualified.", "Aspen independently checked the returned negative/refusal/count packets, preserving the assisted CLI judgment and all coverage/capture limits. Rowan then reconciled the main selection: the finite increment has a distinct correctly scoped completed Work/Plan; a same-Work broad review is not_completed. The earlier broad completion is a superseded administrative error, not proof of that requirement.", "Seven accurately scoped component completions stand. Cedar’s delivery occurrence has a completed judgment but still shows planned activity and no own progress Note; its actual receipts are separately retained. This is a process recording defect, not fabricated progress or a reason to repeat delivery.", "Cached operator inspection additionally displayed all six retained owner-input/result source fields and returned to ordinary content without a new source action. This is existing-actor cached inspection, not separate full-Note technical viewport, long-note or independent operator qualification." ], "acceptance": [ { "title": "S006: read a named retained result's original source and return", "state": "passed", "detail": "Rowan completed the accurately scoped finite named-result/original-source/inspect/reopen Work/Plan after the assisted CLI sample and Aspen’s bounded source/negative/refusal/count review. Four paths remain Exercised. The broader semantic Work is explicitly not_completed, and its earlier erroneous completion is superseded. Capture, assistance, synthetic/coverage and delivery limits are retained; full Version 1 is not qualified." }, { "title": "Full Version 1", "state": "pending", "detail": "All sixteen full Version 1 outcomes remain incomplete. S005 guidance/adoption evidence will not complete their full release boundaries." }, { "title": "V1-01: Organizational context", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Fresh workers still need manual orientation; effective scoped semantic inheritance is not established." }, { "title": "V1-02: Identity, authority and resources", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Josh's own usable participation; reachable scoped workers; full remote allowance/delegation outcome remains incomplete." }, { "title": "V1-03: Records and source references", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Reader-grant plumbing is exposed and has caused denied contribution reads; full area qualification incomplete." }, { "title": "V1-04: Work and planning", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Current task discovery remains cumbersome; native project and application planning views are not yet one usable path." }, { "title": "V1-05: Collective messaging", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Human entry, ordinary reply/thread/attention/return experience incomplete." }, { "title": "V1-06: Lisp and composition", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Broader fresh-agent task continuation and interface usability incomplete." }, { "title": "V1-07: Marketplace and packages", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Complete ordinary public/internal lifecycle and pending-work replacement not qualified." }, { "title": "V1-08: Semantic definitions and discovery", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. A usable namespaced vocabulary, mappings and domain-record authoring journey is not established. Operation search alone is not a complete source inventory." }, { "title": "V1-09: Executable procedures", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. General durable waits, decisions and continuation across harness replacement not qualified." }, { "title": "V1-10: Managed agent work", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Role/assignment is not proof of execution readiness. Automatic cross-harness return/context/attribution still incomplete." }, { "title": "V1-11: Controlled execution", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Rowan's named native execution route returned unavailable; broad controlled local/remote outcome incomplete." }, { "title": "V1-12: Shared bus and federation", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Full independently administered-node journey and durable gap/recovery behavior remain incomplete." }, { "title": "V1-13: Feedback and improvement", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Closed improvement loops and comparable task cost evidence are incomplete." }, { "title": "V1-14: Usable interfaces and integrations", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Actual help failed readability; unfamiliar task completion and required tracker synchronization not qualified." }, { "title": "V1-15: Operational durability and scale", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Full backup/recovery, multi-node concurrency and target-scale evidence not established here." }, { "title": "V1-16: Sidecat UI", "state": "pending", "detail": "Incomplete. Own-identity room participation and integrated human decisions/return remain incomplete." } ], "work": [ { "title": "S006: read a named retained result's original source and return", "owner": "Rowan finite-scope judgment; Linden helper; affected authors; Juniper integration/reporting; Aspen independent QA; Cedar delivery", "state": "delivered", "detail": "The accurately scoped finite Work/Plan is completed at 11:38:34 UTC. Actual full-source/inspection/reopen, assisted CLI, bounded operator/MCP and reviewed negative/refusal/count evidence support this increment. Four paths remain Exercised.", "next": "Preserve the accepted finite evidence and disclosed limits; wider qualification remains unfinished and is selected only through ordinary refinement." }, { "title": "Broader semantic resolution and prerequisite composition", "owner": "Rowan broader Work and future selection", "state": "planned", "detail": "The same unchanged broader Work has a separate review occurrence judged not_completed at 11:38:28 UTC. Its earlier 11:33 completion was an administrative error, explicitly superseded and retained as immutable history. The corrected finite occurrence replaces the mismatched board main.", "next": "Retain the general unfamiliar vocabulary/context/prerequisite task for deliberate future selection. No new sprint is selected by this correction." }, { "title": "Seven component completions and exact delivery", "owner": "Linden; Rowan affected presentation/engine/operator/host authors; Juniper; Aspen; Cedar", "state": "delivered", "detail": "The seven accurately scoped component completions stand. Published sources, matched staging, active installed host and legitimate native kept helper adoption remain unchanged; maintained-package/connector delivery is not inferred.", "next": "Retain source/runtime/acceptance distinctions and original source custody. Further activation/connector delivery remains unselected future owner scope." }, { "title": "Delivery occurrence progress-record defect", "owner": "Cedar delivery receipts; Rowan occurrence judgment; Juniper public disclosure", "state": "review", "detail": "Cedar’s occurrence is judged completed but its activity remains planned with no progress update Note. Once judged, the ordinary progress operation no longer applies. Actual source/build/install/site receipts are separately recorded at cutoff; no synthetic progress was written.", "next": "Keep the defect and separate receipts visible. Future occurrences should record actual progress before judgment; do not rerun completed delivery to repair a reporting field." }, { "title": "Corrected closeout reporting and preserved history", "owner": "Juniper static reporting support; Cedar bounded check/native publication", "state": "review", "detail": "Public plan/progress/source data share fixed cutoff4986. Exact published start4900/progress4976 and S005/S004/S003/agreement bytes are preserved.", "next": "Cedar checks/publishes the distinct frozen closeout source; Juniper verifies served bytes and pipeline. Reporting introduces no acceptance gate." } ], "focus": { "title": "S006 finite increment completed; broad semantic Work not completed", "status": "implemented", "detail": "The corrected finite Work/Plan is completed; seven component completions stand. Four bounded existing-actor paths remain Exercised. The earlier broad completion is superseded as an administrative error; the same unchanged broader Work is not_completed. No next sprint is selected." }, "phases": [ { "id": "s003", "title": "S003: disposed and closed", "state": "verified", "detail": "The previous sprint is closed. Its bounded accepted results remain available for reuse; unfinished work and all full Version 1 obligations are not declared complete. The earlier public snapshot remains a dated historical report.", "evidence": [ "Retained acquisition, keep/reopen and return evidence supports the selected continuation work." ], "next": [] }, { "id": "s004", "title": "S004: reviewed, not completed", "state": "needs-attention", "detail": "The main occurrence is judged not_completed after useful delivered slices. Human participation, remaining installed UI cases and complete retained continuation remain with their original owners. Reusable Work and other Plans are not universally closed.", "evidence": [ "Corrected caller delivery, one new send with same-client reopen and exact 2,355-character readback; independent current-candidate recipient read.", "Earlier substantive 3,568-character fresh continuation result and independent readership retained at their original candidate/scope.", "Bounded current UI reads and missing-executable first-entry/refresh diagnostics; source tests and matched delivery remain separate." ], "next": [ "Original Josh/Cedar human setup/use, Rowan/Aspen UI cases and Linden/Juniper continuation obligations remain unfinished.", "Juniper’s original unknown preparation, keys and Note are preserved without reset, replay, migration or copied-message substitute." ] }, { "id": "s005", "title": "S005: finite guidance-use completed", "state": "verified", "detail": "One selected guidance/adoption boundary is Qualified/completed after three actual samples and independent QA. Main occurrence is owner-judged completed; broader release/human/identity/UI boundaries are not accepted by this result.", "evidence": [ "Fresh read-only task with exact context/reopen and useful next action; different synthetic Records allocation and exact/current/stale-base behavior.", "Independent matched UI whole-GUIDE beginning/PageDown/end/return observation; exact source/install/binary parity.", "Independent finite QA and terminal owner readback, with 34/68 calls, README fallback, UI assistance/coverage and missed pre-charter sequence retained." ], "next": [ "Rowan’s next-outcome refinement remains unselected at cutoff 4831; existing S004/full-release obligations retain their owners." ] }, { "id": "s006", "title": "S006: corrected finite increment completed", "state": "implemented", "detail": "Named-result/original-source/inspect/reopen increment completed on an accurately scoped Work/Plan. Four paths remain Exercised. Broader semantic Work is not_completed; immutable erroneous completion is explicitly superseded.", "evidence": [ "Aspen independently reviewed the selected packets; actual original-source equality, retained reopen and bounded interface use stand with their disclosed limits.", "Native correction records finite completion at11:38:34 and same-Work broad review not_completed at11:38:28; seven component completions stand.", "Cedar’s missing occurrence progress record is disclosed with separate actual receipts." ], "next": [ "Retain broader semantic/release/interface/human qualification and owner scope for deliberate future selection; no replacement sprint selected." ] } ], "components": [ { "name": "Named retained result and reopen — Exercised", "state": "qualifying", "detail": "The actual named result, exact input and actual owner observation survived both environments reopening without reseeding. Existing actor scope; broader qualification remains unfinished." }, { "name": "Semantic original-source action — Exercised", "state": "qualifying", "detail": "The installed host assessed the full alternative schema; Content returned the complete 876-character original equal to an independent exact read. Measured negative/refusal evidence is returned; bounded packet judgment returned; broader qualification remains unfinished." }, { "name": "Ordinary CLI/MCP/Lisp output with deliberate inspection — Exercised", "state": "qualifying", "detail": "Staged CLI and temporary MCP public default showed useful complete text; deliberate inspection preserved exact references/report. Assisted fresh CLI counts/capture gaps and absence of independent MCP/harness deployment acceptance remain disclosed." }, { "name": "Operator shared action, full viewport, back and reopen — Exercised", "state": "qualifying", "detail": "Matched operator use displayed the whole short source and Back returned to the same named result/observation. This is existing-actor integration use; independent GUI and long-note qualification are not established." } ], "qualification": { "commit": "Presentation c2f0ab27 / UI 6b567afa / engine 6460491f / host 23676ba1 / helper a9110345; host installed, candidates staged, helper legitimately kept", "checks": [ { "name": "Source checks and matched delivery", "state": "passed", "detail": "Published source and real source-test/build receipts establish bounded implementation/delivery. Host focused run passed 8 top-level / 12 leaf cases; the host is active on the existing node. Helper publication does not establish maintained-package installation or participant qualification." }, { "name": "Actual original-source/input/result and reopen", "state": "passed", "detail": "Observed full 876-character original, exact six-field input and complete actual owner result equal independent exact read; both environments reopen without reseeding and preserve the entire carry. Scoped runtime evidence only." }, { "name": "Operator and temporary staged MCP runtime", "state": "passed", "detail": "Actual full short-source viewport/Back and public default/explicit inspection exercised in an existing actor context. No independent GUI/MCP participant, long-note scrolling or connected harness deployment acceptance." }, { "name": "Assisted fresh CLI sample and capture provenance", "state": "passed", "detail": "Aspen independently compared saved initial/returning source and inspection receipts. One actor-name mapping assist; 18 shell/13 Sidecat/5 helper, returning 3 submissions. First precise timestamp missing, first stdout reconstructed; participant nested calls unmeasured. This scoped receipt review is not blanket qualification." }, { "name": "Returned measured negative/refusal packets", "state": "passed", "detail": "Observed explicit actions 1 assessment/1 Content; inspections 0/0; four pre-dispatch negatives 1/0 each; actual one-read native refusal retained cold with no retry/fallback. Synthetic declaration supplements, raw-host blocked suggestions, unreachable helper case and tracer failures remain disclosed. Aspen independently checked these exact packets; broader qualification remains separate." }, { "name": "Bounded packet judgment and corrected finite disposition", "state": "passed", "detail": "Aspen’s independent4978 review confirms selected source/negative/refusal/count packets without rerunning actions. Rowan’s4986 correction completes a distinct finite Work/Plan; the same unchanged broader Work is not_completed and the erroneous historical completion is superseded. Four paths remain Exercised." }, { "name": "Broader qualification and process recording", "state": "pending", "detail": "General semantic vocabulary/prerequisite resolution, reachable two-ready helper choice, pre-dispatch permission API, maintained-package/connector delivery and independent GUI/MCP/human/long-note qualification remain unfinished. Cedar’s planned activity/no progress Note despite completed judgment is a disclosed process defect." }, { "name": "Full Version 1 and carried history", "state": "pending", "detail": "All sixteen full Version 1 outcomes remain incomplete. S005 finite guidance is Qualified/completed under existing-actor limits; S004 remains not_completed. Jev remains unselected." } ], "note": "Finite completion records the selected useful increment and bounded independent review. Four paths remain Exercised, not automatically Qualified. The broad Work’s not_completed review and superseded erroneous history prevent a general semantic/full release claim. Actual staged/native-kept delivery and assisted/capture/coverage/process limits remain visible." }, "recent": [ { "date": "2026-10-08T11:38:37.058510407Z", "title": "Corrected finite completion; broader Work not completed", "detail": "Distinct finite Work/Plan completed, same unchanged broad Work review not_completed, erroneous historical completion explicitly superseded. Seven component completions stand; no new sprint selected." }, { "date": "2026-10-08T11:36:44.097370641Z", "title": "Initial completion observed before scope correction", "detail": "Initial main/component completion observation retained; affected broad-main wording is superseded by the following correction." }, { "date": "2026-10-08T11:34:38.520459035Z", "title": "Completed delivery occurrence lacks its progress record", "detail": "Activity planned/no update; completed judgment prevents ordinary progress update. Actual delivery receipts retained separately." }, { "date": "2026-10-08T11:31:34.340895394Z", "title": "Broader Work mismatch identified for closeout", "detail": "The finite source-action proof does not complete the broader vocabulary/prerequisite Work; delivery progress record was missing." }, { "date": "2026-10-08T11:26:17.085882606Z", "title": "Independent served-byte verification and cached UI inspection", "detail": "Complete status/source/plan/history bytes and pipeline match; cached source-field inspection is scoped existing-actor evidence." } ], "pending": [ "All sixteen full Version 1 outcomes remain incomplete; the finite S006 increment does not qualify their full release scope.", "Broader semantic vocabulary/context resolution and prerequisite composition remain not_completed on the same unchanged Work; the earlier completion is a superseded administrative error.", "Maintained-package installation, running-harness connector delivery, reachable two-ready helper choice and pre-dispatch permission API remain unfinished.", "Independent GUI/MCP, human/fresh enrollment and long-note qualification remain open. Assisted CLI, capture gaps, synthetic supplements and logger/control failures stay disclosed.", "S005 finite guidance remains Qualified/completed; S004 remains not_completed with original unfinished owners. Jev and a replacement sprint remain unselected." ], "next": [ "Publish the separately checked corrected closeout and verify served bytes/pipeline while preserving exact start/progress history.", "Rowan refines future work from the unchanged broader not_completed obligation and remaining consumer/delivery/qualification scope; no next sprint is selected at this cutoff.", "Record actual progress before judging future occurrences, match the pinned Work purpose to the selected result, and retain original assisted narratives and failed controls." ], "source": { "label": "Native Sidecat corrected finite S006 completion, broader not_completed disposition and preserved evidence through 8 October 2026, 05:38 MDT", "url": "https://sidecat.dev/development/s006.html#targets" }, "cycle": { "id": "V1-S006", "outcome": "A permitted caller uses a meaningful named retained result to read its exact original source through actual semantic assessment, obtains useful ordinary output with deliberate inspection, and reopens the same result/action.", "stage": "The accurately scoped finite S006 Work/Plan is completed; seven component completions stand. Four existing-actor paths remain Exercised. The broader same-Work review is not_completed; its earlier completion is superseded as an administrative error. No replacement sprint is selected.", "recording": "Plan/progress/source projections share fixed native cutoff4986. The exact published start4900 and progress4976 status/source/plan bytes remain history. Original selection inputs/synthesis and earlier checkpoints are preserved. The erroneous11:33 broad completion and initial4985 wording are explicitly superseded by4986, not erased or treated as proof. Current corrected board/owner receipts and later updated references were read with separate timestamps; no atomic event fencing or invented clock.", "input_note": "Rowan’s native selection and assignment specify the finite useful result and affected owners; subsequent host/interface disposition and Aspen’s corrected charter refine that selected scope. This report does not reconstruct independent worker receipts.", "cutoff_sequence": 4986, "checkpoints": [ { "id": "CP1", "label": "Ready to commit sprint effort", "state": "admitted", "decision": "Rowan selected the finite useful-result journey and bounded parallel owner scopes.", "decided_at": "2026-10-08T07:12:20.148320307Z" }, { "id": "CP2", "label": "Ready to implement a shared change", "state": "pending", "decision": "No separate admission or terminal disposition is recorded through this fixed cutoff; selected work proceeds with its owning implementation and QA." }, { "id": "CP3", "label": "Ready to integrate", "state": "pending", "decision": "No separate admission or terminal disposition is recorded through this fixed cutoff; selected work proceeds with its owning implementation and QA." }, { "id": "CP4", "label": "Ready to release a candidate", "state": "pending", "decision": "No separate admission or terminal disposition is recorded through this fixed cutoff; selected work proceeds with its owning implementation and QA." }, { "id": "CP5", "label": "Ready to publish or cut over", "state": "pending", "decision": "No separate admission or terminal disposition is recorded through this fixed cutoff; selected work proceeds with its owning implementation and QA." }, { "id": "CP6", "label": "Sprint disposed", "state": "admitted", "decision": "Rowan’s scope correction completes the distinct finite Work/Plan and records the unchanged broader Work not_completed. Seven component completions stand; earlier erroneous broad completion is superseded. Four paths remain Exercised and full Version1 incomplete.", "decided_at": "2026-10-08T11:38:34.298361188Z", "decisions": [ { "outcome": "Accurately scoped finite S006 increment completed", "decided_at": "2026-10-08T11:38:34.298361188Z", "sequence": 4986 }, { "outcome": "Same unchanged broader semantic Work review not_completed", "decided_at": "2026-10-08T11:38:28.342152113Z", "sequence": 4986 } ] } ], "inputs": [ { "role": "S006 selection and development lead", "actor": "Rowan", "worker": "Lead selection; harness/model/effort not independently observed in this projection", "summary": "One finite retained-result/original-source/output/inspection/reopen journey; seven affected owner scopes, four integrated Foundation boundaries.", "at": "2026-10-08T07:12:20.148320307Z" }, { "role": "Independent corrected QA charter", "actor": "Aspen", "worker": "Independent QA; harness/model/effort not independently observed in this projection", "summary": "Exact-original equality, inspect/reopen and honest pre-dispatch failure/one-attempt owner-refusal criteria; no private fixture recipe or qualification from scratch/tests.", "at": "2026-10-08T08:28:48.73010619Z" } ], "synthesis": { "actor": "Rowan", "detail": "Reuse the Shape Engine, existing apphost Query and owning Content dispatch; preserve full contracts/branch alternatives and exact carried references. CLI/MCP/Lisp/operator share the same assessment/helper path.", "at": "2026-10-08T07:49:54.603028544Z" }, "history": [ { "title": "S006 useful-result journey selected", "detail": "One finite retained-result/original-source/output/inspect/reopen outcome; prior histories and unfinished release obligations remain.", "at": "2026-10-08T07:12:20.148320307Z", "sequence": 4855 }, { "title": "Parallel S006 owning assignments", "detail": "Caller/helper, presentation, engine, operator, integration, independent QA and delivery have bounded owner scopes.", "at": "2026-10-08T07:18:50.470004261Z", "sequence": 4858 }, { "title": "One read-only shared assessment host selected", "detail": "The existing engine is exposed through apphost Query; application owners retain dispatch and authority.", "at": "2026-10-08T07:49:54.603028544Z", "sequence": 4873 }, { "title": "Corrected independent QA charter", "detail": "Pre-dispatch non-success makes zero Content reads; actual owner refusal follows one attempted authorized read, without fallback/retry.", "at": "2026-10-08T08:28:48.73010619Z", "sequence": 4898 }, { "title": "Narrow engine/host/helper interface accepted", "detail": "Branch-aware complete preview and supplied schema closure are handed off. Frozen GREEN request is not a result.", "at": "2026-10-08T08:29:53.056315541Z", "sequence": 4899 }, { "title": "Source observation and pending check results", "detail": "Interface members are visible in source; stable handoff proceeds independently. Already owned GREEN/RED requests still need actual results.", "at": "2026-10-08T08:30:18.072363477Z", "sequence": 4900 }, { "title": "S006 public start independently verified", "detail": "Exact source09404cb5/cutoff4900 status/plan and complete S005 history served; preserved as history.", "at": "2026-10-08T08:57:34.289735941Z", "sequence": 4917 }, { "title": "Matched CLI and operator candidates staged", "detail": "Presentation/UI builds from published commits succeeded; staging alone supplied no runtime acceptance.", "at": "2026-10-08T09:42:16.835067075Z", "sequence": 4933 }, { "title": "Focused host source check passed", "detail": "Actual 8 top-level/12 leaf GREEN is source-test evidence, separate from installation and use.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:01:58.822619645Z", "sequence": 4944 }, { "title": "Shared assessment host installed and active", "detail": "Existing legitimate Team node setup/activation completed; later actual use is separately recorded.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:19:12.480578448Z", "sequence": 4954 }, { "title": "Named source and complete carry survive reopen", "detail": "Full original-source equality and exact owner input/result retained after both environments reopened.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:20:58.983701845Z", "sequence": 4957 }, { "title": "Actual operator viewport and fresh CLI dispatch", "detail": "Whole short source displayed; Back returned to the same named result. Fresh worker is an existing-actor context.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:25:51.849406044Z", "sequence": 4959 }, { "title": "Assisted fresh CLI returned useful source/inspection/return", "detail": "18 shell,13 Sidecat,5 helper; returning3; one mapping assist and first-capture limitations disclosed.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:31:28.05340706Z", "sequence": 4962 }, { "title": "Independent CLI receipt review retained limits", "detail": "Aspen compared saved outputs/inspection without rerunning the helper; broader acceptance remains separate.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:33:34.785107542Z", "sequence": 4963 }, { "title": "Actual-data temporary MCP default and inspection", "detail": "Complete public output and exact explicit inspection observed; connected harness deployment not inferred.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:34:09.028313551Z", "sequence": 4964 }, { "title": "Retained helper source published", "detail": "Exact helper source published; native kept use is not maintained-package installation.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:38:14.906794193Z", "sequence": 4967 }, { "title": "Negative/refusal/count packets returned for judgment", "detail": "Measured business calls, synthetic supplements and reachable/unreachable case limits retained; Aspen judgment pending.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:56:21.061770721Z", "sequence": 4975 }, { "title": "Returned refusal/count support independently observed", "detail": "One native refusal and cold retention corroborated; tracer setup/control failures stay failures, not product passes.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:56:59.613269664Z", "sequence": 4976 }, { "title": "Independent negative/refusal/count judgment returned", "detail": "Aspen checked the exact packets without rerunning actions; assisted CLI and broader limits retained.", "at": "2026-10-08T11:06:21.060186178Z", "sequence": 4978 }, { "title": "Fixed4976 site check and native publication completed", "detail": "One capped check20/20 and exact source937d66c5 publication; reporting deployment is separate from product qualification.", "at": "2026-10-08T11:24:17.610941498Z", "sequence": 4981 }, { "title": "Independent served-byte verification and cached UI inspection", "detail": "Complete status/source/plan/history bytes and pipeline match; cached source-field inspection is scoped existing-actor evidence.", "at": "2026-10-08T11:26:17.085882606Z", "sequence": 4982 }, { "title": "Broader Work mismatch identified for closeout", "detail": "The finite source-action proof does not complete the broader vocabulary/prerequisite Work; delivery progress record was missing.", "at": "2026-10-08T11:31:34.340895394Z", "sequence": 4983 }, { "title": "Completed delivery occurrence lacks its progress record", "detail": "Activity planned/no update; completed judgment prevents ordinary progress update. Actual delivery receipts retained separately.", "at": "2026-10-08T11:34:38.520459035Z", "sequence": 4984 }, { "title": "Initial completion observed before scope correction", "detail": "Initial main/component completion observation retained; affected broad-main wording is superseded by the following correction.", "at": "2026-10-08T11:36:44.097370641Z", "sequence": 4985 }, { "title": "Corrected finite completion; broader Work not completed", "detail": "Distinct finite Work/Plan completed, same unchanged broad Work review not_completed, erroneous historical completion explicitly superseded. Seven component completions stand; no new sprint selected.", "at": "2026-10-08T11:38:37.058510407Z", "sequence": 4986 } ], "reviews": [ { "title": "Corrected independent QA charter", "detail": "Pre-dispatch non-success makes zero Content reads; actual owner refusal follows one attempted authorized read, without fallback/retry.", "at": "2026-10-08T08:28:48.73010619Z", "sequence": 4898 }, { "title": "Narrow engine/host/helper interface accepted", "detail": "Branch-aware complete preview and supplied schema closure are handed off. Frozen GREEN request is not a result.", "at": "2026-10-08T08:29:53.056315541Z", "sequence": 4899 }, { "title": "Independent CLI receipt review retained limits", "detail": "Aspen compared saved outputs/inspection without rerunning the helper; broader acceptance remains separate.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:33:34.785107542Z", "sequence": 4963 }, { "title": "Returned refusal/count support independently observed", "detail": "One native refusal and cold retention corroborated; tracer setup/control failures stay failures, not product passes.", "at": "2026-10-08T10:56:59.613269664Z", "sequence": 4976 }, { "title": "Independent negative/refusal/count judgment returned", "detail": "Aspen checked the exact packets without rerunning actions; assisted CLI and broader limits retained.", "at": "2026-10-08T11:06:21.060186178Z", "sequence": 4978 }, { "title": "Corrected finite completion; broader Work not completed", "detail": "Distinct finite Work/Plan completed, same unchanged broad Work review not_completed, erroneous historical completion explicitly superseded. Seven component completions stand; no new sprint selected.", "at": "2026-10-08T11:38:37.058510407Z", "sequence": 4986 } ] }, "projection": { "kind": "bounded-public-s006-corrected-closeout", "event_cutoff": "2026-10-08T11:38:37.058510407Z", "event_cutoff_sequence": 4986, "sources": [ { "sequence": 4855, "name": "S006 selected: use a named retained result, read its original source and return", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T07:12:20.148320307Z", "scope": "One finite retained-result/original-source/output/inspect/reopen outcome; prior histories and unfinished release obligations remain." }, { "sequence": 4858, "name": "S006 assignments: parallel owned plans and remaining integration decision", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T07:18:50.470004261Z", "scope": "Caller/helper, presentation, engine, operator, integration, independent QA and delivery have bounded owner scopes." }, { "sequence": 4873, "name": "S006 4869 disposition: one shared query host makes assessment callable from Lisp", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T07:49:54.603028544Z", "scope": "The existing engine is exposed through apphost Query; application owners retain dispatch and authority." }, { "sequence": 4898, "name": "S006 finite pretrial charter and the first source spot-check", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T08:28:48.73010619Z", "scope": "Pre-dispatch non-success makes zero Content reads; actual owner refusal follows one attempted authorized read, without fallback/retry." }, { "sequence": 4899, "name": "S006 4894 collected: exact engine host interface and bounded host author wave", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T08:29:53.056315541Z", "scope": "Branch-aware complete preview and supplied schema closure are handed off. Frozen GREEN request is not a result." }, { "sequence": 4900, "name": "S006 B API is visible in source; release the narrow host handoff independently of full GREEN", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T08:30:18.072363477Z", "scope": "Interface members are visible in source; stable handoff proceeds independently. Already owned GREEN/RED requests still need actual results." }, { "sequence": 4917, "name": "S006 public start deployment independently verified; ordinary-entry preparer review", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T08:57:34.289735941Z", "scope": "Exact source09404cb5/cutoff4900 status/plan and complete S005 history served; preserved as history." }, { "sequence": 4930, "name": "Cedar: 4927 publications: UI and presentation published; engine held on publisher scope", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T09:30:57.063509806Z", "scope": "Exact public source publication receipt; earlier pending/preparation wording is superseded by later delivery/use records within this cutoff." }, { "sequence": 4933, "name": "Cedar: matched CLI, installer and UI pair built from the published commits and staged — nothing installed", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T09:42:16.835067075Z", "scope": "Presentation/UI builds from published commits succeeded; staging alone supplied no runtime acceptance." }, { "sequence": 4936, "name": "Cedar: engine source published under the same key (4935 done)", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T09:52:35.136749349Z", "scope": "Exact public source publication receipt; earlier pending/preparation wording is superseded by later delivery/use records within this cutoff." }, { "sequence": 4944, "name": "S006 host GREEN-v2: actual focused run exit 0, 8 top / 12 leaf all PASS", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:01:58.822619645Z", "scope": "Actual 8 top-level/12 leaf GREEN is source-test evidence, separate from installation and use." }, { "sequence": 4947, "name": "S006 host: published 23676ba1, five-file bundle built; app setup refused at preflight (no prepared node setup here)", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:07:31.898046837Z", "scope": "Exact public source publication receipt; earlier pending/preparation wording is superseded by later delivery/use records within this cutoff." }, { "sequence": 4954, "name": "Cedar 4950: host installed and activated on existing Team node; helper publication packet ready, not dispatched", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:19:12.480578448Z", "scope": "Existing legitimate Team node setup/activation completed; later actual use is separately recorded." }, { "sequence": 4957, "name": "S006 actual named source action succeeded; full owner result and carried reopen match", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:20:58.983701845Z", "scope": "Full original-source equality and exact owner input/result retained after both environments reopened." }, { "sequence": 4959, "name": "S006 fresh ordinary reader dispatched; actual operator source viewport also works", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:25:51.849406044Z", "scope": "Whole short source displayed; Back returned to the same named result. Fresh worker is an existing-actor context." }, { "sequence": 4962, "name": "S006 fresh participant returned assisted CLI journey; Aspen judgment requested", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:31:28.05340706Z", "scope": "18 shell,13 Sidecat,5 helper; returning3; one mapping assist and first-capture limitations disclosed." }, { "sequence": 4963, "name": "S006 assisted CLI sample read, inspected, and returned the same source", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:33:34.785107542Z", "scope": "Aspen compared saved outputs/inspection without rerunning the helper; broader acceptance remains separate." }, { "sequence": 4964, "name": "S006 actual-data staged MCP public default and explicit inspection exercised", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:34:09.028313551Z", "scope": "Complete public output and exact explicit inspection observed; connected harness deployment not inferred." }, { "sequence": 4967, "name": "Cedar 4966: retained-result helper published once, a9110345 on new origin branch", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:38:14.906794193Z", "scope": "Exact helper source published; native kept use is not maintained-package installation." }, { "sequence": 4975, "name": "S006 installed negative/refusal/count packets returned for Aspen judgment", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:56:21.061770721Z", "scope": "Measured business calls, synthetic supplements and reachable/unreachable case limits retained; Aspen judgment pending." }, { "sequence": 4976, "name": "S006 refusal/count support results observed; D4 handle is now terminal", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T10:56:59.613269664Z", "scope": "One native refusal and cold retention corroborated; tracer setup/control failures stay failures, not product passes." }, { "sequence": 4978, "name": "S006 negative and refusal packets match the selected counts", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T11:06:21.060186178Z", "scope": "Aspen checked the exact packets without rerunning actions; assisted CLI and broader limits retained." }, { "sequence": 4981, "name": "Cedar: S006 progress 4976 site check passed and published once: main 937d66c5, pipeline success", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T11:24:17.610941498Z", "scope": "One capped check20/20 and exact source937d66c5 publication; reporting deployment is separate from product qualification." }, { "sequence": 4982, "name": "S006 public progress deployed and independently byte-verified; exact UI inspection observed", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T11:26:17.085882606Z", "scope": "Complete status/source/plan/history bytes and pipeline match; cached source-field inspection is scoped existing-actor evidence." }, { "sequence": 4983, "name": "S006 closeout input: preserve wider semantic Work; reconcile delivery occurrence", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T11:31:34.340895394Z", "scope": "The finite source-action proof does not complete the broader vocabulary/prerequisite Work; delivery progress record was missing." }, { "sequence": 4984, "name": "Cedar: 4983 S006 delivery occurrence already judged completed; no progress update possible; receipts for the record", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T11:34:38.520459035Z", "scope": "Activity planned/no update; completed judgment prevents ordinary progress update. Actual delivery receipts retained separately." }, { "sequence": 4985, "name": "S006 native completion observed; working views updated; closeout projection proceeds", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T11:36:44.097370641Z", "scope": "Initial main/component completion observation retained; affected broad-main wording is superseded by the following correction." }, { "sequence": 4986, "name": "S006 scope correction: finite source increment delivered; broad semantic Work not completed", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T11:38:37.058510407Z", "scope": "Distinct finite Work/Plan completed, same unchanged broad Work review not_completed, erroneous historical completion explicitly superseded. Seven component completions stand; no new sprint selected." } ], "current_sprint_url": "/development/s006.html", "historical_reports": [ { "url": "/development-history/s003-progress.json", "sha256": "64de2570b69b6efc1dd53eca089f8b50722dd06c818fa6b36daca1c576e9d719", "status": "Historical snapshot preserved unchanged; S003 is now disposed and closed." }, { "url": "/development-history/s004-progress.json", "sha256": "d47991fec5a28801e486932f6c0845dc8d08f5a81089a2ebe4a8ae8d4b76a540", "status": "Exact prior published snapshot preserved unchanged through cutoff4751. Closing disposition follows native4791/4796, reported separately." }, { "url": "/development-history/s005-progress.json", "sha256": "228ab8875d712d5154f1f87f5a4cc568cbbe7521ed4ac388812a351ad6ae0561", "status": "Exact deployed S005 start snapshot at site7b525904/cutoff4796, retained unchanged; finite completion is later native evidence." }, { "url": "/development-history/s005-closeout-progress.json", "sha256": "029abdb7f09000a9152f09de7d5127f8928bbfb1bdfdf4917daeddaaaf63eb96", "status": "Exact deployed S005 closeout at source e04647e8/cutoff4831, retained unchanged; Qualified finite guidance-use outcome completed." }, { "url": "/development-history/s006-start-progress.json", "sha256": "350a66946d085b9fa81a094519f2a44eb5c05f760cc8caa988b36a1d8b8b9b85", "status": "Exact independently served S006 start at source09404cb5/cutoff4900; its Foundation statements describe that historical cutoff." }, { "url": "/development-history/s006-progress-4976.json", "sha256": "1a59f8c4c720dd1e67e832e225c9db445a873a932fbf704c2c6ec5c85b17f9c2", "status": "Exact independently served source937d66c5/cutoff4976 progress retained unchanged. Its pending judgment describes that earlier cutoff; subsequent completion/correction are separate." } ], "s004_disposition": { "value": "not_completed", "original_unknown_attempt_untouched": true, "scope": "Exact historical disposition and original owner evidence remain in preserved S005 closeout and S004 snapshots." }, "s005_disposition": { "value": "completed", "maturity": "Qualified", "scope": "Finite guidance use under existing-actor limits; original samples/costs/process disclosures remain in complete closeout snapshot." }, "s006_disposition": { "value": "completed", "judgment": { "value": "completed", "at": "2026-10-08T11:38:34.298361188Z", "scope": "Distinct accurately scoped finite named-result/source-action Work/Plan; Team4855 increment." }, "boundaries": [ { "name": "Named retained result and reopen", "maturity": "Exercised" }, { "name": "Semantic original-source action", "maturity": "Exercised" }, { "name": "Ordinary CLI/MCP/Lisp output with deliberate inspection", "maturity": "Exercised" }, { "name": "Operator shared action, full viewport, back and reopen", "maturity": "Exercised" } ], "component_completions_stand": 7, "bounded_packet_review_sequence": 4978, "correction_sequence": 4986, "broad_semantic_work": { "value": "not_completed", "at": "2026-10-08T11:38:28.342152113Z", "same_exact_work_revision": true, "scope": "General unfamiliar vocabulary/context resolution and prerequisite composition; no new sprint selected." }, "erroneous_historical_completion": { "value": "completed", "at": "2026-10-08T11:33:12.778161057Z", "disposition": "Administrative error explicitly superseded by4986; immutable history, not proof of the broader requirement." }, "jev_selected": false, "next_sprint_selected": false }, "full_v1_outcomes_incomplete": 16, "supplemental_reads": { "owner_read": { "started_at": "2026-10-08T11:41:49.795593+00:00", "finished_at": "2026-10-08T11:41:57.156654+00:00", "scope": "Exact returned4986 finite-completed, same-Work broad-not_completed, erroneous historical Plan revisions and corrected board/own/Cedar occurrences read after fixed4986 cutoff. Reads timestamped separately; not atomic event fencing. Real owner references stay in data only." }, "reference_read": { "finished_at": "2026-10-08T11:42:19.999580+00:00", "scope": "Current corrected working/maturity references read after4986; explicit supersession corroborates exact4986 owner records. Their later record/read times are supplemental, not event-fenced atomic state." }, "references": [ { "name": "version-1-working-view", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T11:41:43.001094727Z", "scope": "Later corrected working/maturity reference corroborates exact4986 owner evidence; supplemental, not event-fenced state." }, { "name": "s006-capability-maturity", "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T11:41:44.219286783Z", "scope": "Later corrected working/maturity reference corroborates exact4986 owner evidence; supplemental, not event-fenced state." } ] }, "published_sources": { "presentation": "c2f0ab270701ba297f7a671efa0fa192b127351e", "ui": "6b567afa01b5dc46b9ab6980579abfb22cadea21", "engine": "6460491f7380abd606ec2c1e74f20f77f75edb88", "host": "23676ba1ecba3f1ab86fe424f46b30b3075b74fe", "helper": "a9110345fbb47e0ea61608d777abee07b871593d" }, "delivery": { "presentation_ui": "published and matched-staged", "host": "built, installed and active on existing Team node", "helper": "published; legitimate native kept adoption; maintained-package installation not established" }, "runtime": { "original_source_characters": 876, "exact_input_and_actual_owner_result_retained": true, "both_environments_reopened_without_reseed": true, "cli_trial": { "shell_submissions": 18, "sidecat_commands": 13, "helper_calls": 5, "returning_submissions": 3, "actor_name_mapping_assists": 1, "first_precise_timestamp": "missing", "first_stdout": "reconstructed", "nested_calls": "not measured by this participant" }, "measured_business_calls": { "name_only": { "assessment": 0, "content": 0 }, "explicit_source": { "assessment": 1, "content": 1 }, "carried_inspection": { "assessment": 0, "content": 0 }, "cold_inspection": { "assessment": 0, "content": 0 }, "returning_explicit": { "assessment": 1, "content": 1 }, "each_of_four_pre_dispatch_negatives": { "assessment": 1, "content": 0 }, "genuine_owner_refusal": { "assessment": 1, "content": 1 } }, "trace_provenance": { "captured_cli_submissions": 29, "exit0": 26, "preparation_control_failures": 3, "measured_logger_calls": 22, "control_logger_calls": 3, "log_reads": 11, "helper_observation_calls": 7, "preparatory_content_reads": 1, "scope": "Separate trace work, not the fresh participant18-submission count or a daemon audit; individual logger reply bodies/keys absent." }, "negative_scope": [ "Missing source member and invalid digest against unchanged captured live schema", "Unsupported unevaluatedProperties and overlapping oneOf are changed synthetic-declaration supplements", "Raw installed host two compatible suggestions select neither/blocked; unreachable two-ready-candidate helper case remains unqualified" ], "owner_refusal": { "kind": "permission_denied", "reason": "note_access_denied", "content_attempts": 1, "retry_or_fallback": false, "cold_carried_error_unchanged": true, "pre_dispatch_permission_api": "absent" } }, "publication_limits": "Public new evidence contains summary/counts, public source revisions and sequence/title/time only. Real Note/Record/instance references, fixture payloads, launch profiles/credentials, private local paths, original unknown-attempt details and private test packets are excluded.", "process_disclosures": { "cedar_occurrence": { "judgment": "completed", "judged_at": "2026-10-08T11:33:24.098440847Z", "activity": "planned", "own_progress_note": false, "receipt_sequence": 4984, "scope": "Real recording defect; actual delivery receipts separately retained, no synthetic progress update." }, "scope_match": "Match pinned Work purpose to the selected result before judgment; historical broad completion superseded without erasure.", "capture": "Preserve one actor-name assist, missing first precise timestamp/reconstructed stdout and separate instrumented counts; future capture begins before call1." }, "cached_ui_inspection": { "source_sequence": 4982, "six_fields_observed": true, "new_source_action": false, "nested_calls": "unmeasured", "scope": "Existing-actor retained-result inspection, not separate full-Note technical viewport or independent/long-note qualification." } } }