{
  "schema": "sidebar.decision_submit_response.v0",
  "source": "sidecatd",
  "record": {
    "record_id": "runtime_record:public:sidebar-release-review",
    "location": "/v0/runtime-records/runtime_record:public:sidebar-release-review",
    "work_ref": "work_thread:public:sidecat-live-snapshot",
    "actor_ref": "agent:codex",
    "record_status": "recorded_denial",
    "prepared_at": "2026-07-05T18:32:00Z",
    "command_ref": "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
    "review_packet_ref": "review:runtime:cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669:runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review",
    "package_admission_integrity": {
      "method": "",
      "value": ""
    },
    "operator_evidence": {
      "summary": "runtime_reco...e-review review is consumed; next action: review_stored_decision",
      "next_action": "review_stored_decision",
      "items": [
        {
          "label": "Work",
          "kind": "work",
          "ref": "work_thread:public:sidecat-live-snapshot",
          "short_ref": "work_thread:...snapshot",
          "detail": "Work item that owns this review."
        },
        {
          "label": "Record",
          "kind": "record",
          "ref": "runtime_record:public:sidebar-release-review",
          "short_ref": "runtime_reco...e-review",
          "detail": "recorded_denial"
        },
        {
          "label": "Review packet",
          "kind": "review_packet",
          "ref": "review:runtime:cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669:runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review",
          "short_ref": "review:runti...e-review",
          "detail": "contract consumed; Decision decision:public:sidecat-live-snapshot is stored for this contract.; next action review_stored_decision"
        },
        {
          "label": "Command",
          "kind": "command",
          "ref": "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
          "short_ref": "cmd:input_er...7b4e9669",
          "detail": "Command or intent that produced the record."
        },
        {
          "label": "Runtime result",
          "kind": "integrity",
          "ref": "9d4fdd27124d9b9980469803e489824dd494d021a21fec4321024163deacf94b",
          "short_ref": "9d4fdd27124d...deacf94b",
          "detail": "sha256, 2825 bytes"
        }
      ]
    },
    "review_contract_status": "consumed",
    "review_contract_status_reason": "Decision decision:public:sidecat-live-snapshot is stored for this contract.",
    "review_contract_next_action": "review_stored_decision",
    "runtime_result_integrity": {
      "method": "sha256",
      "value": "9d4fdd27124d9b9980469803e489824dd494d021a21fec4321024163deacf94b"
    },
    "runtime_result_size_bytes": 2825
  },
  "packet": {
    "schema": "sidecat.review_packet.v0",
    "packet_id": "review:runtime:cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669:runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review",
    "prepared_by_sidecatd": "sidecatd:runtime-record",
    "prepared_at": "2026-07-05T18:32:00Z",
    "work_ref": "work_thread:public:sidecat-live-snapshot",
    "status": "pending_decision",
    "source_refs": {
      "request_command_ref": "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
      "command_envelope_bundle_ref": "",
      "object_protocol_bundle_ref": "",
      "policy_binding_set_ref": "",
      "replay_frame_ref": "replay:runtime:cmd%3Ainput_error%3Atranscript_peg%3A029ac7217b4e9669",
      "contract_refs": [
        "operator_review"
      ]
    },
    "review_scope": {
      "scope_ref": "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
      "title": "Runtime review for cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
      "summary": "Review rejected runtime result and correct_command_input.",
      "blocking_effect": "syntax",
      "requested_by_command_ref": "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
      "subject_refs": [
        "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
        "syntax_error",
        "denial:syntax:syntax_parse_failed",
        "action:correct_command_input",
        "diagnostic:diag:transcript_peg:98af5681e2c3ced9"
      ]
    },
    "subjects": [
      {
        "subject_ref": "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
        "object_type": "command.runtime_result",
        "role": "request_command",
        "summary": "Runtime result for cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669"
      },
      {
        "subject_ref": "syntax_error",
        "object_type": "runtime.gap",
        "role": "unresolved_gap",
        "summary": "Runtime gap requiring evidence or repair."
      },
      {
        "subject_ref": "denial:syntax:syntax_parse_failed",
        "object_type": "runtime.denial_event",
        "role": "denial_event",
        "summary": "Runtime denial event."
      },
      {
        "subject_ref": "action:correct_command_input",
        "object_type": "review.action",
        "role": "recommended_action",
        "summary": "Recommended Sidebar action correct_command_input"
      },
      {
        "subject_ref": "diagnostic:diag:transcript_peg:98af5681e2c3ced9",
        "object_type": "runtime.diagnostic",
        "role": "diagnostic",
        "summary": "Runtime diagnostic: correct command input and retry"
      }
    ],
    "evidence_refs": [
      {
        "evidence_ref": "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
        "kind": "command_runtime_result",
        "required": true,
        "status": "present",
        "resource_ref": "",
        "privacy_class": "internal",
        "summary": "The runtime result that produced this review packet."
      },
      {
        "evidence_ref": "diagnostic:diag:transcript_peg:98af5681e2c3ced9",
        "kind": "runtime_diagnostic",
        "required": true,
        "status": "present",
        "resource_ref": "",
        "privacy_class": "internal",
        "summary": "correct command input and retry"
      },
      {
        "evidence_ref": "syntax_error",
        "kind": "runtime_gap",
        "required": true,
        "status": "missing",
        "resource_ref": "",
        "privacy_class": "internal",
        "summary": "Runtime gap visible to Sidebar review."
      }
    ],
    "authority_refs": [],
    "risk_flags": [
      {
        "risk_ref": "risk:syntax_error",
        "severity": "high",
        "summary": "Runtime gap: syntax_error",
        "requires_decision": true
      },
      {
        "risk_ref": "risk:syntax_error",
        "severity": "high",
        "summary": "Runtime denial at syntax: syntax_parse_failed",
        "requires_decision": true
      }
    ],
    "operator_controls": {
      "control_set_ref": "controls:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review",
      "generated_from_contract_ref": "decision_contract:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review",
      "controls": [
        {
          "control_ref": "control:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:decision",
          "kind": "decision_radio",
          "label": "Decision",
          "required": true,
          "binds_to": "decision",
          "option_refs": [
            "acknowledge_runtime_result",
            "request_follow_up"
          ]
        },
        {
          "control_ref": "control:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:reason",
          "kind": "reason_text",
          "label": "Reason",
          "required": true,
          "binds_to": "reason"
        },
        {
          "control_ref": "control:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:accepted_evidence",
          "kind": "accepted_evidence_checkboxes",
          "label": "Evidence accepted",
          "required": false,
          "binds_to": "accepted_evidence_refs",
          "evidence_refs": [
            "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
            "diagnostic:diag:transcript_peg:98af5681e2c3ced9"
          ]
        },
        {
          "control_ref": "control:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:requested_evidence",
          "kind": "requested_evidence_checkboxes",
          "label": "Evidence requested",
          "required": false,
          "binds_to": "requested_evidence_refs",
          "evidence_refs": [
            "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
            "diagnostic:diag:transcript_peg:98af5681e2c3ced9",
            "syntax_error"
          ]
        },
        {
          "control_ref": "control:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:effects",
          "kind": "effect_acknowledgement_checkboxes",
          "label": "Effects acknowledged",
          "required": true,
          "binds_to": "effect_acknowledgements",
          "effect_refs": [
            "effect:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:acknowledge",
            "effect:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:follow_up"
          ]
        },
        {
          "control_ref": "control:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:follow_up",
          "kind": "follow_up_text",
          "label": "Follow-up",
          "required": false,
          "binds_to": "follow_up_text"
        },
        {
          "control_ref": "control:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:risks",
          "kind": "risk_warning",
          "label": "Review risks",
          "required": true,
          "binds_to": "risk_flags",
          "warning_refs": [
            "risk:syntax_error",
            "risk:syntax_error"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "advisor_output_policy": {
        "advisory_only": true,
        "may_satisfy_decision": false,
        "local_verification_required": true
      }
    },
    "decision_contract": {
      "contract_ref": "decision_contract:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review",
      "status": "consumed",
      "status_reason": "Decision decision:public:sidecat-live-snapshot is stored for this contract.",
      "next_action": "review_stored_decision",
      "valid_decisions": [
        {
          "decision": "acknowledge_runtime_result",
          "label": "Acknowledge runtime result",
          "requires": {
            "reason": true,
            "accepted_evidence_refs": false,
            "requested_evidence_refs": false,
            "follow_up_text": false
          },
          "effects": [
            {
              "effect_ref": "effect:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:acknowledge",
              "effect_type": "review_status",
              "target_ref": "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
              "outcome": "acknowledged",
              "summary": "Record that the runtime result has been reviewed."
            }
          ],
          "closes_packet": true,
          "completion_effect": "records_review"
        },
        {
          "decision": "request_follow_up",
          "label": "Request follow-up",
          "requires": {
            "reason": true,
            "accepted_evidence_refs": false,
            "requested_evidence_refs": false,
            "follow_up_text": true
          },
          "effects": [
            {
              "effect_ref": "effect:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:follow_up",
              "effect_type": "follow_up",
              "target_ref": "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
              "outcome": "follow_up_required",
              "summary": "Record follow-up needed for the runtime result."
            }
          ],
          "closes_packet": false,
          "completion_effect": "keeps_blocked"
        }
      ],
      "submission_policy": {
        "submitted_to": "sidecatd:runtime-projection",
        "sidebar_may_submit": true,
        "sidecatd_validates": true,
        "invalid_decision_status": "rejected"
      }
    },
    "staleness_status": {
      "status": "current",
      "checked_at": "2026-07-05T18:32:00Z",
      "stale_if_subjects_change": [
        "cmd:input_error:transcript_peg:029ac7217b4e9669",
        "syntax_error",
        "denial:syntax:syntax_parse_failed",
        "action:correct_command_input",
        "diagnostic:diag:transcript_peg:98af5681e2c3ced9"
      ]
    },
    "projection_policy": {
      "default_lens": "sidebar",
      "allowed_lenses": [
        "sidebar",
        "json"
      ],
      "public_safe_export": false,
      "redaction_profile": "internal",
      "mutation_allowed": false
    },
    "must_answer": {
      "authority_refs_honest": true,
      "blocking_scope_preserved": true,
      "command_ref_preserved": true,
      "review_action_preserved": true,
      "runtime_denial_refs_visible": true,
      "runtime_gap_refs_visible": true,
      "runtime_status_preserved": true
    }
  },
  "decision": {
    "schema": "sidecat.review_decision.v0",
    "decision_ref": "decision:public:sidecat-live-snapshot",
    "packet_ref": "review:runtime:cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669:runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review",
    "contract_ref": "decision_contract:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review",
    "submitted_by": "operator:public-snapshot",
    "reviewer_ref": "operator:public-snapshot",
    "submitted_via": "sidecat.dev:snapshot-generator",
    "submitted_to": "sidecatd:runtime-projection",
    "submitted_at": "2026-07-05T18:33:00Z",
    "decision": "acknowledge_runtime_result",
    "reason": "Public snapshot boundary verified before publication.",
    "accepted_evidence_refs": null,
    "requested_evidence_refs": null,
    "follow_up_text": "",
    "effect_acknowledgements": [
      "effect:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:acknowledge"
    ],
    "authority_key_id": "authority-key:aa49a2e073be6d51f8f0425959b4f2be24889c9efd98be1e7a712c7a4cf749f1",
    "sidecatd_validation": {
      "expected_status": "accepted",
      "reason": "Decision satisfied the Sidecatd validation contract for packet review:runtime:cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669:runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review."
    }
  },
  "stored": {
    "schema": "sidecatd.review_decision_store_response.v0",
    "status": "accepted",
    "decision_ref": "decision:public:sidecat-live-snapshot",
    "location": "/v0/review-decisions/decision:public:sidecat-live-snapshot",
    "packet_ref": "review:runtime:cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669:runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review",
    "contract_ref": "decision_contract:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review",
    "contract_status": "consumed",
    "contract_status_reason": "Decision decision:public:sidecat-live-snapshot is stored for this contract.",
    "contract_next_action": "review_stored_decision",
    "decision": "acknowledge_runtime_result",
    "submitted_by": "operator:public-snapshot",
    "submitted_at": "2026-07-05T18:33:00Z",
    "authority_key_id": "authority-key:aa49a2e073be6d51f8f0425959b4f2be24889c9efd98be1e7a712c7a4cf749f1",
    "observability": {
      "submitted_by": "operator:public-snapshot",
      "reviewer_ref": "operator:public-snapshot",
      "submitted_via": "sidecat.dev:snapshot-generator",
      "submitted_to": "sidecatd:runtime-projection",
      "authority_receipt_count": 0,
      "effect_acknowledgements": [
        "effect:review_runtime_cmd_input_error_transcript_peg_029ac7217b4e9669_runtime_record_public_sidebar-release-review:acknowledge"
      ],
      "effect_acknowledgement_count": 1,
      "sidecatd_validation_status": "accepted"
    },
    "operation_authority_record": {
      "schema": "sidecatd.operation_authority_record_store_response.v0",
      "status": "stored",
      "record_schema": "sidecat.operation_authority_evidence_record.v0",
      "store_kind": "operation.authority_evidence",
      "record_id": "operation_authority_record:review_decision:decision_public_sidecat-live-snapshot",
      "location": "/v0/operation-authority-records/operation_authority_record:review_decision:decision_public_sidecat-live-snapshot",
      "source_trace_id": "inv_review-decision_decision_public_sidecat-live-snapshot",
      "invocation_trace_integrity": {
        "method": "sha256",
        "value": "aa9146a3c195e7343e35f259ba277018f2357858f98f2f49867aea863b042547"
      },
      "invocation_trace_size_bytes": 3595,
      "proof_count": 0
    }
  }
}