{
  "schema": "sidecat.rearchitecture.dashboard.v1",
  "refresh_minutes": 15,
  "checked_at": "2026-10-08T06:13:24.046323Z",
  "source_updated_at": "2026-10-08T05:56:31.571619727Z",
  "summary": "S005’s finite guidance-use outcome is Qualified and completed. Two fresh worker contexts used shipped guidance to finish legitimate assigned-work and synthetic Records tasks; an independent observer opened the whole matched GUIDE through the actual UI. Aspen accepted all three samples, and Rowan’s main-occurrence completed judgment is owner-verified. These were existing-actor contexts, not human participation or new enrollment. The 34/68-call costs, README 403 fallback, UI assistance/coverage and missed pre-charter sequence are disclosed. Eight cards are explanations. S004 remains not completed, all sixteen full Version 1 outcomes remain incomplete, and no S006 is selected at this cutoff.",
  "scope_note": "S005 completed one finite guidance/adoption boundary over existing owners: two fresh task journeys and actual Apps whole-GUIDE entry/return. It does not qualify Version 1, general UI use, human participation, new enrollment or semantic routing, and does not count prior S003/S004 results again. The S005 start snapshot, S004/S003 history and original unknown send are preserved. No S006 selection is recorded through cutoff 4831.",
  "working_scope": "These are actual delivered resources, observed task/UI samples and independent finite QA/terminal judgment. The declared boundary is Qualified; observed friction and unfinished wider release obligations remain visible.",
  "working": [
    "The sole GUIDE and owning-doc/UI pointers are published: package source ae8fd8cc, docs 4e8fcdf4 and UI db4896db. Installed revision d3fecedf / installation 966a0043 has the complete 44,053-byte GUIDE. Caller library/export bytes remain unchanged; resource installation adopts no code.",
    "The fresh assigned-work reader selected among two genuine choices, read the complete 1,665-character outcome, 1,057-character observed progress and discussion, kept/reopened the same values, separately confirmed the current owner revision and explained the legitimate read-only next action. It performed no task or Team effect.",
    "The reader reported 34 top-level Sidecat CLI calls, all exit 0. Calls 1–22 are explicitly transcribed from its transcript; calls 23–34 have contemporaneous argv, exits, timing and raw output. Nested owner calls are excluded. Stale orientation, discovery burden, dense duplicate output and generic Next suggesting optional progress remain observed friction.",
    "A different fresh participant used synthetic A rice 5 / B beans 3 data through the existing Records owner: bounded returned-cursor pages A then B, A allocated with key/quantity/dates/source preserved, original exact A retained, and a real stale-base revision refused without changing current fields/head/index. Eight read grants applied. Aspen independently read granted source and exact/current Records; she corroborated saved query responses without borrowing index-query authority.",
    "The pantry used 68 CLI invocations in 71 runner receipts: 13 descriptions, six searches and 15 effect attempts—14 applied, one deliberate stale refusal, zero replays. Two guessed operation names and a guessed namespace failed. A public README fetch returned 403; the canonical checkout README matched the pinned source. Shared-helper acquisition was not exercised. These are synthetic records, not physical stock observations.",
    "An observer independent of the UI author used the matched console 597100ee and gateway b3262a9c at 80×24. It opened the whole matched GUIDE, observed beginning, PageDown and end, then returned to the same inventory row; help and UI exited 0. The full-file GUIDE hash matched, while not every middle line or a separate card-heading frame was viewed. The inherited actor nickname and charter locator were two disclosed setup assists.",
    "Aspen accepted all three samples without rerunning participants. Rowan applied only the main S005 completed judgment, then read it back; a later independent pantry review corroborated the result without adding a gate. The contexts used existing Juniper identity, not a human or enrollment trial.",
    "The reader began before the formal charter/dispatch record, although selection and prior QA criteria existed. The missed administrative sequence was disclosed and independently judged. Earlier attention was unsent input; a single standalone Enter actually activated Aspen’s existing harness at 05:37–05:39 UTC. Requested attention is distinct from dispatched/working/result evidence."
  ],
  "acceptance": [
    {
      "title": "S005: guided discovery and useful task return",
      "state": "passed",
      "detail": "Qualified and completed for S005’s one selected guidance-use outcome. Independent QA accepted the fresh assigned-work read/reopen/useful-next-action sample, the different synthetic Records allocation/exact/current/stale-base sample, and actual whole-GUIDE Apps entry/return at 80×24. Calls, assistance, fallback and coverage limits are disclosed. Existing-actor contexts do not establish human participation or new enrollment; eight cards and prior S003/S004 results are not counted as new capabilities."
    },
    {
      "title": "Full Version 1",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "All sixteen full Version 1 outcomes remain incomplete. S005 guidance/adoption evidence will not complete their full release boundaries."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-01: Organizational context",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Fresh workers still need manual orientation; effective scoped semantic inheritance is not established."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-02: Identity, authority and resources",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Josh's own usable participation; reachable scoped workers; full remote allowance/delegation outcome remains incomplete."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-03: Records and source references",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Reader-grant plumbing is exposed and has caused denied contribution reads; full area qualification incomplete."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-04: Work and planning",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Current task discovery remains cumbersome; native project and application planning views are not yet one usable path."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-05: Collective messaging",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Human entry, ordinary reply/thread/attention/return experience incomplete."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-06: Lisp and composition",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Broader fresh-agent task continuation and interface usability incomplete."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-07: Marketplace and packages",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Complete ordinary public/internal lifecycle and pending-work replacement not qualified."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-08: Semantic definitions and discovery",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. A usable namespaced vocabulary, mappings and domain-record authoring journey is not established. Operation search alone is not a complete source inventory."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-09: Executable procedures",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. General durable waits, decisions and continuation across harness replacement not qualified."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-10: Managed agent work",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Role/assignment is not proof of execution readiness. Automatic cross-harness return/context/attribution still incomplete."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-11: Controlled execution",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Rowan's named native execution route returned unavailable; broad controlled local/remote outcome incomplete."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-12: Shared bus and federation",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Full independently administered-node journey and durable gap/recovery behavior remain incomplete."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-13: Feedback and improvement",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Closed improvement loops and comparable task cost evidence are incomplete."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-14: Usable interfaces and integrations",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Actual help failed readability; unfamiliar task completion and required tracker synchronization not qualified."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-15: Operational durability and scale",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Full backup/recovery, multi-node concurrency and target-scale evidence not established here."
    },
    {
      "title": "V1-16: Sidecat UI",
      "state": "pending",
      "detail": "Incomplete. Own-identity room participation and integrated human decisions/return remain incomplete."
    }
  ],
  "work": [
    {
      "title": "One cards source and owning-doc pointers",
      "owner": "Rowan’s documentation author; independent reviewer B",
      "state": "delivered",
      "detail": "The one authored GUIDE and two owning-doc pointers are reviewed, published and delivered. Installed GUIDE is 44,053 bytes and matched to the authored source. Exact source/export parity is retained.",
      "next": "Keep the accepted guidance and observed gaps available for Rowan’s next refinement; do not treat card count as capability count."
    },
    {
      "title": "UI help and real guide entry",
      "owner": "Rowan’s UI author C; Cedar delivery; Aspen QA",
      "state": "delivered",
      "detail": "Help-only UI/README source is published and matched-staged. Independent actual 80×24 Apps/details/whole-GUIDE/return observation is accepted within its finite boundary, with two setup assists and beginning/PageDown/end coverage disclosed.",
      "next": "Preserve the accepted pair and wider S004 UI gaps. No general UI or human qualification follows from this guide-entry pass."
    },
    {
      "title": "Package parity and exact delivery",
      "owner": "Linden: caller/package ownership; Cedar: publication, artifact/install and capped build",
      "state": "delivered",
      "detail": "Cedar completed three native publications, one console-only build and one resource installation. Complete GUIDE and matched binaries are verified; libraries/gateway/version and default launchers remain unchanged, with no code adoption requested.",
      "next": "Reuse the delivered candidate and original owner interfaces. Next-outcome publication/install proposals remain unselected at this cutoff."
    },
    {
      "title": "S005: guided discovery and useful task return",
      "owner": "Aspen: independent charter and judgments; fresh permitted workers; Rowan: integration",
      "state": "delivered",
      "detail": "The single finite guidance-use outcome is Qualified/completed after Aspen accepted both fresh task samples and the independent UI guide-entry observation. Rowan’s main occurrence has an owner-verified completed judgment. Friction and administrative/identity limits remain disclosed.",
      "next": "The accepted finite outcome is closed. Rowan refines the next useful outcome; no S006 selection is recorded through cutoff 4831."
    },
    {
      "title": "Reporting and carried unfinished scope",
      "owner": "Juniper support; Rowan development/selection lead; original S004 owners",
      "state": "review",
      "detail": "The deployed S005 start projection is verified and preserved unchanged. Current native closeout is prepared for separate public delivery at fixed cutoff 4831. S004 unfinished owner scope, its original unknown send and all sixteen release gaps remain intact.",
      "next": "Cedar checks/publishes the frozen closeout packet; Juniper verifies served bytes and pipeline. Reporting does not reopen S005 or gate Rowan’s development."
    }
  ],
  "focus": {
    "title": "S005 completed; next outcome in refinement",
    "status": "verified",
    "detail": "The finite guidance-use boundary is Qualified and owner-judged completed. Preserve its three actual samples and disclosed costs, then refine the next useful outcome under Rowan. No S006 is selected at this cutoff; S004 unfinished owner work and all sixteen release gaps remain."
  },
  "phases": [
    {
      "id": "s003",
      "title": "S003: disposed and closed",
      "state": "verified",
      "detail": "The previous sprint is closed. Its bounded accepted results remain available for reuse; unfinished work and all full Version 1 obligations are not declared complete. The earlier public snapshot remains a dated historical report.",
      "evidence": [
        "Retained acquisition, keep/reopen and return evidence supports the selected continuation work."
      ],
      "next": []
    },
    {
      "id": "s004",
      "title": "S004: reviewed, not completed",
      "state": "needs-attention",
      "detail": "The main occurrence is judged not_completed after useful delivered slices. Human participation, remaining installed UI cases and complete retained continuation remain with their original owners. Reusable Work and other Plans are not universally closed.",
      "evidence": [
        "Corrected caller delivery, one new send with same-client reopen and exact 2,355-character readback; independent current-candidate recipient read.",
        "Earlier substantive 3,568-character fresh continuation result and independent readership retained at their original candidate/scope.",
        "Bounded current UI reads and missing-executable first-entry/refresh diagnostics; source tests and matched delivery remain separate."
      ],
      "next": [
        "Original Josh/Cedar human setup/use, Rowan/Aspen UI cases and Linden/Juniper continuation obligations remain unfinished.",
        "Juniper’s original unknown preparation, keys and Note are preserved without reset, replay, migration or copied-message substitute."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "s005",
      "title": "S005: finite guidance-use completed",
      "state": "verified",
      "detail": "One selected guidance/adoption boundary is Qualified/completed after three actual samples and independent QA. Main occurrence is owner-judged completed; broader release/human/identity/UI boundaries are not accepted by this result.",
      "evidence": [
        "Fresh read-only task with exact context/reopen and useful next action; different synthetic Records allocation and exact/current/stale-base behavior.",
        "Independent matched UI whole-GUIDE beginning/PageDown/end/return observation; exact source/install/binary parity.",
        "Independent finite QA and terminal owner readback, with 34/68 calls, README fallback, UI assistance/coverage and missed pre-charter sequence retained."
      ],
      "next": [
        "Rowan’s next-outcome refinement remains unselected at cutoff 4831; existing S004/full-release obligations retain their owners."
      ]
    }
  ],
  "components": [
    {
      "name": "One package GUIDE and owning-doc/UI pointers",
      "state": "implemented",
      "detail": "Exact reviewed sources are published and the 44,053-byte GUIDE is installed. Library/export parity and old candidates/default launchers are preserved."
    },
    {
      "name": "Finite unfamiliar guidance-use and Apps entry",
      "state": "verified",
      "detail": "Two fresh existing-actor task contexts and an independent matched UI observer meet the declared guidance-use boundary. This is Qualified S005 evidence, not human/enrollment/general UI qualification."
    },
    {
      "name": "Wider caller, UI and Version 1 boundaries",
      "state": "needs-attention",
      "detail": "The original S004 human/UI/complete-continuation owner work, unknown send and all sixteen full Version 1 obligations remain incomplete. Semantic integration and next-outcome proposals remain unselected."
    }
  ],
  "qualification": {
    "commit": "Package ae8fd8cc / docs 4e8fcdf4 / UI db4896db; installed d3fecedf-966a0043; GUIDE 44,053 bytes; matched console 597100ee / gateway b3262a9c",
    "checks": [
      {
        "name": "Exact guidance/help publication and installation",
        "state": "passed",
        "detail": "Cedar’s three native publications, single console build/staging and resource install are complete. Whole GUIDE hash matches authored/installed bytes inside the reader bound. Libraries/exports/gateway are unchanged and no code adoption was requested."
      },
      {
        "name": "Fresh assigned-work guidance sample",
        "state": "passed",
        "detail": "Two real choices, full 1,665-character outcome/1,057-character observed progress/discussion, retained values reopened, separate current lookup and useful read-only next action. Thirty-four CLI calls; first 22 transcribed and last 12 raw-logged. Existing identity, no task/Team effect or enrollment proof."
      },
      {
        "name": "Different fresh Records guidance sample",
        "state": "passed",
        "detail": "Synthetic A/B records exercised cursor ordering, allocation, exact/current/history and real stale-base refusal; 14 effects applied, one refused, no replays. Sixty-eight CLI calls. README 403 recovered via matching canonical checkout; shared-helper acquisition unexercised. Independent QA read granted owner sources/Records and corroborated participant query receipts without borrowed query authority."
      },
      {
        "name": "Independent actual Apps whole-GUIDE observation",
        "state": "passed",
        "detail": "Exact 44,053-byte GUIDE and matched console/gateway confirmed. At 80×24, beginning/PageDown/end and return to the same inventory row observed; help/UI exit 0. Two setup assists disclosed, no separate card-heading frame or every-middle-line claim. Finite guide-entry evidence only."
      },
      {
        "name": "Finite independent QA and main terminal judgment",
        "state": "passed",
        "detail": "Aspen’s 4826 judgment accepts all three samples against the finite selection. Rowan’s main S005 completed judgment at 05:47:36 UTC is owner-verified. A later independent pantry review corroborates it; no added gate or full Version 1 qualification."
      },
      {
        "name": "Prior S005 public start deployment",
        "state": "passed",
        "detail": "The start projection at site source 7b525904 was independently served-byte/source verified with successful pipeline. Its exact JSON, plan Markdown and source pins are retained as history. This historical deployment does not claim the current closeout is already public."
      },
      {
        "name": "Full release and carried S004 acceptance",
        "state": "pending",
        "detail": "All sixteen full Version 1 outcomes remain incomplete. S004 stays not_completed with human participation, remaining UI/complete-continuation owner work and original unknown attempt preserved. No S006 or semantic integration is selected at cutoff 4831."
      }
    ],
    "note": "S005 is Qualified/completed only for its selected finite guidance-use boundary. Eight cards are explanations, not eight capabilities; two new tasks do not re-score prior pantry/continuation. High discovery costs, fallback, assistance, bounded UI coverage and administrative sequence are disclosed rather than silently repaired."
  },
  "recent": [
    {
      "date": "2026-10-08T05:56:31.571619727Z",
      "title": "Product priority input remains refinement",
      "detail": "Useful retained-result/command behavior is proposed for the next outcome. No S006 selection is recorded at this cutoff."
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-08T05:52:04.859528794Z",
      "title": "Pantry corroboration and next-outcome refinement",
      "detail": "Independent corroboration adds no gate; proposed summary/discovery improvements remain unselected."
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-08T05:47:37.698490906Z",
      "title": "S005 main occurrence judged completed",
      "detail": "Rowan’s accepted finite outcome is owner-verified completed; eight cards are not eight capabilities and full Version 1 remains incomplete."
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-08T05:45:42.472250686Z",
      "title": "Independent QA accepts the three finite guidance samples",
      "detail": "Assigned-work reading, synthetic Records and actual whole-GUIDE UI entry meet the selected boundary, with limits disclosed."
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-08T04:44:03.990019458Z",
      "title": "S004 terminal judgment verified; current warm reader adopted",
      "detail": "Main occurrence is not_completed. Juniper’s own current full-library read matches the contribution and leaves old client/original unknown attempt untouched."
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-08T04:36:45.192873802Z",
      "title": "S005 selects guided discovery and two fresh tasks",
      "detail": "One authored GUIDE source, two owning-doc pointers, existing UI help/Apps route and two independently judged guidance-use journeys."
    },
    {
      "date": "2026-10-08T04:31:28.911502977Z",
      "title": "S004 reviewed with delivered slices and unfinished owner scope",
      "detail": "Human participation and complete acceptance remain unfinished; original owner Plans and full release commitments are retained."
    }
  ],
  "pending": [
    "All sixteen full Version 1 outcomes remain incomplete. S005’s Qualified guidance-use boundary does not qualify their full release scope.",
    "S004 remains not_completed. Original Josh/Cedar human setup/use, Rowan/Aspen remaining UI and Linden/Juniper complete-continuation owner work are carried; original unknown send is untouched.",
    "The generic Next suggestion, discovery/output burden and public README 403/canonical fallback are observed refinement inputs, not silently fixed by this closeout.",
    "No S006 is selected through cutoff 4831. Reader/retained-result alternatives, semantic integration and other release work remain deliberately unselected pending Rowan’s coherent selection."
  ],
  "next": [
    "Publish this separately checked fixed-cutoff closeout while retaining the exact S005 start and S004/S003 historical material. Verify served files and pipeline after Cedar’s native publication.",
    "Rowan compares the actual reader/README/discovery costs and useful retained-result alternatives with affected-owner readiness, then selects a coherent next outcome in the native queue. Proposals are not selected work at this cutoff.",
    "Retain S004’s original unfinished owners and unknown attempt. Maintain the distinction between fresh existing-actor contexts, human participation, native role activation and full release qualification."
  ],
  "source": {
    "label": "Native Sidecat S005 finite QA/completed disposition and unselected refinement through 7 October 2026, 23:56 MDT",
    "url": "https://sidecat.dev/development/s005.html#targets"
  },
  "cycle": {
    "id": "V1-S005",
    "outcome": "Unfamiliar permitted participants choose existing capability from shipped guidance, complete the two fresh tasks and return to useful context/results; actual Apps whole-GUIDE entry and return are observed.",
    "stage": "S005’s finite guidance-use boundary is Qualified and main occurrence completed after independent acceptance of all three samples. Source/resources and matched UI are delivered; costs and scope/process limits are retained. S004/full-release work remains incomplete. No S006 is selected through cutoff 4831.",
    "recording": "Current S005 closeout, plan and progress share fixed native cutoff 4831. The exact deployed S005 start JSON/Markdown/source pins and S004/S003 histories are retained separately. Original selection inputs/synthesis remain unchanged. Some intermediate checkpoints were not separately recorded; actual delivery, independent QA and completed closeout are retained without inventing decisions/deadlines. The first reader preceded the formal charter/dispatch record; attention activation and sequence disclosure are explicit. Supplemental owner read is not atomic event fencing.",
    "input_note": "The exact S005 selection credits independent inventory, prose/call-surface/UI/full-release, caller/release and QA input. This row records the lead selection and its attribution; it does not reconstruct individual review receipts.",
    "cutoff_sequence": 4831,
    "checkpoints": [
      {
        "id": "CP1",
        "label": "Ready to commit sprint effort",
        "state": "admitted",
        "decision": "Rowan selected the finite guidance/adoption outcome, two fresh task journeys and actual Apps whole-GUIDE entry. Exact author/review/delivery scopes are retained.",
        "decided_at": "2026-10-08T04:36:45.192873802Z"
      },
      {
        "id": "CP2",
        "label": "Ready to implement a shared change",
        "state": "pending",
        "decision": "No separate intermediate checkpoint decision is recorded in the retained receipts. Actual source/delivery and independent QA support the completed closeout at CP6."
      },
      {
        "id": "CP3",
        "label": "Ready to integrate",
        "state": "pending",
        "decision": "No separate intermediate checkpoint decision is recorded in the retained receipts. Actual source/delivery and independent QA support the completed closeout at CP6."
      },
      {
        "id": "CP4",
        "label": "Ready to release a candidate",
        "state": "pending",
        "decision": "No separate intermediate checkpoint decision is recorded in the retained receipts. Actual source/delivery and independent QA support the completed closeout at CP6."
      },
      {
        "id": "CP5",
        "label": "Ready to publish or cut over",
        "state": "pending",
        "decision": "No separate intermediate checkpoint decision is recorded in the retained receipts. Actual source/delivery and independent QA support the completed closeout at CP6."
      },
      {
        "id": "CP6",
        "label": "Sprint disposed",
        "state": "admitted",
        "decision": "Rowan judged the main S005 occurrence completed after Aspen accepted all three actual samples. Qualified scope is finite guidance/adoption; S004/full release remain incomplete.",
        "decided_at": "2026-10-08T05:47:36.27315461Z",
        "decisions": [
          {
            "outcome": "S005 finite guidance-use outcome completed",
            "decided_at": "2026-10-08T05:47:36.27315461Z",
            "sequence": 4827
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "inputs": [
      {
        "role": "Shared S005 selection",
        "actor": "Rowan",
        "worker": "Codex GPT-6.1-Sol; effort high; lead selection",
        "summary": "One finite guidance/adoption outcome, one cards source, existing owners and exact finite unfamiliar-use/Apps acceptance; eight topics are not eight new capabilities.",
        "at": "2026-10-08T04:36:45.192873802Z"
      }
    ],
    "synthesis": {
      "actor": "Rowan",
      "detail": "Reuse existing readers, Records and Apps; author guidance once, carry returned reader inputs, preserve code boundaries and obtain independent useful results without a private command recipe.",
      "at": "2026-10-08T04:36:45.192873802Z"
    },
    "history": [
      {
        "title": "S004 reviewed not completed",
        "detail": "Useful slices are retained; unfinished owners and original unknown attempt remain intact.",
        "at": "2026-10-08T04:31:28.911502977Z",
        "sequence": 4791
      },
      {
        "title": "S005 finite outcome selected",
        "detail": "Existing cards backlog selected for guidance/adoption; semantic routing and new caller/Records behavior are outside scope.",
        "at": "2026-10-08T04:36:45.192873802Z",
        "sequence": 4793
      },
      {
        "title": "S004 terminal disposition owner-verified",
        "detail": "One main-occurrence judgment applied and read back; other Plans/reusable Work remain intact.",
        "at": "2026-10-08T04:44:03.990019458Z",
        "sequence": 4796
      },
      {
        "title": "Independent QA accepts the three finite guidance samples",
        "detail": "Assigned-work reading, synthetic Records and actual whole-GUIDE UI entry meet the selected boundary, with limits disclosed.",
        "at": "2026-10-08T05:45:42.472250686Z",
        "sequence": 4826
      },
      {
        "title": "S005 main occurrence judged completed",
        "detail": "Rowan’s accepted finite outcome is owner-verified completed; eight cards are not eight capabilities and full Version 1 remains incomplete.",
        "at": "2026-10-08T05:47:37.698490906Z",
        "sequence": 4827
      },
      {
        "title": "Pantry corroboration and next-outcome refinement",
        "detail": "Independent corroboration adds no gate; proposed summary/discovery improvements remain unselected.",
        "at": "2026-10-08T05:52:04.859528794Z",
        "sequence": 4828
      },
      {
        "title": "Product priority input remains refinement",
        "detail": "Useful retained-result/command behavior is proposed for the next outcome. No S006 selection is recorded at this cutoff.",
        "at": "2026-10-08T05:56:31.571619727Z",
        "sequence": 4831
      }
    ],
    "reviews": [
      {
        "title": "Independent finite QA accepts all three samples",
        "detail": "Aspen read actual owner sources/Records and matched UI evidence, disclosed costs/assistance/admin sequence and accepted the finite boundary without rerunning participants.",
        "at": "2026-10-08T05:45:42.472250686Z",
        "sequence": 4826
      }
    ]
  },
  "projection": {
    "kind": "bounded-public-s005-closeout",
    "event_cutoff": "2026-10-08T05:56:31.571619727Z",
    "event_cutoff_sequence": 4831,
    "sources": [
      {
        "name": "S005 fresh read-only participant result ready for Aspen/Rowan independent judgment",
        "sequence": 4818,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T05:19:54.035774509Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:ad176d6159ff0896d1ada54ca4cd17c0a8c633f8f58026b2c15803b82970452d",
          "id": "note_5e36873bdcf506b9b9013a80cb286fb9",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_c4cfe5c12e3c6f62072b53d3d7501cf7"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "S005 public transition independently verified deployed; exact R1 source and preserved history",
        "sequence": 4819,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T05:20:31.090029647Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:5543bbf02838701e4a192358cad41eb40d879bc4681a9d7cd656eac965921cd5",
          "id": "note_548b95e4a58b8becbcf8c48d12ea5c5a",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_b3449cf93ddba4ff94aa0927d336b9c1"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "S005 independent installed UI GUIDE observation completed; raw evidence ready for judgment",
        "sequence": 4821,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T05:24:07.120248942Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:48c9c1acc420c35eb80baaef5af4621bf5cd3dcf70a0d0c17f779ab9a2007ab8",
          "id": "note_2545ec1191155fcd88ea89648965a281",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_64520e46373dc7789b41ca5c83d15b2d"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "S005 different fresh pantry participant completed; owner result and QA readership ready",
        "sequence": 4822,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T05:34:21.943528085Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:00e6f5a6422da0a9a90b3c213940f223127f067c8960981f2e9cfd628bcf81c6",
          "id": "note_39e7e64fbaa2f0ce29d0437d6fe11fae",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_62a6258f99fe298be33fbc4791e19d0a"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "S005 finite QA judgment: three guidance samples completed",
        "sequence": 4826,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T05:45:42.472250686Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:afb52227d46330af5c876319cee77c4b6a9cfed0118d8394b02725f202574869",
          "id": "note_95dceb049fddb3e35e1d66919d3f9cb9",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_ac60127392e709543f2540d104b8fb4e"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "S005 review and disposition: finite guided-use outcome completed",
        "sequence": 4827,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T05:47:37.698490906Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:d7cf4f874526513a1c892eee89144c787a896affbfa64bcd4e3a548d99a30c84",
          "id": "note_3194a55f37125fe496ced10c6a8966c7",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_427856b5c4be56ee09c0ec22f563c05f"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "Next-outcome refinement: finish a useful read deliberately; owner inputs requested",
        "sequence": 4828,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T05:52:04.859528794Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:4cbf18c703fda7dcdd9b9c25c22628172102ec6b28b7fe138bc5d09ccb060762",
          "id": "note_1fd976f23d69e27dabf29c40503d3735",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_8fddd9d8e008c0a1a7faada4c47017a8"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "Next-outcome contribution: useful retained-result action with IDs hidden by default",
        "sequence": 4829,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T05:52:47.213702916Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:3910ea4b3ffbec445b660edbe6ad8c8757cf99ebe53bc81f394c53b3253a12a5",
          "id": "note_91313216c24efa26c22eb8f95b2f657f",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_a682dc5465f19591f13914b9f450422d"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "Cedar 4828 assessment: one package publish/artifact/install is feasible; no console rebuild; library has 2192 bytes of headroom",
        "sequence": 4830,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T05:53:08.421042801Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:adbb30a4eb5493f55636bd7840be35d06eedaef96a756801bf527d0403150cf4",
          "id": "note_c1b5125d8fc6b8f84dd501030da35141",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_bcbf524ea71afe291d2f7e6eff2689a1"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "Product priority input: next sprint should mature usable capability, with summary repair inside it",
        "sequence": 4831,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T05:56:31.571619727Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:46b6ab8a9cb0613cd068b8911c8ed9c99965bd87c7219229884c8b9ce3d26afa",
          "id": "note_5bd4f37b7a51e8d71f973fc2e5ce1434",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_dcf187206e427cdfbf1d800005d83835"
        }
      }
    ],
    "current_sprint_url": "/development/s005.html",
    "historical_reports": [
      {
        "url": "/development-history/s003-progress.json",
        "sha256": "64de2570b69b6efc1dd53eca089f8b50722dd06c818fa6b36daca1c576e9d719",
        "status": "Historical snapshot preserved unchanged; S003 is now disposed and closed."
      },
      {
        "url": "/development-history/s004-progress.json",
        "sha256": "d47991fec5a28801e486932f6c0845dc8d08f5a81089a2ebe4a8ae8d4b76a540",
        "status": "Exact prior published snapshot preserved unchanged through cutoff4751. Closing disposition follows native4791/4796, reported separately."
      },
      {
        "url": "/development-history/s005-progress.json",
        "sha256": "228ab8875d712d5154f1f87f5a4cc568cbbe7521ed4ac388812a351ad6ae0561",
        "status": "Exact deployed S005 start snapshot at site7b525904/cutoff4796, retained unchanged; finite completion is later native evidence."
      }
    ],
    "s004_disposition": {
      "value": "not_completed",
      "review_sequence": 4791,
      "owner_verified_sequence": 4796,
      "main_plan_supplemental": {
        "owner": "sidecat.dev/work",
        "instance_id": "app_7d2a7c76530b1f8320ef2a4d42241cdb",
        "kind": "plan",
        "id": "plan_66ed632733a0e6ad506513e3f341fe33",
        "revision_id": "revision_3b8ef098acda66bee945b7d79f1402aa",
        "digest": "sha256:13a3ecccbf10758ae9869f82f313ee33afe89a03c6edcfdf4c3f1091c69ad2bd"
      },
      "judgment_supplemental": {
        "value": "not_completed",
        "at": "2026-10-08T04:40:16.360542787Z",
        "evidence": [
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_c07f0a1f14a5a155316783e86ff779ed",
            "revision_id": "revision_1a86781653a4c9b39ec261990ed5623f",
            "digest": "sha256:e29988042a9f6a2f1b2475032bb1a96fb1d580dbd01f907c87c738c10f1a1124"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_8a902108ac264b95cdf3908c3fe0759c",
            "revision_id": "revision_179aab53b206cb594105e32b8f92840f",
            "digest": "sha256:17faf8352524fa2e4c9dabd98ca15dcb9a7f99066887ebff82b5f24bafe8abc0"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_2470174087749c5b8134229d3e88fe8a",
            "revision_id": "revision_e3920003df9b618c15f73a3903ae1e2c",
            "digest": "sha256:e4353f63e1575a48a6befc12b2cbe3607086f6f4366b71a47b0c860efab92276"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_229d346bf5082df2e232bf4960cb1209",
            "revision_id": "revision_c292132f33127665eb081771242457f2",
            "digest": "sha256:287ffcdc5a3a04f83fc76aa79803be149d6775853755b01a3713a376ac26566d"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_91eef3d91a09041008f56899cfa2fddd",
            "revision_id": "revision_454862cc667f3e22ab7113aa053892a9",
            "digest": "sha256:77a101d5b857853f57b0ed6a8aa45db8c8d697cc42ac30ed93ce1dc931436e50"
          }
        ]
      },
      "original_selection_url": "/development/s004.html",
      "unfinished_owners_retained": true,
      "original_unknown_attempt_untouched": true
    },
    "current_candidate": {
      "caller_source": "ae8fd8cc9e775d7f65773efb2bb5dd31024fc8cc",
      "caller_tree": "3abe2be0510d82826a3d0c29f2944233e73aae44",
      "caller_revision": "sha256:d3fecedf98d9a8c00ed255e227af5e2a8cfe14e537e7766a91e59d22a501fe1d",
      "installation": "sha256:966a00438fcc0f8c3c8ba1e9ef0f7ea1d903ef001f15500694ece5788bfb7fc6",
      "conversation_bytes": 63344,
      "team_bytes": 65510,
      "ui_source": "db4896db3b87da282f1d5edc0ea193b93969910c",
      "ui_tree": "5081a95c4a265675dd1690f7b42f31703e6dbaa2",
      "console_sha256": "597100eeb7c8a0c06aaa9e0329d4b09e23a75f432f15c9fa80c95517f0f06237",
      "gateway_sha256": "b3262a9c223bf0b8352ddaa5e90528603ad27e0d38bcd8472df9f1e2426f5802",
      "readme_source": "db4896db3b87da282f1d5edc0ea193b93969910c",
      "scope": "Delivered S005 guide/help candidate; actual finite guidance-use samples accepted. General UI/human/full release qualification excluded.",
      "guide_bytes": 44053,
      "guide_sha256": "6d2faee2884e434586416ca7aa5111f3bd1ee66bb488a733a0c18e6507998fbd",
      "docs_source": "4e8fcdf42c9a42e3ef25e2ee66068bc941f45698"
    },
    "new_guidance_passed": true,
    "full_v1_outcomes_incomplete": 16,
    "supplemental_reads": {
      "read_at": "2026-10-08T06:03:19.355340Z",
      "scope": "Current exact main owning Plan read after fixed cutoff4831; corroborates completed disposition, not atomic event fencing."
    },
    "previous_public_report": {
      "commit": "7b525904ec585bb0d3eef6aee4b13c6dc6681453",
      "tree": "9d67fc29f18a65910e6ad6fc05e309c358c331fe",
      "cutoff_sequence": 4796,
      "note": "Deployed S005 start verified at4819; exact snapshot/plan/source pins retained. This closeout is a separate unpublished projection at cutoff4831."
    },
    "limits": "Qualified/completed only for one finite S005 guidance-use boundary. All16fullV1 incomplete, S004not_completed/unfinished owners and original unknown send preserved. Existing-actor fresh contexts not human/enrollment; cards notcapabilitycount.34/68calls with first22reader calls transcribed; README403 canonical fallback; UI two assists and begin/PageDown/end limited coverage; precharter sequence and actual attention activation disclosed. No S006 selected at cutoff4831.",
    "selection_sources": [
      {
        "name": "S004 sprint review: not completed; delivered slices and unfinished owner dispositions",
        "sequence": 4791,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T04:31:28.911502977Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:e29988042a9f6a2f1b2475032bb1a96fb1d580dbd01f907c87c738c10f1a1124",
          "id": "note_c07f0a1f14a5a155316783e86ff779ed",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_1a86781653a4c9b39ec261990ed5623f"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "S005 selected: discover existing capabilities and complete fresh tasks from shipped guidance",
        "sequence": 4793,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T04:36:45.192873802Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:ad8f864dfa1ba517848d837d10ecef1ff976be2fb7142c9f62882c4cb4be18bc",
          "id": "note_0fa1ac84c833371cc859dc04c6260be8",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_b30507a99d6d361b85fd98cf730a8eb1"
        }
      },
      {
        "name": "S004 main terminal judgment verified; Root current-reader upgrade and S005 support",
        "sequence": 4796,
        "recorded_at": "2026-10-08T04:44:03.990019458Z",
        "content": {
          "digest": "sha256:2a4f0ce3ea9fed02adf9be35c0e323699577a0ec0d7616bc1c5da094c206f4cd",
          "id": "note_bfef10c0ce11fe54940d075b68b76942",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "revision_id": "revision_87feaed08bad5526b11e0fd1ae348d81"
        }
      }
    ],
    "supporting_content_sources": [
      {
        "name": "Cedar S005 4801 delivery complete: three publications, one console build staged, GUIDE installed",
        "content": {
          "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
          "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
          "kind": "note",
          "id": "note_22078295456103db022b071b6295ad30",
          "revision_id": "revision_14191b02aa7f45f8cbb36e30a1cf25e9",
          "digest": "sha256:97f6e2087b01e46ed884903159a852afbc5d90313d13d3026b8688b4efb7452b"
        },
        "scope": "Exact Cedar delivery Note carried by completed Plan evidence; identified as Team4805 by lead4827. Original event timestamp not reconstructed."
      }
    ],
    "start_plan_history": {
      "markdown_url": "/development-history/s005-start-sprint.md",
      "markdown_sha256": "007eea1d5f2b38576f7634eb992a45a21613dd4d17735a85c227b6713bdf5328",
      "sources_url": "/development-history/s005-start-sources.json",
      "sources_sha256": "ec827744b746584c22ceeea76e3a58b8150eee5d4b11cc535037c8445cdc931b"
    },
    "s005_disposition": {
      "value": "completed",
      "maturity": "Qualified finite guidance/adoption only",
      "qa_sequence": 4826,
      "review_sequence": 4827,
      "main_plan": {
        "owner": "sidecat.dev/work",
        "instance_id": "app_7d2a7c76530b1f8320ef2a4d42241cdb",
        "kind": "plan",
        "id": "plan_d0952b51b7ff9438cf9da9676f4e234f",
        "revision_id": "revision_0e5e0011246db4f27aa3b20838ae7715",
        "digest": "sha256:0d07762de853991c2f1cc15ed7ef8d866af9b28b0c3d8e62cd35c3462d01e11a"
      },
      "work": {
        "owner": "sidecat.dev/work",
        "instance_id": "app_7d2a7c76530b1f8320ef2a4d42241cdb",
        "kind": "work",
        "id": "work_2374e0b243a7a95b0456f9e326833d4c",
        "revision_id": "revision_ae16f9583a47cd3ac8991b5d5c15b998",
        "digest": "sha256:6d80caf1da6fe791879ab706a5d126dd82bb4d9cfd302d84962433f5695a6ad0"
      },
      "judgment": {
        "value": "completed",
        "at": "2026-10-08T05:47:36.27315461Z",
        "evidence": [
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_3194a55f37125fe496ced10c6a8966c7",
            "revision_id": "revision_427856b5c4be56ee09c0ec22f563c05f",
            "digest": "sha256:d7cf4f874526513a1c892eee89144c787a896affbfa64bcd4e3a548d99a30c84"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_0fa1ac84c833371cc859dc04c6260be8",
            "revision_id": "revision_b30507a99d6d361b85fd98cf730a8eb1",
            "digest": "sha256:ad8f864dfa1ba517848d837d10ecef1ff976be2fb7142c9f62882c4cb4be18bc"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_95dceb049fddb3e35e1d66919d3f9cb9",
            "revision_id": "revision_ac60127392e709543f2540d104b8fb4e",
            "digest": "sha256:afb52227d46330af5c876319cee77c4b6a9cfed0118d8394b02725f202574869"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_a07f4aa8f41d0aebd3f13b7cabb2e34b",
            "revision_id": "revision_f3f97ca58e5f321792659367483146e5",
            "digest": "sha256:b5bb0ca718f329efaec15704ecceab0b67f9d1a94369903e7719ef240f6dce7e"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_22078295456103db022b071b6295ad30",
            "revision_id": "revision_14191b02aa7f45f8cbb36e30a1cf25e9",
            "digest": "sha256:97f6e2087b01e46ed884903159a852afbc5d90313d13d3026b8688b4efb7452b"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_5e36873bdcf506b9b9013a80cb286fb9",
            "revision_id": "revision_c4cfe5c12e3c6f62072b53d3d7501cf7",
            "digest": "sha256:ad176d6159ff0896d1ada54ca4cd17c0a8c633f8f58026b2c15803b82970452d"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_2545ec1191155fcd88ea89648965a281",
            "revision_id": "revision_64520e46373dc7789b41ca5c83d15b2d",
            "digest": "sha256:48c9c1acc420c35eb80baaef5af4621bf5cd3dcf70a0d0c17f779ab9a2007ab8"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_39e7e64fbaa2f0ce29d0437d6fe11fae",
            "revision_id": "revision_62a6258f99fe298be33fbc4791e19d0a",
            "digest": "sha256:00e6f5a6422da0a9a90b3c213940f223127f067c8960981f2e9cfd628bcf81c6"
          },
          {
            "owner": "sidecat.dev/content",
            "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef",
            "kind": "note",
            "id": "note_305cc61d71647cf02391a1efab3b9b81",
            "revision_id": "revision_2d0d13b49b734ec33b33f7e96e154899",
            "digest": "sha256:6d262fc86c5e968bf3b16eca64a496e446d2555111d42601dd6d3bc00906e6ba"
          }
        ]
      },
      "next_sprint_selected": false
    },
    "samples": {
      "reader": {
        "sequence": 4818,
        "calls": 34,
        "first22_provenance": "Explicit transcript transcriptions",
        "last12_provenance": "Contemporaneous argv/exit/time/raw records",
        "outcome_chars": 1665,
        "observed_progress_chars": 1057,
        "two_actual_choices": true,
        "business_effects": false,
        "shared_helper_acquisition": true
      },
      "pantry": {
        "sequence": 4822,
        "calls": 68,
        "runner_receipts": 71,
        "describe_calls": 13,
        "search_calls": 6,
        "effect_attempts": 15,
        "applied": 14,
        "deliberate_refused": 1,
        "replays": 0,
        "read_grants": 8,
        "synthetic": true,
        "public_readme_fetch": 403,
        "fallback": "Canonical checkout README byte-matched pinned source",
        "shared_helper_acquisition": false,
        "qa_query_authority": "Independent granted record/source reads; no borrowed index-query right"
      },
      "ui": {
        "sequence": 4821,
        "columns": 80,
        "rows": 24,
        "guide_bytes": 44053,
        "coverage": "Beginning, PageDown, end and same-inventory return; not every middle line or separate card-heading frame",
        "setup_assists": [
          "Inherited actor nickname clarified",
          "Charter locator supplied on explicit request"
        ],
        "exit_code": 0,
        "help_exit_code": 0,
        "independent_of_author_c": true
      },
      "identity_limit": "Fresh separate worker contexts under existing Juniper; no human or enrollment qualification"
    },
    "process_disclosures": {
      "precharter_reader": true,
      "scope": "Selection and prior QA criteria existed; formal charter/dispatch recording followed first reader and missed sequence was disclosed/independently judged",
      "attention_activation": "Earlier reminders were unsent input; one standalone Enter actually activated existing Aspen harness05:37–05:39Z",
      "requested_dispatched_working_result_distinct": true,
      "no_new_audit_startup_framework": true,
      "duplicate_observer": "Canceled before GUI, exit -15/no result; excluded from accepted sample count, not a failed trial."
    }
  }
}