{ "schema": "sidecat.capability-maturity-report.v1", "report_identity": "S004 shared capability table", "updated_at": "2026-10-10T13:12:51.334947654Z", "cutoff_sequence": 5897, "scale": { "Unimplemented": "No maintained behavior establishes the responsibility", "Foundation": "Contracts/internal behavior without the ordinary journey", "Exercised": "Bounded ordinary journey and relevant recovery demonstrated", "Qualified": "Documented boundary and release evidence complete" }, "dimensions": [ "usefulness", "architecture", "implementation", "installed availability", "authority/recovery", "qualification", "caller experience" ], "columns": [ "Product capability", "Existing implementation or use", "Missing qualification or material gap", "Sprint disposition" ], "rows": [ { "id": "V1-01", "cells": [ "Organizational context", "Installed prepared context is independently qualified for the tested six-export edition: an ordinary newcomer installs and explicitly adopts it, selects two owner inputs, creates Work/Plan and returns after reopen by task title. Exact original input pins survive omitted updates; source checks47/47 and installed pin checks11/11 passed.", "This qualification covers the prepared context edition, not all organizational context. Native scope membership, read-without-revise, native Plan repin/supersedes, broader inheritance and the public default remain open.", "Integrate the accepted context edition with Cedar's Node successors. Continue the broader context and semantic responsibilities without repeating completed trials unless changed behavior requires it." ], "verification": "Independent installed journey and terminal review07 accepted at Team5714; bounded capability qualified, full-area outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-02", "cells": [ "Identity, authority and resources", "Prepared actors and owner access controls are used. Exact child-mission source passes 34 Auth cases; allowance 38, Begin/revoke 46 and settlement 67 pass in successive owner suites.", "Authority components pass owner suites, but the common authority facade had five failing behaviors in the later source trial. Installed guarded effects, delegation and opt-in governance still need complete qualification.", "Authority engineer owns the remaining token/executor path. Root integrates qualified successors and judges actual installed authorized effects." ], "verification": "Updated through Team5628: attributed source, isolated installed and recovery observations; full outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-03", "cells": [ "Records and source references", "S006 exercised an exact 876-character originating Note. S007 now captures distinct originals; an assisted installed CLI participant deliberately selected, read and restored the correct 1,518-character original. Independent readback confirmed the bound task, source, title and full text.", "Full-area qualification remains incomplete. The S007 CLI sample used an existing prepared actor and assistance; both-lot controls, ordinary reconnected MCP/Lisp and production UI participant acceptance remain open.", "Retain the exercised original-read and restore evidence. Complete the selected S007 ordinary-use controls and remaining surfaces before judgment; no full V1-03 completion." ], "verification": "Current bounded evidence and declared limits; not full-area retest", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-04", "cells": [ "Work and planning", "The earlier Note/Work/Plan/progress/share and reconnect workflows remain exercised. Installed opt-in Plan completion is independently qualified with genuine Notes and three authenticated actors. The extension verifies producer, binder and reviewer scope, a deliberately selected new occurrence for a changed candidate, rejection of previous approval, and preserved accepted detail. Ordinary unbound completion remains available; fresh CLI and MCP detail agree.", "Kernel project/Work and application Plan coherence, unfamiliar participant discovery and evidence preparation without routine ID plumbing, actual scrum capability-analysis enrollment, successor activation and worker disposition remain incomplete. Candidate renewal uses a new occurrence of the same Work; in-place candidate rebinding is intentionally refused. The qualified completion mechanism is not yet a public default delivery.", "Root owns integration and qualification. The original 49 behavioral assertions within141 checks stand. Team5897 records an independently accepted extension:29 behavioral assertions,29 successful calls and16 fresh scope/contract checks. Seven actual refusals were inspected. Broader governance Plan remains underway and unjudged; enrollment stays optional and human qualification is outside agent delivery." ], "verification": "Installed completion and candidate/scope extension independently accepted; broader Work/planning outcome remains incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-05", "cells": [ "Collective messaging", "Real room messages, shared content and bounded reads are used.", "Ordinary collaborator discovery and reply remain incomplete. The CLI newcomer cannot find a colleague through message targets or current-session participants; no colleague feedback is obtained.", "Human-and-agent team participation selected." ], "verification": "Updated at Team 5510 from exact integrated source, isolated installed observations and disclosed participant limits; full outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-06", "cells": [ "Lisp and composition", "Explicit installed package-library adoption is independently qualified for the prepared six-export edition. Ordinary install/adopt/find/do/reopen/title-return passed3 selection/return and16 final assertions; all four adoption roots and seven supplemental owner refusal/origin outcomes passed the completed daemon traversal.", "General heterogeneous composition, macro/unsupported capture adoption and per-value public origin remain unfinished. Native Records/stock effects and default-release delivery are open. The completed daemon traversal has three receiving-grant failures and two unqualified skips; it is not whole-suite GREEN.", "Codex semantic product lead owns package adoption, scoped context and prepared composition, with a Node consumer review from Cedar. Preserve S005/S006 evidence and complete S007 ordinary entry." ], "verification": "Independent installed journey and terminal review07 accepted at Team5714; bounded capability qualified, full-area outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-07", "cells": [ "Marketplace and packages", "The prepared context package is accepted as a usable installed capability: ten resources, sixteen owner schema documents and six exports support independent normal installation, explicit adoption and useful execution/reopen. Combined package source e59563a138096736d1678cbb734a95634ce27249 preserves both reviewed heads and matches exact tree5cff10c0477943314c8996bea96d9bdcc9d59194.", "The qualified prepared edition is not yet a published default. Wider marketplace publication/discovery/replacement and other package lifecycles remain unfinished. Cedar owns the combined Node/package delivery; acceptance of this edition does not qualify all packages.", "Codex owns semantic package adoption and composition. Cedar now owns the complete packages and marketplace area under native assigned Work/Plan (Team5881/5897): publication, discovery, inspection, installation/use, replacement and self-hosted access. The existing packages-fix lane leads authoring, with independent QA within its current worker/resource cap. Cedar acknowledgement and new implementation evidence are not yet established. Codex B remains off." ], "verification": "Independent installed journey and terminal review07 accepted at Team5714; bounded capability qualified, full-area outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-08", "cells": [ "Semantic engine", "Prepared context/package use and supplied-source semantic assessment are independently qualified within their documented boundaries. Installed assessment0.4.1 adds an ordinary named receiving-policy preview: explicitly selected finite mapping converts recorded5000 grams into the exact draft text 'Recorded net carton mass: 5 kilograms.' Missing mapping rows and undeclared conversions remain blocked or unknown. Genuine Content source reads and authored annotations are preserved.", "Assessment qualification uses genuine Content declarations, closure and reads with QA-authored policy/schema/vocabulary inputs. The new conversion is a declared finite mapping, not general arithmetic, physical measurement or a Records/action effect. Engine and Guide source successors are published; integrated Core, retained callers, complete S007 CLI/UI, broader composition and matched public default delivery remain incomplete.", "The semantic owner and two children continue the selected command-analysis increment: compare observed and alternative bindings against declared task meaning and explain preserved, lost and unknown criteria. Installed quantity0.4.1 was independently accepted at Team5852 and raw results reviewed by Root. Cedar5859 reports exact Engine/Guide source publication; Core0.4.1 remains a Node integration input. Team5860/5896 select the next increment without replacing S007 or claiming installed Compare." ], "verification": "Installed supplied-source assessment0.4.1 finite mapping accepted; source publication distinct from integrated/default delivery. Full semantic-engine outcome remains incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-09", "cells": [ "Executable procedures", "Unknown-outcome, cancellation/retry and pending-retry repairs are integrated. Later stopped-observation source passes 80 selected owner tests; four integrated unknown/known/canceled/interrupted controls pass.", "Native cancellation/retry routes remain missing in the separate owner trial. Its latest run also has a temporary-socket setup failure in one old control, so it is not clean RED. Full waits, recovery and installed procedure use remain open.", "Orchestration engineer owns native routing and recovery; integration keeps actual uncertainty and stopped outcomes separate from success." ], "verification": "Updated at Team 5510 from exact integrated source, isolated installed observations and disclosed participant limits; full outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-10", "cells": [ "Managed agent work", "Earlier manager/child source evidence remains. A later real child-process source trial passed application Plan and RolesAssignment handoff, immutable-context checks and completion recording; process exit is kept distinct from actual Plan completion.", "The Plan bridge source evidence is not complete installed managed work. Cross-harness returns, current-principal authority, cancellation/retry and restart recovery need integrated user-path qualification.", "Root retains integration responsibility and coordinates the Node owner and remote-execution owner for installed managed work." ], "verification": "Updated through Team5628: attributed source, isolated installed and recovery observations; full outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-11", "cells": [ "Controlled execution", "A serialized capped remote builder performs source-matched Go/Rust/site checks and builds, with retained commands, exits and unchanged-source checks.", "That build path does not qualify general controlled local/remote execution, cancellation, connector effects or actionable unknown outcomes. The protected-material failure required private reconstruction of owner setup; general actionable prerequisite discovery and supported repair/request remain unqualified (Team5159/5162).", "Reuse the accepted builder. Keep unknown effects untouched; do not infer a general execution qualification from component build passes." ], "verification": "Current bounded evidence and declared limits; not full-area retest", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-12", "cells": [ "Shared bus and federation", "Local typed owner calls remain installed. Cedar's fresh-node federation trial executed commands from one node on another. Linden reports completed subscription, local two-node and route-reselection runs; a separate bus check failed.", "Cross-node Work dispatch failed in the fresh-node trial; successor nodes are prepared but its final demonstration is pending. Local bus runs do not establish independently administered-node recovery or full durable subscription behavior.", "Linden owns local bus and application coordination; Aspen owns federation and remote execution. Cedar is transferring its existing federation work after one bounded demonstration. Each owner retains its own full development and QA cycle." ], "verification": "Updated through Team5628: attributed source, isolated installed and recovery observations; full outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-13", "cells": [ "Feedback and improvement", "Native findings and independent participant reports are retained unchanged. Current trials expose collaboration, documentation, orientation and output friction. A separate helper probe returns structured criticism advice with zero tool events.", "The helper probe is backend feasibility, not installed UI or automatic priority change. Complete feedback intake, comparable task costs, useful independent QA and accepted improvement delivery remain unfinished.", "Cedar owns the responsive operator interface and retained feedback intake alongside Node. Root aligns priorities and release decisions. The separate QA guide has a first research unit; it is not yet a usable manual or completed QA cycle." ], "verification": "Updated through Team5628: attributed source, isolated installed and recovery observations; full outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-14", "cells": [ "Usable interfaces and integrations", "Prepared CLI/MCP/Lisp use remains exercised. The context edition's ordinary installation, returned adoption, default dispatcher/direct parity and CLI/MCP/Lisp return checks passed on an isolated candidate. Cedar's reconciled installer successor d9b05560c and round2 REPL/package journeys are under independent review; earlier Ubuntu evidence remains.", "Installer, REPL/package successors and the semantic candidate remain unpublished as a matched default. Full daemon/CLI/surface traversal is incomplete; coherent public help/manual/package behavior, macOS and broader integrations remain open. Finite parity checks do not qualify the full command surface.", "Cedar owns Node/CLI, installer and fresh-node REPL/package trials; Codex owns semantic/common-task integration and release review. Codex B is off." ], "verification": "Updated through Team5688 from independent installed observations and current owner disposition; finite boundaries explicit, full outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-15", "cells": [ "Operational durability and scale", "Retained records survive earlier node reconnect trials. After a real desktop out-of-memory interruption at19:01 MDT, the heartbeat restored Root's original thread at19:15. Root then manually resumed Claude, Grok and Cursor from retained conversations; completed remote jobs were not replayed.", "Root's original-thread recovery is observed, but other primary recovery required manual action. The existing monitor detected federation idle for ten checks without acting; a guarded owner-wake correction is assigned, not delivered. Whole-team recovery, verified backup restore, contention and scale remain unfinished.", "Cedar retains recovery engineering and Node durability; Aspen owns the hourly coordination reminder. Root monitors resources and qualifies recovery behavior. Existing S007 restoration and broader durability obligations remain." ], "verification": "Updated through Team5688 from independent installed observations and current owner disposition; finite boundaries explicit, full outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" }, { "id": "V1-16", "cells": [ "Sidecat UI", "Earlier finite S007 retained-source/UI evidence stands. A new published Boards build passed its source gates but dropped five installed retained-source behaviors. Cedar restored the prior default at21:59MDT; the new build remains side by side. Three-way merge and independent installed retest are underway.", "The UI regression omitted displayed-proposal binding/refusal, task-change context clearing, Shift input, task breadcrumb and footer. Their unpublished predecessor source must be merged and published with Boards. Broader responsiveness, feedback, conversation, authorized decisions and useful current usage remain unqualified.", "Cedar owns Node/UI together and is merging the exact S007 predecessor with published Boards, preserving unrelated owner work. Ship and test the resulting matched source/default; source gates alone do not qualify the operator path." ], "verification": "Updated through Team5688 from independent installed observations and current owner disposition; finite boundaries explicit, full outcome incomplete.", "full_outcome": "incomplete" } ], "history": [ { "at": "2026-10-08T04:56:51.395849554Z", "scope": "Original S004 baseline", "rows": [ { "id": "V1-01", "cells": [ "Organizational context", "Guidance, named references, roles and selected working context are used.", "Fresh workers still need manual orientation; effective scoped semantic inheritance is not established.", "Improve the context needed for task continuation." ] }, { "id": "V1-02", "cells": [ "Identity, authority and resources", "Prepared actors, access decisions and bounded resource observations exist.", "Josh's own usable participation; reachable scoped workers; full remote allowance/delegation outcome remains incomplete.", "Cedar owns selected identity/access and execution prerequisites." ] }, { "id": "V1-03", "cells": [ "Records and source references", "Exact Notes are reused by messages and Work; authorized team reads are exercised.", "Reader-grant plumbing is exposed and has caused denied contribution reads; full area qualification incomplete.", "Make the two selected journeys share content correctly." ] }, { "id": "V1-04", "cells": [ "Work and planning", "Work definitions, assigned Plan occurrences, board selection and terminal judgments are in ordinary lead use.", "Current task discovery remains cumbersome; native project and application planning views are not yet one usable path.", "Real continuation is selected; no competing planning ledger." ] }, { "id": "V1-05", "cells": [ "Collective messaging", "Real room messages, shared content and bounded reads are used.", "Human entry, ordinary reply/thread/attention/return experience incomplete.", "Human-and-agent team participation selected." ] }, { "id": "V1-06", "cells": [ "Lisp and composition", "Bounded caller package acquisition, keep/reopen and return were accepted in S003.", "Broader fresh-agent task continuation and interface usability incomplete.", "Reuse the accepted slice in the continuation outcome." ] }, { "id": "V1-07", "cells": [ "Marketplace and packages", "Exact caller package delivery provides bounded exercised evidence.", "Complete ordinary public/internal lifecycle and pending-work replacement not qualified.", "Reuse existing packaging; no broad marketplace campaign." ] }, { "id": "V1-08", "cells": [ "Semantic definitions and discovery", "Exact identity and typed contracts exist.", "A usable namespaced vocabulary, mappings and domain-record authoring journey is not established. Operation search alone is not a complete source inventory.", "Use established shared meanings; keep this release gap explicit." ] }, { "id": "V1-09", "cells": [ "Executable procedures", "Bounded composed caller/pantry tasks were accepted.", "General durable waits, decisions and continuation across harness replacement not qualified.", "Build only the selected real continuation path." ] }, { "id": "V1-10", "cells": [ "Managed agent work", "Four actual external team sessions have responded; Codex native delegation is available.", "Role/assignment is not proof of execution readiness. Automatic cross-harness return/context/attribution still incomplete.", "Reuse native agent/session mechanisms with retained Sidecat task context." ] }, { "id": "V1-11", "cells": [ "Controlled execution", "Existing execution contracts and capped remote build path.", "Rowan's named native execution route returned unavailable; broad controlled local/remote outcome incomplete.", "Resolve the concrete selected execution dependency." ] }, { "id": "V1-12", "cells": [ "Shared bus and federation", "Typed local owner calls operate through the bus.", "Full independently administered-node journey and durable gap/recovery behavior remain incomplete.", "Existing calls only; no federation expansion." ] }, { "id": "V1-13", "cells": [ "Feedback and improvement", "Josh's findings, independent proposals and dispositions are retained.", "Closed improvement loops and comparable task cost evidence are incomplete.", "Two-sprint QA-review trial with useful-findings and cost measures." ] }, { "id": "V1-14", "cells": [ "Usable interfaces and integrations", "CLI/MCP/Lisp and a bounded installed client exist.", "Actual help failed readability; unfamiliar task completion and required tracker synchronization not qualified.", "Fix entry points/help needed for the two outcomes; wider gaps stay visible." ] }, { "id": "V1-15", "cells": [ "Operational durability and scale", "Some bounded restart/return evidence exists.", "Full backup/recovery, multi-node concurrency and target-scale evidence not established here.", "Relevant recovery only; no scale campaign." ] }, { "id": "V1-16", "cells": [ "Sidecat UI", "Installed task/progress/Note views and bounded observations exist.", "Own-identity room participation and integrated human decisions/return remain incomplete.", "Rowan delivers a runnable independently tested client for the selected journey." ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-08T16:20:05Z", "scope": "Current bounded evidence through5095; every changed cell retained", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-03", "capability": "Records and source references", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Exact Notes are reused by messages and Work; authorized team reads are exercised.", "after": "S006 exercised an exact originating Note read through semantic assessment: all 876 characters matched the independent owner read. Named results retain the actual observation and reopen without reseeding.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-03", "capability": "Records and source references", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Reader-grant plumbing is exposed and has caused denied contribution reads; full area qualification incomplete.", "after": "Full-area qualification remains incomplete. S007's distinct-source capture, explicit choice and task-bound reader/restore are still under implementation and testing.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-03", "capability": "Records and source references", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Make the two selected journeys share content correctly.", "after": "S006 finite original-source increment completed at Exercised scope. S007 advances exact source association and ordinary entry; no full V1-03 completion.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Work definitions, assigned Plan occurrences, board selection and terminal judgments are in ordinary lead use.", "after": "Reusable Work, assigned Plan occurrences, boards and terminal judgments are used. The corrective QA coverage audit now has a native underway Plan and shared evidence.", "evidence": [ "Team5091", "Team5093", "installed c2f0ab27 CLI/manual probes" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Current task discovery remains cumbersome; native project and application planning views are not yet one usable path.", "after": "Native project planning and application Plan judgment are not one clear user path. Capability analysis is not enforced as an opted-in scrum condition; a stable complete report was missing. Evidence stays optional by default.", "evidence": [ "Team5091", "Team5093", "installed c2f0ab27 CLI/manual probes" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Real continuation is selected; no competing planning ledger.", "after": "Preserve current S007 selected Work. Corrective capability/QA reporting is underway; opt-in governance implementation admission remains with Rowan.", "evidence": [ "Team5091", "Team5093", "installed c2f0ab27 CLI/manual probes" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Bounded caller package acquisition, keep/reopen and return were accepted in S003.", "after": "S006 exercised retained named values/functions and actual source observation across reopened environments. S005 guidance-use is Qualified within its finite existing-actor boundary.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Broader fresh-agent task continuation and interface usability incomplete.", "after": "General fresh-agent continuation and full Lisp documentation remain incomplete. New S007 capture/caller source has synthetic boundary checks, not installed participant qualification.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Reuse the accepted slice in the continuation outcome.", "after": "Reuse the maintained retained-result package. S007 caller work continues on the reassigned isolated Sol author occurrence.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Exact caller package delivery provides bounded exercised evidence.", "after": "Maintained helper source a9110345 is published. The installed durable_conversation GUIDE supplies eight capability cards; S005 finite guidance-use is Qualified under its stated sample limits.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Complete ordinary public/internal lifecycle and pending-work replacement not qualified.", "after": "Eight card topics are not eight qualified product capabilities. Maintained caller-package installation, broad public/internal lifecycle and pending-work replacement remain unqualified.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Reuse existing packaging; no broad marketplace campaign.", "after": "Use installed guidance and existing delivery mechanisms. New S007 caller/package delivery remains pending; no broad marketplace campaign.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic definitions and discovery", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Exact identity and typed contracts exist.", "after": "The standalone engine and read-only semantic assessment host are implemented. Host 0.2.0 is installed; actual Find ambiguity/single-source and selected-source Check controls were observed. S006 exercised one real original-source selection/read.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic definitions and discovery", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "A usable namespaced vocabulary, mappings and domain-record authoring journey is not established. Operation search alone is not a complete source inventory.", "after": "Find needs supplied catalog/documents/meaning. No top-level task-to-command semantic discovery exists. Broader vocabulary/mapping/domain-authoring and ordinary S007 participant use remain unqualified.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic definitions and discovery", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Use established shared meanings; keep this release gap explicit.", "after": "S007 integrates unfamiliar declared meaning, whole-contract assessment and deliberate source choice. Command discovery/manual gaps are explicit refinement inputs.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Four actual external team sessions have responded; Codex native delegation is available.", "after": "External team harnesses and native Sol delegation execute bounded assignments. Team5083 reassigned a stalled caller occurrence; Team5089 reports actual source and checks on the replacement branch.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Role/assignment is not proof of execution readiness. Automatic cross-harness return/context/attribution still incomplete.", "after": "An assignment or live process does not prove successful work. Automatic cross-harness activation, durable return, context and attribution remain incomplete.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Reuse native agent/session mechanisms with retained Sidecat task context.", "after": "Keep ready component owners parallel; retain the old unfinished occurrence and verify replacement results against the same Work.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-11", "capability": "Controlled execution", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Existing execution contracts and capped remote build path.", "after": "A serialized capped remote builder performs source-matched Go/Rust/site checks and builds, with retained commands, exits and unchanged-source checks.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-11", "capability": "Controlled execution", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Rowan's named native execution route returned unavailable; broad controlled local/remote outcome incomplete.", "after": "That build path does not qualify general controlled local/remote execution, cancellation, connector effects or actionable unknown outcomes.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-11", "capability": "Controlled execution", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Resolve the concrete selected execution dependency.", "after": "Reuse the accepted builder. Keep unknown effects untouched; do not infer a general execution qualification from component build passes.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-12", "capability": "Shared bus and federation", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Typed local owner calls operate through the bus.", "after": "Typed owner calls and semantic query-host operations are installed on the local bus. Application permission and Content effects remain with their owners.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-12", "capability": "Shared bus and federation", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Full independently administered-node journey and durable gap/recovery behavior remain incomplete.", "after": "Independently administered-node cooperation, durable subscriptions and gap/recovery qualification remain incomplete.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-12", "capability": "Shared bus and federation", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Existing calls only; no federation expansion.", "after": "Use the existing query and Content contracts for S007; no federation expansion is selected.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-13", "capability": "Feedback and improvement", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Josh's findings, independent proposals and dispositions are retained.", "after": "Operator findings and independent reviews are retained in native Team/Work. Two QA audits reproduced help, discovery, coverage-list and installed-manual gaps; Team5091/5093 preserve the findings and corrective audit.", "evidence": [ "Team5091", "Team5093", "installed c2f0ab27 CLI/manual probes" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-13", "capability": "Feedback and improvement", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Closed improvement loops and comparable task cost evidence are incomplete.", "after": "No complete current command-to-expectation-to-evidence coverage ledger was demonstrated. QA-review usefulness and comparable task costs are not established by test counts.", "evidence": [ "Team5091", "Team5093", "installed c2f0ab27 CLI/manual probes" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-13", "capability": "Feedback and improvement", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Two-sprint QA-review trial with useful-findings and cost measures.", "after": "Corrective QA coverage audit underway. Rowan must assign disposition/implementation; broad all-hands QA and unfamiliar current-build trials are not complete.", "evidence": [ "Team5091", "Team5093", "installed c2f0ab27 CLI/manual probes" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "CLI/MCP/Lisp and a bounded installed client exist.", "after": "CLI c2f0ab27 is now installed. Live operation search finds appwork.plan.judge; independent audits exercised help availability for 129 leaves. S006 exercised meaningful CLI/temporary MCP/Lisp output.", "evidence": [ "Team5091", "Team5093", "installed c2f0ab27 CLI/manual probes" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Actual help failed readability; unfamiliar task completion and required tracker synchronization not qualified.", "after": "Installed man page is stale; judge is absent from its index; invalid project plan judge --help succeeds with parent help. search/apropos are absent. Complete searchable manual, unfamiliar task acceptance and tracker synchronization remain unqualified.", "evidence": [ "Team5091", "Team5093", "installed c2f0ab27 CLI/manual probes" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Fix entry points/help needed for the two outcomes; wider gaps stay visible.", "after": "Preserve installed presentation improvement. Treat manual parity, help correctness and task discovery as explicit unresolved QA requirements; default MCP reconnect and S007 trials remain separate.", "evidence": [ "Team5091", "Team5093", "installed c2f0ab27 CLI/manual probes" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-15", "capability": "Operational durability and scale", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Some bounded restart/return evidence exists.", "after": "S006 retained named state and actual source observations reopened unchanged without reseeding. Component runs use bounded remote resources and source/artifact matching.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-15", "capability": "Operational durability and scale", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Full backup/recovery, multi-node concurrency and target-scale evidence not established here.", "after": "Bounded reopening is not full backup/recovery, multi-node contention, absent-agent or target-scale qualification.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-15", "capability": "Operational durability and scale", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Relevant recovery only; no scale campaign.", "after": "S007 new typed cold restoration remains pending. Keep broader durability and scale outcomes incomplete.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Installed task/progress/Note views and bounded observations exist.", "after": "S006 exercised the matched operator viewport against the complete 876-character original and return. S007 task UI component tests pass; the accepted cache UI is separately built/staged.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Own-identity room participation and integrated human decisions/return remain incomplete.", "after": "Human own-identity participation and broad UI acceptance remain incomplete. New typed task restore/body trials remain pending; independent QA found the Esc-cancel editor defect and focused tests fail as expected.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Rowan delivers a runnable independently tested client for the selected journey.", "after": "Deliver and qualify the corrected task-bound UI with the maintained caller. Cache source/staging and legacy tests do not qualify the new task route.", "evidence": [ "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5092" ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-08T20:36:34Z", "scope": "Josh5159 actionable owner/prerequisite failure gap; backlog only, no maturity promotion or changed S007 acceptance", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Eight card topics are not eight qualified product capabilities. Maintained caller-package installation, broad public/internal lifecycle and pending-work replacement remain unqualified.", "after": "Eight card topics are not eight qualified product capabilities. Maintained caller-package installation, broad public/internal lifecycle and pending-work replacement remain unqualified. Source publication currently fails without identifying the missing repository prerequisite, actual setup owner or supported repair/request action (Team5159/5162).", "evidence": [ "Team5159", "Team5162", "work_10e44373ab304615ca9a826265db7d12", "plan_126f980f8297707a51c6e63a7b0b9204" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-11", "capability": "Controlled execution", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "That build path does not qualify general controlled local/remote execution, cancellation, connector effects or actionable unknown outcomes.", "after": "That build path does not qualify general controlled local/remote execution, cancellation, connector effects or actionable unknown outcomes. The protected-material failure required private reconstruction of owner setup; general actionable prerequisite discovery and supported repair/request remain unqualified (Team5159/5162).", "evidence": [ "Team5159", "Team5162", "work_10e44373ab304615ca9a826265db7d12", "plan_126f980f8297707a51c6e63a7b0b9204" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Installed man page is stale; judge is absent from its index; invalid project plan judge --help succeeds with parent help. search/apropos are absent. Complete searchable manual, unfamiliar task acceptance and tracker synchronization remain unqualified.", "after": "Installed man page is stale; judge is absent from its index; invalid project plan judge --help succeeds with parent help. search/apropos are absent. Complete searchable manual, unfamiliar task acceptance and tracker synchronization remain unqualified. Ordinary task/library preparation and owner-failure results need discoverable missing prerequisites, actual owners and supported next actions; no new top-level command or automatic permission gate is selected (Team5159/5162).", "evidence": [ "Team5159", "Team5162", "work_10e44373ab304615ca9a826265db7d12", "plan_126f980f8297707a51c6e63a7b0b9204" ] } ], "backlog": { "work": { "owner": "sidecat.dev/work", "instance_id": "app_7d2a7c76530b1f8320ef2a4d42241cdb", "kind": "work", "id": "work_10e44373ab304615ca9a826265db7d12", "revision_id": "revision_c5879a2207e206232f80f692bf313fa1", "digest": "sha256:57c4563e8077128c2bd6f80d6b6e03b909c432ed1ecbbd70ba0cb6926f5639a8" }, "plan": { "owner": "sidecat.dev/work", "instance_id": "app_7d2a7c76530b1f8320ef2a4d42241cdb", "kind": "plan", "id": "plan_126f980f8297707a51c6e63a7b0b9204", "revision_id": "revision_575c52531bfd6a362f646ef5b1239afe", "digest": "sha256:74b6567219164535bfe097ee5e5c86b44785c7ef30f6140f93b680e53b18ca9a" }, "board": { "owner": "sidecat.dev/work", "instance_id": "app_7d2a7c76530b1f8320ef2a4d42241cdb", "kind": "board", "id": "board_c9b43e676cbca8201d440bc5fecfb9ad", "revision_id": "revision_27efe716e4facf7211c33fbcf68f5f3a", "digest": "sha256:4a23122a56558f51222258e5053a6aa3f31dc27f5e71a08c34145d4ecd9622b6" }, "priority": 82, "state": "planned", "note": { "digest": "sha256:d83d1cfb240a007a6c177bc58b1d91a46d4c97b936aea205071299c3d0fce465", "id": "note_a263be83e8689cd8d1e95b92cac1584f", "instance_id": "app_a5ce1c632a55b6c3b6150db1ae0755ef", "kind": "note", "owner": "sidecat.dev/content", "revision_id": "revision_1435b00aa649fca94d1db3217dbd986b" } } }, { "at": "2026-10-08T20:58:42Z", "scope": "Bounded evidence through Team5166; assisted CLI use, installed component delivery and actual UI input failure; no full qualification", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-03", "capability": "Records and source references", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "S006 exercised an exact originating Note read through semantic assessment: all 876 characters matched the independent owner read. Named results retain the actual observation and reopen without reseeding.", "after": "S006 exercised an exact 876-character originating Note. S007 now captures distinct originals; an assisted installed CLI participant deliberately selected, read and restored the correct 1,518-character original. Independent readback confirmed the bound task, source, title and full text.", "evidence": [ "Team5156", "Team5158", "Team5163" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-03", "capability": "Records and source references", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Full-area qualification remains incomplete. S007's distinct-source capture, explicit choice and task-bound reader/restore are still under implementation and testing.", "after": "Full-area qualification remains incomplete. The S007 CLI sample used an existing prepared actor and assistance; both-lot controls, ordinary reconnected MCP/Lisp and production UI participant acceptance remain open.", "evidence": [ "Team5156", "Team5158", "Team5163" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-03", "capability": "Records and source references", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "S006 finite original-source increment completed at Exercised scope. S007 advances exact source association and ordinary entry; no full V1-03 completion.", "after": "Retain the exercised original-read and restore evidence. Complete the selected S007 ordinary-use controls and remaining surfaces before judgment; no full V1-03 completion.", "evidence": [ "Team5156", "Team5158", "Team5163" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "S006 exercised retained named values/functions and actual source observation across reopened environments. S005 guidance-use is Qualified within its finite existing-actor boundary.", "after": "S006 retained values and actual source observations reopened without reseeding. The installed S007 retained_result library exposes six exports; ordinary CLI library calls exercised deliberate choice, full original reading and carried restoration. S005 finite guidance remains Qualified.", "evidence": [ "Team5158", "Team5163" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "General fresh-agent continuation and full Lisp documentation remain incomplete. New S007 capture/caller source has synthetic boundary checks, not installed participant qualification.", "after": "General fresh-agent continuation and full Lisp documentation remain incomplete. The S007 sample needed shipped package guidance and assistance; independent ordinary reconnected MCP/Lisp acceptance remains open.", "evidence": [ "Team5158", "Team5163" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Reuse the maintained retained-result package. S007 caller work continues on the reassigned isolated Sol author occurrence.", "after": "Reuse the installed retained-result library for the remaining S007 trials. Preserve the assisted CLI limits and existing S005/S006 evidence.", "evidence": [ "Team5158", "Team5163" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Maintained helper source a9110345 is published. The installed durable_conversation GUIDE supplies eight capability cards; S005 finite guidance-use is Qualified under its stated sample limits.", "after": "S005 finite guidance-use is Qualified. The S007 caller package is natively installed and locally ready; installed inspection exposes six exports and the exact 13,326-byte GUIDE. One assisted CLI participant used the installed library.", "evidence": [ "Team5156", "Team5158", "Team5162", "Team5163", "Team5159" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Eight card topics are not eight qualified product capabilities. Maintained caller-package installation, broad public/internal lifecycle and pending-work replacement remain unqualified. Source publication currently fails without identifying the missing repository prerequisite, actual setup owner or supported repair/request action (Team5159/5162).", "after": "Broad public/internal package lifecycle and pending-work replacement remain unqualified. Caller source publication is held at a repository setup prerequisite; ordinary failure results do not identify the missing prerequisite, actual setup owner or supported repair/request action. Installed resource readiness does not establish complete marketplace qualification.", "evidence": [ "Team5156", "Team5158", "Team5162", "Team5163", "Team5159" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Use installed guidance and existing delivery mechanisms. New S007 caller/package delivery remains pending; no broad marketplace campaign.", "after": "Continue ordinary use of the ready installed package and resolve the held source-publication prerequisite through its owner. Keep broader lifecycle work separate from S007.", "evidence": [ "Team5156", "Team5158", "Team5162", "Team5163", "Team5159" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "CLI c2f0ab27 is now installed. Live operation search finds appwork.plan.judge; independent audits exercised help availability for 129 leaves. S006 exercised meaningful CLI/temporary MCP/Lisp output.", "after": "Installed CLI c2f0ab27 and operation search remain available. A fresh CLI participant read and restored the correct S007 original with assistance in 16 calls. The help repair has assertion RED, focused GREEN and passing affected/manual checks; delivery remains pending.", "evidence": [ "Team5158", "Team5161", "Team5162", "Team5163", "Team5159" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Installed man page is stale; judge is absent from its index; invalid project plan judge --help succeeds with parent help. search/apropos are absent. Complete searchable manual, unfamiliar task acceptance and tracker synchronization remain unqualified. Ordinary task/library preparation and owner-failure results need discoverable missing prerequisites, actual owners and supported next actions; no new top-level command or automatic permission gate is selected (Team5159/5162).", "after": "Ordinary library-route discovery required assistance. The installed man page remains stale; judge is absent from its index; invalid project plan judge help succeeds with parent help. search/apropos remain absent. Readable task association, updated installed help/manual, unassisted use, reconnected MCP and tracker synchronization remain unqualified. Ordinary task/library preparation and owner-failure results need discoverable missing prerequisites, actual owners and supported next actions; no new top-level command or automatic permission gate is selected (Team5159/5162).", "evidence": [ "Team5158", "Team5161", "Team5162", "Team5163", "Team5159" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Preserve installed presentation improvement. Treat manual parity, help correctness and task discovery as explicit unresolved QA requirements; default MCP reconnect and S007 trials remain separate.", "after": "Complete the remaining ordinary S007 surfaces and controls. Keep help delivery and coherent discovery/recovery improvements on their native corrective backlog; do not infer qualification from help test counts.", "evidence": [ "Team5158", "Team5161", "Team5162", "Team5163", "Team5159" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "S006 exercised the matched operator viewport against the complete 876-character original and return. S007 task UI component tests pass; the accepted cache UI is separately built/staged.", "after": "S006 exercised the full 876-character original viewport and return. The corrected S007 UI passes 22 Rust and 16 Go cases. A normal production UI/gateway pair is installed; its dashboard shows eight assigned and eight created rows under the delivery actor.", "evidence": [ "Team5156", "Team5161", "Team5166" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Human own-identity participation and broad UI acceptance remain incomplete. New typed task restore/body trials remain pending; independent QA found the Esc-cancel editor defect and focused tests fail as expected.", "after": "The installed pantry UI trial is blocked: query/context editors drop the first capital letter, so the displayed context label cannot be entered faithfully and no original is read. Back/Restore returns an ambiguous result. Human own-identity participation and broad UI acceptance remain incomplete.", "evidence": [ "Team5156", "Team5161", "Team5166" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Deliver and qualify the corrected task-bound UI with the maintained caller. Cache source/staging and legacy tests do not qualify the new task route.", "after": "Repair the observed UI text-entry routing defect and rerun the selected two-lot task, full original, Back and cold reopen. Keep component GREEN and installed delivery separate from participant acceptance; S007 remains unjudged.", "evidence": [ "Team5156", "Team5161", "Team5166" ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-09T05:54:01Z", "scope": "Root24-hour delivery push: qualified assignment sharing, finite installed UI trial, current CLI help behavior and actual orchestration RED; full outcomes unchanged", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Reusable Work, assigned Plan occurrences, boards and terminal judgments are used. The corrective QA coverage audit now has a native underway Plan and shared evidence.", "after": "Reusable Work, Plan occurrences, boards and judgments are used. The maintained assignment helper0.1.1 now shares both task Notes and Plans with explicit readers. Its tests-first repair passed8 pure cases, actual owner grants and independent Linden Plan/Work/Note reads; source2423 is published.", "evidence": [ "Team5320", "Team5362", "Team5365" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Native project planning and application Plan judgment are not one clear user path. Capability analysis is not enforced as an opted-in scrum condition; a stable complete report was missing. Evidence stays optional by default.", "after": "Native project planning and application Plans still form different paths. Typed scoped context and opted-in scrum-condition enforcement remain incomplete. Evidence stays optional by default; qualification and release belong to Root, without an outside-human gate.", "evidence": [ "Team5320", "Team5362", "Team5365" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Preserve current S007 selected Work. Corrective capability/QA reporting is underway; opt-in governance implementation admission remains with Rowan.", "after": "Root owns the24-hour release push and its native release board. Preserve original S007 work and judgments; integrate the qualified helper correction while completing the broader planning/context path. Opt-in governance Work remains explicitly unfinished.", "evidence": [ "Team5320", "Team5362", "Team5365" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "S006 retained values and actual source observations reopened without reseeding. The installed S007 retained_result library exposes six exports; ordinary CLI library calls exercised deliberate choice, full original reading and carried restoration. S005 finite guidance remains Qualified.", "after": "S006 retained values and actual source observations reopen without reseeding. The installed S007 retained_result library has six exports; assisted ordinary CLI use exercised choice, full-original read and restoration. S005 finite guidance remains Qualified. Development assignment/progress composition is catfooded; the0.1.1 reader repair has eight passing pure cases and actual installed-owner/independent-reader proof.", "evidence": [ "Team5320", "Team5362", "Team5365" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic definitions and discovery", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "S007 integrates unfamiliar declared meaning, whole-contract assessment and deliberate source choice. Command discovery/manual gaps are explicit refinement inputs.", "after": "Cedar leads the semantic engine as an agent workhorse: one owner declaration and shared ranking contract, ordinary task-find/task-do with identifiers internal by default, and explicit inspection. Marketplace and UI consume that contract. Source development and installed qualification remain separate.", "evidence": [ "Team5339", "Team5345" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-09", "capability": "Executable procedures", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "General durable waits, decisions and continuation across harness replacement not qualified.", "after": "The full configured procedure journey, installed discovery, restart/harness replacement, waits, cancellation and retry remain unqualified. A real Engine/reopened-SQLite test now reproduces the adapter incorrectly treating an unknown executor outcome as failed; its known-exit7 control passes.", "evidence": [ "Team5350", "Team5366" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-09", "capability": "Executable procedures", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Build only the selected real continuation path.", "after": "The assigned orchestration author is repairing the reproduced unknown-outcome defect tests-first, then completing durable task and managed-run contracts on the existing sidecat-orch owner. Integration preserves original attempts; this repair does not waive the full procedure outcome.", "evidence": [ "Team5350", "Team5366" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Installed CLI c2f0ab27 and operation search remain available. A fresh CLI participant read and restored the correct S007 original with assistance in 16 calls. The help repair has assertion RED, focused GREEN and passing affected/manual checks; delivery remains pending.", "after": "Installed CLI1.0.0-dev.20261008.s007-help-candidate-tree7dc025bd now refuses project plan judge --help with exit2 and an actionable parent-query explanation. The S007 original read/restore worked with assistance. Qualified assignment helper0.1.1 is published and in use through the installed owners.", "evidence": [ "Team5320", "Team5362", "Team5365" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Ordinary library-route discovery required assistance. The installed man page remains stale; judge is absent from its index; invalid project plan judge help succeeds with parent help. search/apropos remain absent. Readable task association, updated installed help/manual, unassisted use, reconnected MCP and tracker synchronization remain unqualified. Ordinary task/library preparation and owner-failure results need discoverable missing prerequisites, actual owners and supported next actions; no new top-level command or automatic permission gate is selected (Team5159/5162).", "after": "The installed man page still has no judge index entry. Unassisted task discovery, complete manual/examples, ordinary reconnected MCP, Linux/macOS installation and issue-tracker synchronization remain unqualified. The repository-prerequisite help correction has behavioral RED; its GREEN and the MCP identity qualification remain pending. No new top-level command or automatic permission gate is implied.", "evidence": [ "Team5320", "Team5362", "Team5365" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "S006 exercised the full 876-character original viewport and return. The corrected S007 UI passes 22 Rust and 16 Go cases. A normal production UI/gateway pair is installed; its dashboard shows eight assigned and eight created rows under the delivery actor.", "after": "Installed UI73fd6b52/gateway47cc6535 exercised the selected S007 task: capital context input and first query character were retained; three viewport captures matched the complete1518-character original after viewport normalization; same-task Back/reopen retained it. Switching tasks cleared the old source and the earlier lot stayed honestly missing/invalidated.", "evidence": [ "Team5333", "Team5341" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The installed pantry UI trial is blocked: query/context editors drop the first capital letter, so the displayed context label cannot be entered faithfully and no original is read. Back/Restore returns an ambiguous result. Human own-identity participation and broad UI acceptance remain incomplete.", "after": "The finite trial used a prepared actor and assistance. Boards completion/prerequisite transition, refresh during a pending selection switch, denied original, reconnected MCP/Lisp and the complete operator goals/conversation/authorized-decision/usage path remain unqualified. External human review is not a release prerequisite.", "evidence": [ "Team5333", "Team5341" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Repair the observed UI text-entry routing defect and rerun the selected two-lot task, full original, Back and cold reopen. Keep component GREEN and installed delivery separate from participant acceptance; S007 remains unjudged.", "after": "Aspen owns the remaining selected UI checks and operator-focused presentation/docs in a protected source tree. Preserve the actual finite trial and its limits. New source is under development; S007 stays unjudged until its remaining outcomes receive an explicit disposition.", "evidence": [ "Team5333", "Team5341" ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-09T07:17:51Z", "scope": "Isolated prepared coordination and later qualified owner source; no full outcome or public availability promotion", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Reusable Work, Plan occurrences, boards and judgments are used. The maintained assignment helper0.1.1 now shares both task Notes and Plans with explicit readers. Its tests-first repair passed8 pure cases, actual owner grants and independent Linden Plan/Work/Note reads; source2423 is published.", "after": "Isolated 66b exercises native helper 0.1.1 install/adoption, Note/Work/Plan creation, progress and explicit Note/Plan sharing. A distinct CLI reader reconnects successfully. Later Work successor source passes 37 owner tests; it is not installed.", "evidence": [ "Team5417", "Team5418", "Team5419" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Native project planning and application Plans still form different paths. Typed scoped context and opted-in scrum-condition enforcement remain incomplete. Evidence stays optional by default; qualification and release belong to Root, without an outside-human gate.", "after": "Project/application planning coherence, typed context, opted-in policy and actual worker disposition remain unfinished. Evidence is optional by default.", "evidence": [ "Team5417", "Team5418", "Team5419" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Root owns the24-hour release push and its native release board. Preserve original S007 work and judgments; integrate the qualified helper correction while completing the broader planning/context path. Opt-in governance Work remains explicitly unfinished.", "after": "Root integrates qualified deltas and owns qualification. Preserve exact retired contracts and original attempts; S007 stays unjudged.", "evidence": [ "Team5417", "Team5418", "Team5419" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "S006 retained values and actual source observations reopen without reseeding. The installed S007 retained_result library has six exports; assisted ordinary CLI use exercised choice, full-original read and restoration. S005 finite guidance remains Qualified. Development assignment/progress composition is catfooded; the0.1.1 reader repair has eight passing pure cases and actual installed-owner/independent-reader proof.", "after": "Installed helper 0.1.1 loads explicitly into a named Lisp environment with zero owner calls. Assignment/progress/sharing and fresh Lisp/MCP reads preserve exact Notes and Plan; prior S005/S006 evidence stands.", "evidence": [ "Team5418", "Team5419" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "General fresh-agent continuation and full Lisp documentation remain incomplete. The S007 sample needed shipped package guidance and assistance; independent ordinary reconnected MCP/Lisp acceptance remains open.", "after": "Prepared assisted coordination only; general fresh-agent continuation, full docs and the separate S007 original-source MCP/Lisp task remain unqualified.", "evidence": [ "Team5418", "Team5419" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "S005 finite guidance-use is Qualified. The S007 caller package is natively installed and locally ready; installed inspection exposes six exports and the exact 13,326-byte GUIDE. One assisted CLI participant used the installed library.", "after": "Exact helper resources install natively in the isolated Linux candidate. Its returned guide/loader supports explicit adoption and a real shared task.", "evidence": [ "Team5419" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Broad public/internal package lifecycle and pending-work replacement remain unqualified. Caller source publication is held at a repository setup prerequisite; ordinary failure results do not identify the missing prerequisite, actual setup owner or supported repair/request action. Installed resource readiness does not establish complete marketplace qualification.", "after": "The local RC is unpublished and unavailable publicly. Broad marketplace lifecycle, pending-work replacement, platforms and independent package adoption remain incomplete.", "evidence": [ "Team5419" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-09", "capability": "Executable procedures", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Bounded composed caller/pantry tasks were accepted.", "after": "Integrated unknown-outcome repair passes 6 checks. Separate cancellation/retry owner source passes 76; pending-retry amendment successor passes 78, preserving prior attempts.", "evidence": [ "Team5391", "Team5411", "Team5420" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-09", "capability": "Executable procedures", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The full configured procedure journey, installed discovery, restart/harness replacement, waits, cancellation and retry remain unqualified. A real Engine/reopened-SQLite test now reproduces the adapter incorrectly treating an unknown executor outcome as failed; its known-exit7 control passes.", "after": "Later source is absent from installed 66b. Public cancellation/retry routes, uncertainty boundaries, waits and the full procedure journey remain open.", "evidence": [ "Team5391", "Team5411", "Team5420" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "External team harnesses and native Sol delegation execute bounded assignments. Team5083 reassigned a stalled caller occurrence; Team5089 reports actual source and checks on the replacement branch.", "after": "Separate Work successor source passes 37 tests, including uniqueness, restart and exact old-key/contract recovery. This is source-only predecessor/successor context.", "evidence": [ "Team5417", "Team5420" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "An assignment or live process does not prove successful work. Automatic cross-harness activation, durable return, context and attribution remain incomplete.", "after": "Actual worker activation/disposition, authority delegation, attributable installed runs and cross-harness return remain incomplete.", "evidence": [ "Team5417", "Team5420" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Installed CLI1.0.0-dev.20261008.s007-help-candidate-tree7dc025bd now refuses project plan judge --help with exit2 and an actionable parent-query explanation. The S007 original read/restore worked with assistance. Qualified assignment helper0.1.1 is published and in use through the installed owners.", "after": "Prepared isolated Note/Plan/progress/share and CLI/MCP/Lisp reconnect pass; a distinct CLI reader confirms exact records. CF19 help source 4612b432 is public after 173 tests/subcases.", "evidence": [ "Team5416", "Team5418", "Team5419" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The installed man page still has no judge index entry. Unassisted task discovery, complete manual/examples, ordinary reconnected MCP, Linux/macOS installation and issue-tracker synchronization remain unqualified. The repository-prerequisite help correction has behavioral RED; its GREEN and the MCP identity qualification remain pending. No new top-level command or automatic permission gate is implied.", "after": "Local RC is unpublished and assisted. S007 MCP/Lisp, full manuals, macOS, tracker integration and the complete first-worker path remain unqualified.", "evidence": [ "Team5416", "Team5418", "Team5419" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Continue ordinary use of the ready installed package and resolve the held source-publication prerequisite through its owner. Keep broader lifecycle work separate from S007.", "after": "Codex B owns wider lifecycle; retain isolated install/adoption proof and complete ordinary package use.", "evidence": [ "Team5419" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-09", "capability": "Executable procedures", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "The assigned orchestration author is repairing the reproduced unknown-outcome defect tests-first, then completing durable task and managed-run contracts on the existing sidecat-orch owner. Integration preserves original attempts; this repair does not waive the full procedure outcome.", "after": "Integrate exact reviewed deltas and complete public routes plus installed cancellation/retry/recovery.", "evidence": [ "Team5391", "Team5411", "Team5420" ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-09T10:16:26Z", "scope": "Successor source and isolated installed newcomer activity; failed preparation and incomplete collaboration retained; no full outcome or public availability promotion", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-01", "capability": "Organizational context", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Guidance, named references, roles and selected working context are used.", "after": "Guidance, named references and roles are used. An isolated newcomer receives a prepared identity and ordinary organization; MCP orientation and project/Work use are observed.", "evidence": [ "Team5498", "Team5506", "Team5510" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-01", "capability": "Organizational context", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Fresh workers still need manual orientation; effective scoped semantic inheritance is not established.", "after": "Fresh orientation still exposes identifiers and misses useful project context. Scoped semantic inheritance and consistent first-contact preparation remain unfinished.", "evidence": [ "Team5498", "Team5506", "Team5510" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-02", "capability": "Identity, authority and resources", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Prepared actors, access decisions and bounded resource observations exist.", "after": "Prepared actors and owner access controls are used. Exact child-mission source passes 34 Auth cases; allowance 38, Begin/revoke 46 and settlement 67 pass in successive owner suites.", "evidence": [ "Team5433", "Team5463", "Team5472" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-02", "capability": "Identity, authority and resources", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Josh's own usable participation; reachable scoped workers; full remote allowance/delegation outcome remains incomplete.", "after": "The installed e4 trial carries the earlier allowance slice but does not activate the opt-in authority service. Later Begin/settlement are source-only; actual guarded effects, facade use and the full delegated-resource journey remain incomplete.", "evidence": [ "Team5433", "Team5463", "Team5472" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-02", "capability": "Identity, authority and resources", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Cedar owns selected identity/access and execution prerequisites.", "after": "Authority engineer owns the remaining token/executor path. Root integrates qualified successors and judges actual installed authorized effects.", "evidence": [ "Team5433", "Team5463", "Team5472" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Isolated 66b exercises native helper 0.1.1 install/adoption, Note/Work/Plan creation, progress and explicit Note/Plan sharing. A distinct CLI reader reconnects successfully. Later Work successor source passes 37 owner tests; it is not installed.", "after": "The earlier isolated Note/Work/Plan/progress/share task and distinct-reader reconnect remain exercised. The successor combines Work predecessor recovery and opt-in completion policy: 77 integrated Work events pass. A CLI newcomer retains a practical unreviewed Work result; MCP creates and updates an ordinary project and Work.", "evidence": [ "Team5444", "Team5467", "Team5494", "Team5498" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Project/application planning coherence, typed context, opted-in policy and actual worker disposition remain unfinished. Evidence is optional by default.", "after": "Kernel project/Work and application Plan coherence remains incomplete. Newcomer collaboration fails at missing target/session discovery. Full independent completion-policy, successor activation and worker-disposition journeys are still open.", "evidence": [ "Team5444", "Team5467", "Team5494", "Team5498" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Root integrates qualified deltas and owns qualification. Preserve exact retired contracts and original attempts; S007 stays unjudged.", "after": "Root owns integration and qualification. Preserve exact retired offers and attempts; keep evidence optional by default. Current participant trials are finite observations, not S007 or full-area completion.", "evidence": [ "Team5444", "Team5467", "Team5494", "Team5498" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-05", "capability": "Collective messaging", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Human entry, ordinary reply/thread/attention/return experience incomplete.", "after": "Ordinary collaborator discovery and reply remain incomplete. The CLI newcomer cannot find a colleague through message targets or current-session participants; no colleague feedback is obtained.", "evidence": [ "Team5494" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Exact helper resources install natively in the isolated Linux candidate. Its returned guide/loader supports explicit adoption and a real shared task.", "after": "Helper 0.1.1 installs and loads explicitly in the earlier isolated candidate. Successor e4 builds ten artifact stages and installs five ordinary apps;143 installed files match artifacts.", "evidence": [ "Team5484", "Team5501" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The local RC is unpublished and unavailable publicly. Broad marketplace lifecycle, pending-work replacement, platforms and independent package adoption remain incomplete.", "after": "The local RC is unpublished and unavailable publicly. Marketplace lifecycle, pending-work replacement, independent adoption and other platforms remain incomplete. Candidate user docs are supplemental; installer packaging repair is not yet GREEN.", "evidence": [ "Team5484", "Team5501" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-09", "capability": "Executable procedures", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Integrated unknown-outcome repair passes 6 checks. Separate cancellation/retry owner source passes 76; pending-retry amendment successor passes 78, preserving prior attempts.", "after": "Unknown-outcome, cancellation/retry and pending-retry repairs are integrated. Later stopped-observation source passes 80 selected owner tests; four integrated unknown/known/canceled/interrupted controls pass.", "evidence": [ "Team5495", "Team5467" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-09", "capability": "Executable procedures", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Later source is absent from installed 66b. Public cancellation/retry routes, uncertainty boundaries, waits and the full procedure journey remain open.", "after": "Native cancellation/retry routes remain missing in the separate owner trial. Its latest run also has a temporary-socket setup failure in one old control, so it is not clean RED. Full waits, recovery and installed procedure use remain open.", "evidence": [ "Team5495", "Team5467" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-09", "capability": "Executable procedures", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Integrate exact reviewed deltas and complete public routes plus installed cancellation/retry/recovery.", "after": "Orchestration engineer owns native routing and recovery; integration keeps actual uncertainty and stopped outcomes separate from success.", "evidence": [ "Team5495", "Team5467" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Separate Work successor source passes 37 tests, including uniqueness, restart and exact old-key/contract recovery. This is source-only predecessor/successor context.", "after": "Work successor source passes37 owner tests. Real manager/child activation and disposition source passes86 top-level /125 events; these patches are integrated into e4.", "evidence": [ "Team5495" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Actual worker activation/disposition, authority delegation, attributable installed runs and cross-harness return remain incomplete.", "after": "The native disposition reader is prepared and uncompiled. Public pin/read, typed Plan dispatch, cross-principal ownership, installed cancellation/retry and attributable cross-harness return remain incomplete.", "evidence": [ "Team5495" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Keep ready component owners parallel; retain the old unfinished occurrence and verify replacement results against the same Work.", "after": "Orchestration engineer owns the public reader and Plan bridge. Qualify the installed managed task independently; process-disposition source proof alone does not complete it.", "evidence": [ "Team5495" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-12", "capability": "Shared bus and federation", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Use the existing query and Content contracts for S007; no federation expansion is selected.", "after": "Linden owns application route reselection and bus/federation recovery, with an independent installed-path reviewer. Current local and finite source evidence does not qualify independently administered-node cooperation.", "evidence": [ "Team5496" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-13", "capability": "Feedback and improvement", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Operator findings and independent reviews are retained in native Team/Work. Two QA audits reproduced help, discovery, coverage-list and installed-manual gaps; Team5091/5093 preserve the findings and corrective audit.", "after": "Native findings and independent participant reports are retained unchanged. Current trials expose collaboration, documentation, orientation and output friction. A separate helper probe returns structured criticism advice with zero tool events.", "evidence": [ "Team5497" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-13", "capability": "Feedback and improvement", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "No complete current command-to-expectation-to-evidence coverage ledger was demonstrated. QA-review usefulness and comparable task costs are not established by test counts.", "after": "The helper probe is backend feasibility, not installed UI or automatic priority change. Complete feedback intake, comparable task costs, useful independent QA and accepted improvement delivery remain unfinished.", "evidence": [ "Team5497" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-13", "capability": "Feedback and improvement", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Corrective QA coverage audit underway. Rowan must assign disposition/implementation; broad all-hands QA and unfamiliar current-build trials are not complete.", "after": "Aspen owns responsive UI and retained feedback intake; Root owns the on-demand advice helper. Criticism alone does not dispatch work or reprioritize the selected outcomes.", "evidence": [ "Team5497" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Prepared isolated Note/Plan/progress/share and CLI/MCP/Lisp reconnect pass; a distinct CLI reader confirms exact records. CF19 help source 4612b432 is public after 173 tests/subcases.", "after": "Earlier prepared CLI/MCP/Lisp sharing and reconnect remain exercised. Public CLI 5211 passes195 author cases and is in e4. A CLI newcomer makes 22 calls and retains an unreviewed practical result; a medium-effort MCP newcomer makes 20 Sidecat calls for a real project/Work task.", "evidence": [ "Team5494", "Team5498", "Team5499", "Team5501", "Team5506", "Team5510" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Local RC is unpublished and assisted. S007 MCP/Lisp, full manuals, macOS, tracker integration and the complete first-worker path remain unqualified.", "after": "CLI collaboration is blocked; its first process read unrelated bootstrap instructions. MCP run 1 never reached Sidecat because of harness trust; run 2 used medium instead of required xhigh. Corrected trials are pending. User docs are supplemental, with a packaging repair12/13 passing and archive data mode still RED; macOS and wider integrations remain open.", "evidence": [ "Team5494", "Team5498", "Team5499", "Team5501", "Team5506", "Team5510" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Complete the remaining ordinary S007 surfaces and controls. Keep help delivery and coherent discovery/recovery improvements on their native corrective backlog; do not infer qualification from help test counts.", "after": "Codex B owns ordinary CLI/MCP and documentation coherence. Integration preserves each failed attempt and supplies a distinct xhigh MCP caller. No clean required newcomer or public-release claim is made.", "evidence": [ "Team5494", "Team5498", "Team5499", "Team5501", "Team5506", "Team5510" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-15", "capability": "Operational durability and scale", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "S006 retained named state and actual source observations reopened unchanged without reseeding. Component runs use bounded remote resources and source/artifact matching.", "after": "Earlier exact Notes/Plan/results survive reconnect. The e4 isolated node ends its first bounded lifetime and resumes with the same store, actors and profiles; an independent lead read recovers the newcomer result.", "evidence": [ "Team5484" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-15", "capability": "Operational durability and scale", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Bounded reopening is not full backup/recovery, multi-node contention, absent-agent or target-scale qualification.", "after": "The2m27s interruption is disclosed. This finite resume is not full backup/recovery, multi-node contention, absent-agent or target-scale qualification.", "evidence": [ "Team5484" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Aspen owns the remaining selected UI checks and operator-focused presentation/docs in a protected source tree. Preserve the actual finite trial and its limits. New source is under development; S007 stays unjudged until its remaining outcomes receive an explicit disposition.", "after": "Aspen continues the remaining selected UI checks and responsive presentation, with separate intake and ordinary-view workers. The helper probe is not an installed UI result. Preserve the finite assisted original trial; S007 remains unjudged.", "evidence": [ "Team5497" ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-10T01:25:32Z", "scope": "New source and fresh-node trials, product-area ownership and actual interruption recovery; no full-outcome promotion or release-scope change", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-01", "capability": "Organizational context", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Fresh orientation still exposes identifiers and misses useful project context. Scoped semantic inheritance and consistent first-contact preparation remain unfinished.", "after": "Prepared orientation works, but scoped inheritance and ordinary package adoption remain unfinished. The organization-context library exists in source; its retained owner suite was failing at the previous handoff. An isolated successor is under repair.", "evidence": [ "Team5623", "Team5627" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-02", "capability": "Identity, authority and resources", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The installed e4 trial carries the earlier allowance slice but does not activate the opt-in authority service. Later Begin/settlement are source-only; actual guarded effects, facade use and the full delegated-resource journey remain incomplete.", "after": "Authority components pass owner suites, but the common authority facade had five failing behaviors in the later source trial. Installed guarded effects, delegation and opt-in governance still need complete qualification.", "evidence": [ "Team5600" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Prepared assisted coordination only; general fresh-agent continuation, full docs and the separate S007 original-source MCP/Lisp task remain unqualified.", "after": "Ordinary resource-only package installation does not make its Lisp methods available. Existing trials used explicit private preparation; the selected repair extends existing REPL adoption, with context as its first consumer. General prepared composition remains unfinished.", "evidence": [ "Team5599", "Team5623" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Reuse the installed retained-result library for the remaining S007 trials. Preserve the assisted CLI limits and existing S005/S006 evidence.", "after": "Codex semantic product lead owns package adoption, scoped context and prepared composition, with a Node consumer review from Cedar. Preserve S005/S006 evidence and complete S007 ordinary entry.", "evidence": [ "Team5615", "Team5623" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Helper 0.1.1 installs and loads explicitly in the earlier isolated candidate. Successor e4 builds ten artifact stages and installs five ordinary apps;143 installed files match artifacts.", "after": "Earlier helper install/adoption remains exercised. Later isolated rc3 builds passed 13 artifact stages and installed six application bundles; 151 authored documentation files plus an index were checked. Cedar's fresh-node package trial found and repaired an empty-index response in source; its rebuilt candidate awaits installed use.", "evidence": [ "Team5593", "Team5626" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The local RC is unpublished and unavailable publicly. Marketplace lifecycle, pending-work replacement, independent adoption and other platforms remain incomplete. Candidate user docs are supplemental; installer packaging repair is not yet GREEN.", "after": "The integrated candidate and current repairs are unpublished. Marketplace lifecycle, resource-only library adoption and independent complete package use remain unfinished; new installed proof must follow the source repairs.", "evidence": [ "Team5598", "Team5599", "Team5626" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Codex B owns wider lifecycle; retain isolated install/adoption proof and complete ordinary package use.", "after": "Codex owns semantic package adoption and composition; Cedar owns Node package integration and the fresh-node package trial. Codex B is off.", "evidence": [ "Team5615", "Team5623", "Team5626" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Product capability", "before": "Semantic definitions and discovery", "after": "Semantic engine", "evidence": [ "Operator clarification: semantic discovery is one part of the engine" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Find needs supplied catalog/documents/meaning. No top-level task-to-command semantic discovery exists. Broader vocabulary/mapping/domain-authoring and ordinary S007 participant use remain unqualified.", "after": "Ordinary installation still lacks usable adoption of the context/discovery libraries, and capability catalog assembly needs repair. Meaning, types and relations, mapping, scoped context, prepared composition, assessment/explanation and discovery remain the full intended engine scope; none is waived by a narrow discovery result.", "evidence": [ "Team5599", "Team5623", "Operator semantic-engine scope" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Cedar leads the semantic engine as an agent workhorse: one owner declaration and shared ranking contract, ordinary task-find/task-do with identifiers internal by default, and explicit inspection. Marketplace and UI consume that contract. Source development and installed qualification remain separate.", "after": "Codex semantic product lead owns the full engine area. First delivery joins existing context/library code to ordinary installed adoption, followed by prepared domain tasks and independent qualification; Cedar reviews the Node boundary.", "evidence": [ "Team5615", "Team5623", "Team5627" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Work successor source passes37 owner tests. Real manager/child activation and disposition source passes86 top-level /125 events; these patches are integrated into e4.", "after": "Earlier manager/child source evidence remains. A later real child-process source trial passed application Plan and RolesAssignment handoff, immutable-context checks and completion recording; process exit is kept distinct from actual Plan completion.", "evidence": [ "Team5601" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The native disposition reader is prepared and uncompiled. Public pin/read, typed Plan dispatch, cross-principal ownership, installed cancellation/retry and attributable cross-harness return remain incomplete.", "after": "The Plan bridge source evidence is not complete installed managed work. Cross-harness returns, current-principal authority, cancellation/retry and restart recovery need integrated user-path qualification.", "evidence": [ "Team5601" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-10", "capability": "Managed agent work", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Orchestration engineer owns the public reader and Plan bridge. Qualify the installed managed task independently; process-disposition source proof alone does not complete it.", "after": "Root retains integration responsibility and coordinates the Node owner and remote-execution owner for installed managed work.", "evidence": [ "Team5615" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-12", "capability": "Shared bus and federation", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Typed owner calls and semantic query-host operations are installed on the local bus. Application permission and Content effects remain with their owners.", "after": "Local typed owner calls remain installed. Cedar's fresh-node federation trial executed commands from one node on another. Linden reports completed subscription, local two-node and route-reselection runs; a separate bus check failed.", "evidence": [ "Team5606", "Team5625" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-12", "capability": "Shared bus and federation", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Independently administered-node cooperation, durable subscriptions and gap/recovery qualification remain incomplete.", "after": "Cross-node Work dispatch failed in the fresh-node trial; successor nodes are prepared but its final demonstration is pending. Local bus runs do not establish independently administered-node recovery or full durable subscription behavior.", "evidence": [ "Team5606", "Team5625", "Team5626" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-12", "capability": "Shared bus and federation", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Linden owns application route reselection and bus/federation recovery, with an independent installed-path reviewer. Current local and finite source evidence does not qualify independently administered-node cooperation.", "after": "Linden owns local bus and application coordination; Aspen owns federation and remote execution. Cedar is transferring its existing federation work after one bounded demonstration. Each owner retains its own full development and QA cycle.", "evidence": [ "Team5615", "Team5625", "Team5626" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-13", "capability": "Feedback and improvement", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Aspen owns responsive UI and retained feedback intake; Root owns the on-demand advice helper. Criticism alone does not dispatch work or reprioritize the selected outcomes.", "after": "Cedar owns the responsive operator interface and retained feedback intake alongside Node. Root aligns priorities and release decisions. The separate QA guide has a first research unit; it is not yet a usable manual or completed QA cycle.", "evidence": [ "Team5615", "Team5622" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Earlier prepared CLI/MCP/Lisp sharing and reconnect remain exercised. Public CLI 5211 passes195 author cases and is in e4. A CLI newcomer makes 22 calls and retains an unreviewed practical result; a medium-effort MCP newcomer makes 20 Sidecat calls for a real project/Work task.", "after": "Prepared CLI/MCP/Lisp use remains exercised. rc3 includes installed authored documentation. Cedar's installer repair passed 99 source tests and a fresh Ubuntu installation, rerun, root refusal and restart. Fresh-node REPL/package trials have additional source fixes and are still running.", "evidence": [ "Team5593", "Team5609", "Team5626" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "CLI collaboration is blocked; its first process read unrelated bootstrap instructions. MCP run 1 never reached Sidecat because of harness trust; run 2 used medium instead of required xhigh. Corrected trials are pending. User docs are supplemental, with a packaging repair12/13 passing and archive data mode still RED; macOS and wider integrations remain open.", "after": "Installer and later journey repairs are not published; macOS validation and release/documentation version consistency remain open. Actual MCP input-schema and marketplace reference failures were identified. Installed package adoption and coherent ordinary use remain unfinished.", "evidence": [ "Team5598", "Team5599", "Team5609", "Team5626" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Codex B owns ordinary CLI/MCP and documentation coherence. Integration preserves each failed attempt and supplies a distinct xhigh MCP caller. No clean required newcomer or public-release claim is made.", "after": "Cedar owns Node/CLI, installer and fresh-node REPL/package trials; Codex owns semantic/common-task integration and release review. Codex B is off.", "evidence": [ "Team5615", "Team5626" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-15", "capability": "Operational durability and scale", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Earlier exact Notes/Plan/results survive reconnect. The e4 isolated node ends its first bounded lifetime and resumes with the same store, actors and profiles; an independent lead read recovers the newcomer result.", "after": "Retained records survive earlier node reconnect trials. After a real desktop out-of-memory interruption at19:01 MDT, the heartbeat restored Root's original thread at19:15. Root then manually resumed Claude, Grok and Cursor from retained conversations; completed remote jobs were not replayed.", "evidence": [ "Team5619", "Team5620", "Team5625", "Team5626", "Team5628" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-15", "capability": "Operational durability and scale", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The2m27s interruption is disclosed. This finite resume is not full backup/recovery, multi-node contention, absent-agent or target-scale qualification.", "after": "Root restart is observed, but the other primary harnesses required manual recovery. Whole-team automatic recovery, backup restoration, contention and target-scale qualification remain unfinished. Resource pressure caused a real interruption.", "evidence": [ "Team5628" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-15", "capability": "Operational durability and scale", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "S007 new typed cold restoration remains pending. Keep broader durability and scale outcomes incomplete.", "after": "Cedar retains recovery engineering and Node durability; Aspen owns the hourly coordination reminder. Root monitors resources and qualifies recovery behavior. Existing S007 restoration and broader durability obligations remain.", "evidence": [ "Team5615", "Team5628" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Aspen continues the remaining selected UI checks and responsive presentation, with separate intake and ordinary-view workers. The helper probe is not an installed UI result. Preserve the finite assisted original trial; S007 remains unjudged.", "after": "Cedar now owns Node and SidecatUI together, including caching, responsiveness and useful operator interaction. Its UI takeover child is mapping the existing implementation and building a first useful slice. Previous finite S007 evidence stands; no new UI completion is claimed.", "evidence": [ "Team5615", "Team5626" ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-10T04:32:35.434Z", "scope": "Ordinary installed context/package journey and actual UI rollback; no full-outcome promotion or release-scope change", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-01", "capability": "Organizational context", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Guidance, named references and roles are used. An isolated newcomer receives a prepared identity and ordinary organization; MCP orientation and project/Work use are observed.", "after": "Guidance, references and roles are used. An independent newcomer installed a prepared context edition, selected two actual owner inputs, created Work/Plan and reopened the same original versions by a human task title. Ordinary views kept identifiers internal. Context controls passed22/22; the repaired pin path passed11/11 installed checks.", "evidence": [ "Team5677", "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-01", "capability": "Organizational context", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Prepared orientation works, but scoped inheritance and ordinary package adoption remain unfinished. The organization-context library exists in source; its retained owner suite was failing at the previous handoff. An isolated successor is under repair.", "after": "The finite context journey is exercised on an isolated candidate. Native scope membership, read-without-revise and native Plan repin/supersedes remain open; public default availability and wider inheritance need integrated qualification.", "evidence": [ "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-01", "capability": "Organizational context", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Improve the context needed for task continuation.", "after": "The semantic owner continues full context and engine work. Integrate the usable prepared edition and finish the selected S007 whole-task/UI return; completed newcomer checks recur only when a relevant change warrants it.", "evidence": [ "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Installed helper 0.1.1 loads explicitly into a named Lisp environment with zero owner calls. Assignment/progress/sharing and fresh Lisp/MCP reads preserve exact Notes and Plan; prior S005/S006 evidence stands.", "after": "Earlier retained-helper evidence stands. Core78b4b655 lets a resource-only package return its literal adoption command and expose six exports in default main. Independent useful execution and exact source reopen passed3/3 return checks and16/16 final assertions. A separate actual mixed library trial preserved scratch while adopting four request maps and two methods.", "evidence": [ "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Ordinary resource-only package installation does not make its Lisp methods available. Existing trials used explicit private preparation; the selected repair extends existing REPL adoption, with context as its first consumer. General prepared composition remains unfinished.", "after": "Ordinary adoption works for the tested six-export edition. General heterogeneous composition, macro/unsupported capture adoption and per-value public origin remain unfinished. The mixed pantry trial is resource-only; native Records/stock effects, full SDK traversal and public release remain open.", "evidence": [ "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Earlier helper install/adoption remains exercised. Later isolated rc3 builds passed 13 artifact stages and installed six application bundles; 151 authored documentation files plus an index were checked. Cedar's fresh-node package trial found and repaired an empty-index response in source; its rebuilt candidate awaits installed use.", "after": "Earlier helper and six-app candidate install evidence stands. A genuine prepared context package with ten resources, sixteen owner schema documents and six exports passes independent ordinary install, returned adoption and useful execution/reopen. Cedar's separate marketplace/package repairs remain local and are in round2 qualification.", "evidence": [ "Team5682", "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The integrated candidate and current repairs are unpublished. Marketplace lifecycle, resource-only library adoption and independent complete package use remain unfinished; new installed proof must follow the source repairs.", "after": "The exercised prepared edition and Node repairs are not a published default release. Wider marketplace publication/discovery/replacement lifecycle and independent complete package use remain unfinished; the finite context-package result does not qualify all packages.", "evidence": [ "Team5682", "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "The standalone engine and read-only semantic assessment host are implemented. Host 0.2.0 is installed; actual Find ambiguity/single-source and selected-source Check controls were observed. S006 exercised one real original-source selection/read.", "after": "The engine and read-only assessment host exist. A genuine catalog/prepared edition carries actual assessment0.3 owner descriptors, schemas and context methods. Independent ordinary install/adoption, plain-language discovery, context execution and title-based source return passed. Pin preservation passes47 source and11 installed cases; kept source changes only with explicit adoption.", "evidence": [ "Team5677", "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Ordinary installation still lacks usable adoption of the context/discovery libraries, and capability catalog assembly needs repair. Meaning, types and relations, mapping, scoped context, prepared composition, assessment/explanation and discovery remain the full intended engine scope; none is waived by a narrow discovery result.", "after": "The tested context/composition path is exercised. Full meaning/type/relation publication and adoption, mapping catalogs, heterogeneous assessment and explanation remain incomplete. Broad collection misclassifies source-declared names absent from a smaller node's application list; Team5678 corrects the earlier false-advertisement attribution. Native Records, complete S007 UI and public default delivery remain open.", "evidence": [ "Team5678", "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Codex semantic product lead owns the full engine area. First delivery joins existing context/library code to ordinary installed adoption, followed by prepared domain tasks and independent qualification; Cedar reviews the Node boundary.", "after": "Codex's semantic product lead owns the full engine area with two author/independent-test children. The first installed context edition passed; integrate the exact candidate with Cedar's Node successors and continue broader domain composition. Full remote traversal has no terminal whole-suite verdict yet.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5688" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Prepared CLI/MCP/Lisp use remains exercised. rc3 includes installed authored documentation. Cedar's installer repair passed 99 source tests and a fresh Ubuntu installation, rerun, root refusal and restart. Fresh-node REPL/package trials have additional source fixes and are still running.", "after": "Prepared CLI/MCP/Lisp use remains exercised. The context edition's ordinary installation, returned adoption, default dispatcher/direct parity and CLI/MCP/Lisp return checks passed on an isolated candidate. Cedar's reconciled installer successor d9b05560c and round2 REPL/package journeys are under independent review; earlier Ubuntu evidence remains.", "evidence": [ "Team5682", "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-14", "capability": "Usable interfaces and integrations", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Installer and later journey repairs are not published; macOS validation and release/documentation version consistency remain open. Actual MCP input-schema and marketplace reference failures were identified. Installed package adoption and coherent ordinary use remain unfinished.", "after": "Installer, REPL/package successors and the semantic candidate remain unpublished as a matched default. Full daemon/CLI/surface traversal is incomplete; coherent public help/manual/package behavior, macOS and broader integrations remain open. Finite parity checks do not qualify the full command surface.", "evidence": [ "Team5682", "Team5684" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-15", "capability": "Operational durability and scale", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Root restart is observed, but the other primary harnesses required manual recovery. Whole-team automatic recovery, backup restoration, contention and target-scale qualification remain unfinished. Resource pressure caused a real interruption.", "after": "Root's original-thread recovery is observed, but other primary recovery required manual action. The existing monitor detected federation idle for ten checks without acting; a guarded owner-wake correction is assigned, not delivered. Whole-team recovery, verified backup restore, contention and scale remain unfinished.", "evidence": [ "Team5682", "Team5686", "Team5688" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Installed UI73fd6b52/gateway47cc6535 exercised the selected S007 task: capital context input and first query character were retained; three viewport captures matched the complete1518-character original after viewport normalization; same-task Back/reopen retained it. Switching tasks cleared the old source and the earlier lot stayed honestly missing/invalidated.", "after": "Earlier finite S007 retained-source/UI evidence stands. A new published Boards build passed its source gates but dropped five installed retained-source behaviors. Cedar restored the prior default at21:59MDT; the new build remains side by side. Three-way merge and independent installed retest are underway.", "evidence": [ "Team5682" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The finite trial used a prepared actor and assistance. Boards completion/prerequisite transition, refresh during a pending selection switch, denied original, reconnected MCP/Lisp and the complete operator goals/conversation/authorized-decision/usage path remain unqualified. External human review is not a release prerequisite.", "after": "The UI regression omitted displayed-proposal binding/refusal, task-change context clearing, Shift input, task breadcrumb and footer. Their unpublished predecessor source must be merged and published with Boards. Broader responsiveness, feedback, conversation, authorized decisions and useful current usage remain unqualified.", "evidence": [ "Team5682" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-16", "capability": "Sidecat UI", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Cedar now owns Node and SidecatUI together, including caching, responsiveness and useful operator interaction. Its UI takeover child is mapping the existing implementation and building a first useful slice. Previous finite S007 evidence stands; no new UI completion is claimed.", "after": "Cedar owns Node/UI together and is merging the exact S007 predecessor with published Boards, preserving unrelated owner work. Ship and test the resulting matched source/default; source gates alone do not qualify the operator path.", "evidence": [ "Team5682", "Team5688" ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-10T05:53:15.444Z", "scope": "Native installed capability acceptance and terminal daemon evidence through Team5714; human qualification is outside agent completion scope", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-01", "capability": "Organizational context", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Guidance, references and roles are used. An independent newcomer installed a prepared context edition, selected two actual owner inputs, created Work/Plan and reopened the same original versions by a human task title. Ordinary views kept identifiers internal. Context controls passed22/22; the repaired pin path passed11/11 installed checks.", "after": "Installed prepared context is independently qualified for the tested six-export edition: an ordinary newcomer installs and explicitly adopts it, selects two owner inputs, creates Work/Plan and returns after reopen by task title. Exact original input pins survive omitted updates; source checks47/47 and installed pin checks11/11 passed.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5696", "Team5712", "Team5714" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-01", "capability": "Organizational context", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The finite context journey is exercised on an isolated candidate. Native scope membership, read-without-revise and native Plan repin/supersedes remain open; public default availability and wider inheritance need integrated qualification.", "after": "This qualification covers the prepared context edition, not all organizational context. Native scope membership, read-without-revise, native Plan repin/supersedes, broader inheritance and the public default remain open.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5696", "Team5712", "Team5714" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-01", "capability": "Organizational context", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "The semantic owner continues full context and engine work. Integrate the usable prepared edition and finish the selected S007 whole-task/UI return; completed newcomer checks recur only when a relevant change warrants it.", "after": "Integrate the accepted context edition with Cedar's Node successors. Continue the broader context and semantic responsibilities without repeating completed trials unless changed behavior requires it.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5696", "Team5712", "Team5714" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Earlier retained-helper evidence stands. Core78b4b655 lets a resource-only package return its literal adoption command and expose six exports in default main. Independent useful execution and exact source reopen passed3/3 return checks and16/16 final assertions. A separate actual mixed library trial preserved scratch while adopting four request maps and two methods.", "after": "Explicit installed package-library adoption is independently qualified for the prepared six-export edition. Ordinary install/adopt/find/do/reopen/title-return passed3 selection/return and16 final assertions; all four adoption roots and seven supplemental owner refusal/origin outcomes passed the completed daemon traversal.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5696", "Team5712", "Team5714" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-06", "capability": "Lisp and composition", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Ordinary adoption works for the tested six-export edition. General heterogeneous composition, macro/unsupported capture adoption and per-value public origin remain unfinished. The mixed pantry trial is resource-only; native Records/stock effects, full SDK traversal and public release remain open.", "after": "General heterogeneous composition, macro/unsupported capture adoption and per-value public origin remain unfinished. Native Records/stock effects and default-release delivery are open. The completed daemon traversal has three receiving-grant failures and two unqualified skips; it is not whole-suite GREEN.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5696", "Team5712", "Team5714" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Earlier helper and six-app candidate install evidence stands. A genuine prepared context package with ten resources, sixteen owner schema documents and six exports passes independent ordinary install, returned adoption and useful execution/reopen. Cedar's separate marketplace/package repairs remain local and are in round2 qualification.", "after": "The prepared context package is accepted as a usable installed capability: ten resources, sixteen owner schema documents and six exports support independent normal installation, explicit adoption and useful execution/reopen. Combined package source e59563a138096736d1678cbb734a95634ce27249 preserves both reviewed heads and matches exact tree5cff10c0477943314c8996bea96d9bdcc9d59194.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5696", "Team5712", "Team5714" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The exercised prepared edition and Node repairs are not a published default release. Wider marketplace publication/discovery/replacement lifecycle and independent complete package use remain unfinished; the finite context-package result does not qualify all packages.", "after": "The qualified prepared edition is not yet a published default. Wider marketplace publication/discovery/replacement and other package lifecycles remain unfinished. Cedar owns the combined Node/package delivery; acceptance of this edition does not qualify all packages.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5696", "Team5712", "Team5714" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "The engine and read-only assessment host exist. A genuine catalog/prepared edition carries actual assessment0.3 owner descriptors, schemas and context methods. Independent ordinary install/adoption, plain-language discovery, context execution and title-based source return passed. Pin preservation passes47 source and11 installed cases; kept source changes only with explicit adoption.", "after": "The engine and assessment host support a qualified prepared context/package workflow: actual owner descriptors and schemas, plain-language task discovery, context execution and exact title-based return. Keep this useful capability distinct from the full semantic engine's wider meaning/type/relation, mapping, analysis and composition responsibilities.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5696", "Team5712", "Team5714" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Codex's semantic product lead owns the full engine area with two author/independent-test children. The first installed context edition passed; integrate the exact candidate with Cedar's Node successors and continue broader domain composition. Full remote traversal has no terminal whole-suite verdict yet.", "after": "Semantic lead retains full engine ownership with two active children. Terminal review07:1041 passed top-level roots, three organization-read receiving-grant failures, two unqualified skips and no timeout/unfinished cases. All adoption roots passed. The three failures reproduce on untouched ef49; Cedar/Aspen own repair. Combined Node and public default delivery remain pending.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5696", "Team5712", "Team5714" ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-10T08:13:49.236Z", "scope": "Second independently qualified installed capability accepted at Team5747; wider engine and default delivery remain incomplete", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "The engine and assessment host support a qualified prepared context/package workflow: actual owner descriptors and schemas, plain-language task discovery, context execution and exact title-based return. Keep this useful capability distinct from the full semantic engine's wider meaning/type/relation, mapping, analysis and composition responsibilities.", "after": "Two installed workflows are independently qualified: prepared context/package use and supplied-source semantic assessment 0.4. The latter assesses exact source branches, typed meanings, mappings, annotations and constraints; CLI, MCP/Lisp and direct Check agree. Undeclared meaning stays unknown, ambiguity remains visible and denied original reads remain denied after cached return.", "evidence": [ "Team5747" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "The tested context/composition path is exercised. Full meaning/type/relation publication and adoption, mapping catalogs, heterogeneous assessment and explanation remain incomplete. Broad collection misclassifies source-declared names absent from a smaller node's application list; Team5678 corrects the earlier false-advertisement attribution. Native Records, complete S007 UI and public default delivery remain open.", "after": "Assessment 0.4 qualification uses genuine Content declarations, closure and reads with QA-authored lot/policy/vocabulary/mapping inputs. Inherited meaning-source integration, retained caller replacement, publication/adoption of meaning catalogs, wider heterogeneous composition, native Records, complete S007 UI and public default delivery remain incomplete.", "evidence": [ "Team5747" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Semantic lead retains full engine ownership with two active children. Terminal review07:1041 passed top-level roots, three organization-read receiving-grant failures, two unqualified skips and no timeout/unfinished cases. All adoption roots passed. The three failures reproduce on untouched ef49; Cedar/Aspen own repair. Combined Node and public default delivery remain pending.", "after": "Semantic owner accepted installed assessment 0.4 at Team5747 after 38/38 independent assertions over 68 receipts and separate owner checks. Cedar can integrate reviewed source b4f4f8d4addff4b28131dd2f6439b8b1a32300f4 and its bundle without another permission gate. Two semantic children continue retained-caller review and inherited meaning-source integration. Earlier review07 had 1041 passing roots and three receiving-grant failures; source repair is separate from installed/default qualification.", "evidence": [ "Team5747" ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-10T10:05:29.336Z", "scope": "Third bounded installed capability: opt-in completion independently qualified; broader governance and default delivery remain incomplete", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "The earlier isolated Note/Work/Plan/progress/share task and distinct-reader reconnect remain exercised. The successor combines Work predecessor recovery and opt-in completion policy: 77 integrated Work events pass. A CLI newcomer retains a practical unreviewed Work result; MCP creates and updates an ordinary project and Work.", "after": "The earlier Note/Work/Plan/progress/share and reconnect workflows remain exercised. Installed opt-in Plan completion is independently qualified with genuine Notes and three authenticated actors: requirements, reviewer approval, current-access staleness, preserved accepted detail and explicit waiver. Ordinary unbound completion remains available; fresh CLI and MCP detail agree.", "evidence": [ "Team5797" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Kernel project/Work and application Plan coherence remains incomplete. Newcomer collaboration fails at missing target/session discovery. Full independent completion-policy, successor activation and worker-disposition journeys are still open.", "after": "Kernel project/Work and application Plan coherence, unfamiliar participant discovery and evidence preparation without routine ID plumbing, remaining policy/candidate scope scenarios, actual scrum capability-analysis enrollment, successor activation and worker disposition remain incomplete. The qualified installed completion mechanism is not yet a public default delivery.", "evidence": [ "Team5797" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Root owns integration and qualification. Preserve exact retired offers and attempts; keep evidence optional by default. Current participant trials are finite observations, not S007 or full-area completion.", "after": "Root owns integration and qualification. Team5797 accepts the controlled installed completion workflow after independent review: 49 behavioral assertions within 141 checks, with setup and transport counted separately. Broader governance Plan remains underway and unjudged. Keep enrollment optional; human qualification is outside agent delivery.", "evidence": [ "Team5797" ] } ] }, { "at": "2026-10-10T13:12:51.334947654Z", "scope": "Extend two qualified installed capabilities; assign complete marketplace ownership without claiming acknowledgement or implementation", "changes": [ { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "The earlier Note/Work/Plan/progress/share and reconnect workflows remain exercised. Installed opt-in Plan completion is independently qualified with genuine Notes and three authenticated actors: requirements, reviewer approval, current-access staleness, preserved accepted detail and explicit waiver. Ordinary unbound completion remains available; fresh CLI and MCP detail agree.", "after": "The earlier Note/Work/Plan/progress/share and reconnect workflows remain exercised. Installed opt-in Plan completion is independently qualified with genuine Notes and three authenticated actors. The extension verifies producer, binder and reviewer scope, a deliberately selected new occurrence for a changed candidate, rejection of previous approval, and preserved accepted detail. Ordinary unbound completion remains available; fresh CLI and MCP detail agree.", "evidence": [ "Team5897" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Kernel project/Work and application Plan coherence, unfamiliar participant discovery and evidence preparation without routine ID plumbing, remaining policy/candidate scope scenarios, actual scrum capability-analysis enrollment, successor activation and worker disposition remain incomplete. The qualified installed completion mechanism is not yet a public default delivery.", "after": "Kernel project/Work and application Plan coherence, unfamiliar participant discovery and evidence preparation without routine ID plumbing, actual scrum capability-analysis enrollment, successor activation and worker disposition remain incomplete. Candidate renewal uses a new occurrence of the same Work; in-place candidate rebinding is intentionally refused. The qualified completion mechanism is not yet a public default delivery.", "evidence": [ "Team5897" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-04", "capability": "Work and planning", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Root owns integration and qualification. Team5797 accepts the controlled installed completion workflow after independent review: 49 behavioral assertions within 141 checks, with setup and transport counted separately. Broader governance Plan remains underway and unjudged. Keep enrollment optional; human qualification is outside agent delivery.", "after": "Root owns integration and qualification. The original 49 behavioral assertions within141 checks stand. Team5897 records an independently accepted extension:29 behavioral assertions,29 successful calls and16 fresh scope/contract checks. Seven actual refusals were inspected. Broader governance Plan remains underway and unjudged; enrollment stays optional and human qualification is outside agent delivery.", "evidence": [ "Team5897" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Existing implementation or use", "before": "Two installed workflows are independently qualified: prepared context/package use and supplied-source semantic assessment 0.4. The latter assesses exact source branches, typed meanings, mappings, annotations and constraints; CLI, MCP/Lisp and direct Check agree. Undeclared meaning stays unknown, ambiguity remains visible and denied original reads remain denied after cached return.", "after": "Prepared context/package use and supplied-source semantic assessment are independently qualified within their documented boundaries. Installed assessment0.4.1 adds an ordinary named receiving-policy preview: explicitly selected finite mapping converts recorded5000 grams into the exact draft text 'Recorded net carton mass: 5 kilograms.' Missing mapping rows and undeclared conversions remain blocked or unknown. Genuine Content source reads and authored annotations are preserved.", "evidence": [ "Team5852", "Team5859", "Team5860", "Team5896", "Team5897" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Missing qualification or material gap", "before": "Assessment 0.4 qualification uses genuine Content declarations, closure and reads with QA-authored lot/policy/vocabulary/mapping inputs. Inherited meaning-source integration, retained caller replacement, publication/adoption of meaning catalogs, wider heterogeneous composition, native Records, complete S007 UI and public default delivery remain incomplete.", "after": "Assessment qualification uses genuine Content declarations, closure and reads with QA-authored policy/schema/vocabulary inputs. The new conversion is a declared finite mapping, not general arithmetic, physical measurement or a Records/action effect. Engine and Guide source successors are published; integrated Core, retained callers, complete S007 CLI/UI, broader composition and matched public default delivery remain incomplete.", "evidence": [ "Team5852", "Team5859", "Team5860", "Team5896", "Team5897" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-08", "capability": "Semantic engine", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Semantic owner accepted installed assessment 0.4 at Team5747 after 38/38 independent assertions over 68 receipts and separate owner checks. Cedar can integrate reviewed source b4f4f8d4addff4b28131dd2f6439b8b1a32300f4 and its bundle without another permission gate. Two semantic children continue retained-caller review and inherited meaning-source integration. Earlier review07 had 1041 passing roots and three receiving-grant failures; source repair is separate from installed/default qualification.", "after": "The semantic owner and two children continue the selected command-analysis increment: compare observed and alternative bindings against declared task meaning and explain preserved, lost and unknown criteria. Installed quantity0.4.1 was independently accepted at Team5852 and raw results reviewed by Root. Cedar5859 reports exact Engine/Guide source publication; Core0.4.1 remains a Node integration input. Team5860/5896 select the next increment without replacing S007 or claiming installed Compare.", "evidence": [ "Team5852", "Team5859", "Team5860", "Team5896", "Team5897" ] }, { "capability_id": "V1-07", "capability": "Marketplace and packages", "column": "Sprint disposition", "before": "Codex owns semantic package adoption and composition; Cedar owns Node package integration and the fresh-node package trial. Codex B is off.", "after": "Codex owns semantic package adoption and composition. Cedar now owns the complete packages and marketplace area under native assigned Work/Plan (Team5881/5897): publication, discovery, inspection, installation/use, replacement and self-hosted access. The existing packages-fix lane leads authoring, with independent QA within its current worker/resource cap. Cedar acknowledgement and new implementation evidence are not yet established. Codex B remains off.", "evidence": [ "Team5881", "Team5897" ] } ] } ], "sources": [ "s004-capability-maturity", "s005-capability-maturity", "s006-capability-maturity", "version-1-contract", "version-1-development", "Team5083", "Team5089", "Team5091", "Team5092", "Team5093", "Team5159", "Team5162", "Team5156", "Team5158", "Team5161", "Team5163", "Team5166", "Team5320", "Team5333", "Team5341", "Team5339", "Team5345", "Team5362", "Team5365", "Team5366", "Team5417", "Team5418", "Team5419", "Team5391", "Team5411", "Team5420", "Team5416", "Team5433", "Team5444", "Team5463", "Team5467", "Team5472", "Team5484", "Team5494", "Team5495", "Team5497", "Team5498", "Team5499", "Team5500", "Team5501", "Team5510", "Team5506", "Team5593", "Team5598", "Team5599", "Team5600", "Team5601", "Team5606", "Team5609", "Team5615", "Team5619", "Team5620", "Team5622", "Team5623", "Team5625", "Team5626", "Team5627", "Team5628", "Team5677", "Team5684", "Team5682", "Team5678", "Team5688", "Team5686", "Team5696", "Team5712", "Team5714", "Team5747", "Team5797", "Team5852", "Team5859", "Team5860", "Team5865", "Team5881", "Team5896", "Team5897" ], "limits": [ "All16 full outcomes incomplete", "This report is not an execution queue or a new full QA verdict", "This report records installed opt-in completion qualification; it neither enrolls our scrum nor establishes full governance compliance.", "S004 selected-boundary acceptance remains unqualified; no unchanged cell is silently promoted" ], "qualification_policy": "Agents qualify documented installed boundaries and independently test them. Operator/client human qualification occurs after handoff and is not a completion prerequisite. A candidate, source publication and released default are reported separately.", "qualified_capabilities": [ { "id": "prepared-context-package", "name": "Install and explicitly adopt a prepared context package, perform useful work and recover exact pinned inputs by task title", "state": "Qualified", "coverage": [ "V1-01", "V1-06", "V1-07", "V1-08" ], "boundary": "Tested resource-only six-export edition on the isolated installed candidate; no claim of full semantic engine, general marketplace or public default delivery.", "evidence": [ "Team5684", "Team5696", "Team5714" ], "independent_test": "3 selection/return checks,16 final assertions,11 installed pin checks; four adoption roots and seven supplemental outcomes in completed review07", "remaining_delivery": "Cedar combined Node/package publication and matched default installation" }, { "id": "supplied-source-semantic-assessment", "name": "Assess supplied source meanings, mappings and constraints, inspect uncertainty and recover permitted originals", "state": "Qualified", "coverage": [ "V1-08" ], "boundary": "Installed assessment0.4.1 with an ordinary named receiving-policy entry and genuine Content source reads. Explicit finite mapping previews5000 grams as5 kilograms;6000 has no declared row and remains incomplete, and direct5000 without mapping remains incompatible. This does not qualify general arithmetic, physical measurement, Records/action effects, complete S007/UI or default release.", "evidence": [ "Team5747", "Team5852", "Team5859", "Team5897" ], "independent_test": "38/38 independent assertions over 68 original receipts; transport parity, exact branches, explicit mappings, ambiguity, absent semantics, negative inputs, cached denial and reopen checked; owner independently reviewed the returned manifest. Extension: independently inspected compiled Engine controls and actual ordinary named-policy, missing-row and direct-check replies; Root verified20 raw files against the manifest and the production diff.", "remaining_delivery": "Integrated Node/Core0.4.1, retained caller replacement and matched public default delivery; wider semantic responsibilities remain active." }, { "id": "opt-in-plan-completion", "name": "Enroll a Plan in optional completion requirements, evaluate real evidence and authorized review, and complete or explicitly waive with preserved accepted detail", "state": "Qualified", "coverage": [ "V1-04" ], "boundary": "Controlled installed journey with genuine Notes and three distinct authenticated actors; source and actual replies independently reviewed. Extended candidate and actor scope are qualified using a deliberately selected new Plan occurrence of the same Work, not in-place rebinding. No claim of unfamiliar participant discovery, external-shell enforcement or public/default delivery.", "evidence": [ "Team5797", "Team5897" ], "independent_test": "49 behavioral assertions in 141 checks; separate actor scopes, reviewer approval, missing/stale/refused/unknown/not_run/failed cases, explicit waiver, unbound control and fresh CLI/MCP parity. Independent reviewer inspected raw results and final supplement. Extension:29 behavioral assertions,29 successful calls and16 fresh scope/contract checks; actual wrong producer/binder/reviewer, changed-policy, previous-observation and previous-approval refusals inspected. Previous occurrence remains not_completed; new authorized approval completes only the new occurrence.", "remaining_delivery": "Broader governance acceptance scenarios and ordinary participant preparation; matched Node/public default release" } ] }